favorite algae eater

what is your favorite algae eater

  • pleco

    Votes: 62 32.1%

  • otto

    Votes: 66 34.2%

  • snail

    Votes: 21 10.9%

  • other

    Votes: 44 22.8%
  • Total voters
    193
i love plecos.. and its sad that i cant house em....

hey do clown loaches count as bottom feeders? i like em too :cool:
 
I have to go with Bristlenoses! They definetly keep my tank cleaner than anything else I have ever had by far! Well, that and they are so cute...in a gargoyle looking sense.
Charity
 
CJC said:
I have to go with Bristlenoses! They definetly keep my tank cleaner than anything else I have ever had by far! Well, that and they are so cute...in a gargoyle looking sense.
Charity
Click to expand...
Did you see my avatar? That was my bristlenose till he died 3 weeks ago. :(
 
Isn't it true that simease algae eaters only eat algae when they are baby/youth and then after that they become a bit aggressive and demand other foods
 
jasonskillz said:
n wtf is an otto :huh: :huh: :huh:
i search it n nothing show :read: :huh:
Click to expand...
Otocinclus affinis.

I voted for these as I've got five of them. They school around and do a nice job w/ algae.

I'd love to try a true SAE if I could ever find one in my locale. They're legendary.
GUYZY said:
Isn't it true that simease algae eaters only eat algae when they are baby/youth and then after that they become a bit aggressive and demand other foods
Click to expand...
That would be the Chinese algae eater (CAE) that would be guilty of that behavior. True SAE never stop their dutiful eating of algae.

Here's a good link to tell the difference between these.

Algae Eaters

I accidentally bought some young False Siamensis (they look like true SAE, but have some vital, easily noticeable physical differences), and they are not so good at eating algae as a true SAE or the otocinclus catfish.

v/r, N-A
 
Last edited:
GUYZY said:
Isn't it true that simease algae eaters only eat algae when they are baby/youth and then after that they become a bit aggressive and demand other foods
Click to expand...

No, that would be Chinese AE's, who will eat your fish, too. (And yes, they get MORE aggressive and eat LESS algae--I wouldn't advise them from personal experience). Research to make sure you know what they look like before you go looking for a Siamese.
 
star_rider said:
I chose 'other' primarily because I like the bristlenosed catfish aka bushynosed ..generally considered a pleco(but in actuality it is a catfish)
Click to expand...

Question: how would a bristlenose fare in a Lake Malawi-geared tank with Yellow Labs and Cobalt Blues? It's freshwater, I know, and the Mbuna need a higher ph (crushed coral in mine) and Rift Lake Salts (more minerals than actual salt)? I'm intrigued by all the good comments about them, but am not personally familiar with them (not really found in my region). Thanks!! :D
 
I would have to go with snails...They have such cute faces! If taken care of properly they are very active. I have 3 different colors in my 10g. An ivory, a blue and a yellow. So many colors to choose from as well as shell shapes. You just can't lose with snails...unless you don't like babies..but who doesnt like babies :D
 
Rosita,
generally the BN is in water in the pH range of 5.5-7.8
but they have been acclimated to higher pH.

I am not sure how well accepted they are with those tank mates..but they seem to get along with semi-agressive fish well and can tolerate breeding angels..which may not be as agressive as many cichlids but they are mean when they are spawning..and it's more than posturing..angels have been known to kill other fish..I know from personal experience that most other fish are not safe in a tank with breeding angels. especially other angels.
 
How about ottos in that same environment?? I also don't use rift salts or coral, would that make a difference?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom