feeding an orange pike

Since they are carnivourous I would try blood worms, krill, beef heart, shrimp.... anything meaty. Maybe even those sinking carnivore wafers. I wouldn't feed it feeders that may be diseased though.
 
Mine gets a diet of both cichlid staple and cichlid gold pellets, freeze dried krill, live blood worms and the occassional extra cichlid fry (whatever I have that's "overbreeding" at the moment). ;)
 
AquariaCentral.com