Fish that won't eat fry?

FeatherDuster

AC Members
Mar 24, 2007
1,028
0
0
I just finished cycling my old 5G. I plan to use it as a fry tank for my fancy guppies. However I know it will be fishless most of the time (I don't get fry often) and was wondering if there is a fish out there that won't gobble the fry. It seems sad to have a very nice functioning 5G just sitting there with nothing in it (maybe a few live plants).
 
I have a couple small cory's with my fry.. they seemed to leave them alone. I also have an apple snail with them, but I busted him eating a fry one time.. I don't know how that happened.

lol it seems crazy to think a snail could hunt a fry and eat it. Maybe it was already dead? Cory's sound like an interesting idea. I have never had any before, but I hear many people love them. Is there any particular type and amount I should get? I know I am limited on size.

Too bad betas love to gobble fry up. If that wasn't the case I would have made my sister's beta one happy fish. I personally think the tank she has is too small for him, but sadly its her fish.
 
Pygmy cories sound like a wonderful choice. Maybe three? If they do try to go after the fry I can always move them to the main 35G tank for a while. Both the tanks are in the same room. I am sure my loach would like having some bottom feeders to play with.
 
i've heard of people putting small cories in their fry tank.

And as for the snail, that owuld be okay in a fry tank too i think, it wouldnt probably be only able to feed on dead fry. Which would actually help out anyway.. but if you have egg layers make sure to get the snail out of there until they hatch, as it will finish the eggs off in seconds.
 
Actually, in my opinion, cories wouldn't be a good idea for 5 gallons. You'd need at least 2-3 of them and that's not enough swimming room for any corydoras species. Even the pygmy ones are very active and energetic and would be too boisterous for a fry tank.

My personal preference for anything smaller than 10 gallons is invertebrates. Snails and shrimp take up very little bio load and are good bottom-feeding scavengers. I've only ever seen snails prey on dead or dying fish. They're simply too slow to attack anything healthy enough to wriggle away.

Shrimp might be a little more tricky. They tend to be very picky about their water perims and can easily be over-stressed if the guppy fry pick at or chase them. They can also harass and kill weak or sick fish, eating the fins off the slower moving fry. It's not common-practice... but it's worth keeping an eye on your fish to be on the safe side.

All in all, with a healthy batch of hungry guppy fry, food falling to the bottom of the tank shouldn't be much of an issue and bottom-feeders aren't all that necessary. In fact 5 gallons for a fry tank is a bit small to be adding any other fishes... but again, that is just my personal opinion.
 
I don't think otos would be a good choice at all. They like a strong current, which wouldn't be welcome by fancy guppies, and they need a good supply of natural live algae and aren't a good fish to keep only 1 or 2 of.
 
Thanks for all the info. However I want to stay away from inverts. I have had them before and they personally don't do anything for me (its why I gave them away). And the fry won't be staying in the tank for long. 3-4 weeks at most. I have lots of hiding places in the main tank once they are old enough to handle my water currents. I also only plan to save 2 batches of guppies each year. So thats the max of 2 months out of the year for fry use.

Ah and I am not aiming specifically for a bottom feeder. Those were just the most common suggestions. I do 15% water changes with small substrate cleaning every week so food buildup isn't a concern of mine.
 
AquariaCentral.com