yeah, the stryo was pretty craggy, and then the tape kind of smoothed it out before the glass. I think at the other end I'm going to spray a mold release agent on to protect the styrofoam instead of using tape. Then it should capture the texture a bit better. I think the cement will bring back some of the "rockiness" though.
I'm a bit torn, cuz as you say, the smoothness is good for fish not hurting themselves, but doesn't look super real. We'll see how it turns out with the grout, hopefully today!
the reason i suggested grout is because if you have a good jagged rock texture in your foam, then the grout will capture that without filling in too many gaps.
cement, I found, pretty much rendered my hard worked rock texture on the foam, useless, because it filled in all the little nooks and crannies.
Grout would have maintained my pre-fabbed rock texture.
Grout, on your smooth surface, wont give much of a jagged rock texture i dont think. I could be wrong though.
Also make sure you find a grout that can handle years of being wet, without eroding away, and one that doesnt contain latex, or anything that will leech into water and kill fish.
unless you are going to epoxy the final product. in which case, thin it out using MEK (and do it properly, according to the specific directions and ratios listed by your epoxy manufacturer, in my case it would be 10:1 epoxy:MEK )apply your first coat, and let it harden for a good couple weeks, then apply a few more coats of some maybe slightly thicker epoxy.
I would advise against brushing it on, as this creates THOUSANDS of tiny air bubbles in the epoxy when you brush over rough surfaces.
I would think that pouring the epoxy on, and just being good and sloppy about it, OR loading it into an air gun, and spraying it on, would yield the best results.
your gf/wife must love you, and all the glass fibers/foam pellets that come along with you
