Harvesting Nemo

I too support the thought of farm raised fish to protect the native populations but as with all things it's not absolute. For some cultures the industry is an important part of their economy. Also look at the poor quality of fish some farms are turning out. The industry as a whole (collecting and farming) needs to step up the accountability.
 
fishypoo2 is right, would you rather the farm the fish effectively and sustainably, or cut down the rainforest and have all the fish in the water way die anyway?

I can't say for salt water fish, but FW fish are generally not harvested at an unsustainable rate. Many times, locals catch the fish using nets and similiar primitive techniques.

Also, the farming techniques used for captive bred fish may not be, in all cases, enviromentally sound.
 
Wow. What an article. If the state of Hawaii wants to regulate the industry, the first thing they need to do is up the cost of a permit. $50 bucks to go out and collect really expensive fish any which way you choose? C'mon! That's like saying, "Sure, you can have a liquor license for $50 bucks and sell anything you want, anywhere." If that were the case, bars and pubs would be more prevalent than Starbucks.

If you want to regulate an industry, the first step is to make it unavailable to just anyone. If you're serious about making money and making a living doing something, then you're going to be willing to fork over some green to do so. Plus, since it's so expensive to start up, you're going to protect your investment by conducting your business in a responsible manner. Plain and simple. This tactic might encourage more "poaching" but, on the flip-side, the state would get more money from serious fisherman that they can put into better enforcement, and I'm sure that the aquarium fishery could benefit from better enforcement of quotas and the like. Many of the numbers that the various regulatory agencies get come from the fishermen themselves and it's basically an honor system thing. Who's to say what these guys really take in? Sure, the honest ones are probably thinking about maintaining their livelyhood. But the "out for a quick buck" guys probably aren't too concerned.

I don't know. I don't want to rant. It should just be harder to obtain permission to acquire fish from the wild. It might mean more money out of pocket for you and me but, hey, fish are luxury items. Luxury costs money.
 
Harvesting wild fish isn't the evil thing it used to be. At least they are no longer using mild poisons or explosives to stun the fish before collecting and damaging everything around it.

IT needs to be more regulated, limited permit numbers, limited catch numbers, but by all means its a very good environmentally friendly way to get fish, much more so than farm raising.

On that note I might also add that farm raised SW fish are quickly becoming a much much more available thing, BUT there are many more species that are next to impossible to spawn in captivity.
 
AquariaCentral.com