I couldn't find a picture taken from above, but one from the belly will do as well; look at his pectoral and pelvic fins then compare to Jenna's pleco;
![]()
The soft tissue between the hard rays is degenerating first at the top, that's early fin rot.
His fins have never been as rounded and full as yours but I definitely see his deterioration from the first pic I posted vs the second - if this is fin rot should I be treating my tank as a whole? Thank you so much!