How many shrimps are enough?

Kissofthegorami said:
ghost shrimp do not eat algae. I don't know why everyone likes them so much. Thye are bait and they die.

Actually, I have observed them consuming hair and string algae. Besides, though largely underappreciated (largely due to their ubiquity, cheapness, and supposed delicacy [primarily a result of stressful collection and wholesale procedures]), they are just as interesting in their own right as cherry shrimp and the like.
 
RTR said:
Amanos do not eat plants. They don't have the mouth for it. Nor have I ever witnessed canabalism among them. I think that there is a bit of exaggeration going on here.

But, yes, like most algae-grazers, they will take the line of least energy expenditure and eat fishfood before doing the work of clearing the algae. But I can't blame them, I act the same way.
Have you ever starve your shrimps?
 
And yet they managed to survive? Doesn't that already ring a bell?
Anyway, I drop a piece of lectuse to feed to my Amano (algea eating), cherry, rainbow(blue), bubble bee, tiger and rhino shrimps as an alternative to algae. And they all have a great feast on the lectuse. Also, all their mouths seems to be working fine the last I checked. I also feed them zuchini, apples and peas. Err yeah, they share the same tank with my BN pleco. I've also saw them picking off a dead apistogamma, triple red (sob). I also attempted to rescue a newly introduced cherry shrimp that molted in the open, but by the time I managed to fish the amano shrimp out in my net, all I have is the amano shrimp clinging on to the cherry shrimps head.
Also, I haven't seem a tropical fish that does not practice canabalism yet ... they all eat their dad, mon, siblings and offspring (if the fit in the mouth, it's usually food, if it's dead it's definately food).

PS: "Starve", "starved" hmm, I thought they have the same meaning.
 
RTR, hate to bust your bubble, but depending on the circumstances, Amano do indeed eat healthy plants. I say this only because I have seen it with my own eyes.

I had (emphasis on the "had" part) a actual field of lobelia cardinalis, 2 ft by 9 inches wide, almost 180 individual plants. I stocked my tank with too many adult Amanos, about 1.75 per gallon (I can now only recommend 1 per gallon or 1 per 4 liters). Once they did a number on any detrius and long algaes I had in the tank, they took to scavenging for food. They do this 24/7 FYI... they're like little horses.

It took about a week, but they found the softest plant species in the tank and wiped it clean: began clipping the stems at the top, removing unwanted leaves and working their way down. I was not happy... I finally was able to catch and move enough of the shrimp to keep them from doing any more damage, but now I am left with only about 5 whole stems of lobelia.

I think they were too many, too big, too hungry and too good at their jobs. I was not supplimenting their food source, and they let me know about it. My recommendation for Amanos is around 1 per gallon, maybe even less, and let them dictate to you how many need to be in your tank. If you have to give them additional food, then you might have too many.

I know this info might make a couple of you unhappy, but I can assure you it happened, I watched 190 shrimp destroy $1000+ in plants. :( I am NOT saying it is commonplace or that it will happen to you, but it certainly did happen to me. Just a heads up.
 
LOL! I would love to see a tank with $1000.00 worth of Lobelia cardinalis.

FYI: A lettuce leaf in a tank is not a healthy plant, it is by definition a dying leaf, right? As such it is fair gane for any herbivore or algae grazer, but will be comsumed easier if frozen or blanced first.
 
RTR said:
LOL! I would love to see a tank with $1000.00 worth of Lobelia cardinalis.
.
I am confused. Lobelia cardinalis Is a Perennial.
Lobelia%20cardinalis.jpg
 
RTR said:
LOL! I would love to see a tank with $1000.00 worth of Lobelia cardinalis.

FYI: A lettuce leaf in a tank is not a healthy plant, it is by definition a dying leaf, right? As such it is fair gane for any herbivore or algae grazer, but will be comsumed easier if frozen or blanced first.
OK, how about cleaning a plate of 4" x 4" ricca carpet?
 
AquariaCentral.com