Ich Help!!!

Originally posted by paradigmcubed
I also want to know if I was right to take the blue filter pieces out of the back of the pump?

What blue filter pieces? They aren't the biofilter bed are they? The only thing that should be removed is the carbon when using such medicines as M-Green.

I have to agree with SumpinFishy - When I first started out keeping fish and used such medicines I had my hand in the tank all the time during treatment, just wash your hands. I am pretty sure that research is assuming ingestion of the chemicals.

And I know everyone everywhere is still saying put salt in the freshwater tank for ich but it really isn't all that good an idea. Many fish species are sensitive to salt (like plecos) so one should be aware of what their species' tolerances are. Also the salt works against ich by basically stressing the fish so that it exudes more of a slime coat which helps to keep new parasitic cysts from attaching while the amount of salt necessary to actually kill off the free swimming form of the parasite is too much for most freshwater fish well being. I haven't had a case of ich in quite awhile thank goodness but I would use nothing but Mardel's Coppersafe.

By the way with these M-Green based meds usually the instructions direct the treater to do waterchanges when the med regime is done and these along with the replacement of the carbon will get rid of the medicine (though it may permanently stain the tank's silicon seals green or blue.

Cheers
 
i have treated a tank containing cories (salt sensitive) and FW puffers (easily stressed) using the salt/temp method (good old iodized table salt). neither the cories nor the puffers showed any signs of stress whatsoever and the ich was successfully treated.

the salt was removed with water changes at the end of the treatment period (14 days after last visible cyst). there has been no recurrence and all fish are doing well. it works, saves on the cost of meds, done slowly and sensibly (1tsp per gallon, pre-dissolved and added over 2 days) will not harm fish like cories IME and avoids putting toxic (and carcinogenic) material in the tank.

if fish get stressed with salt, how does being immersed in a solution of toxic medication make them 'feel'? there aren't many medications that I have taken long term (and there have been a few) that didn't make me feel rough.

that said, if the salt hadn't worked I would then have tried meds.

my 2p :)

Edit: would also be keen to know which bits of the filter were removed...
 
Last edited:
I also read that the State of California recognizes that it can cause cancer.

I have noticed that lots of things cause cancer only in California. It must be related to all of the sun and collagen. Oh wait, they cause cancer too.;)
 
AquariaCentral.com