Ick in new tank, start over? And other questions...

shaunnadavies

AC Members
Sep 4, 2009
18
0
0
Hi There,

This is my first post here, and I am pretty new to aquarium care. I've had tanks before, but someone else has always cared for them. Anyways, I bought a 40 gallon and the cycling has been going great, BUT out of the 5 fish that I bought to start up the tank, one had ICK! I took it back to the store the day after I bought it. Then last night I noticed another had ICK. I'm wondering if it might be best to just take the remaining 4 fish back to the store, and crank the heat on my tank up for a few days with no fish. Will that kill the ICK? I'd like to stay away from medications and all that as much as possible as this is a new tank, and I'd hate to start messing with salts/medications if I don't need to. I am SO upset with the store that sold me the fish with ICK to begin with. I know that it's up to me to look at the health of my fish before buying, but when I returned the fish with ICK the store personnel tried blaming it on over-feeding (which I absolutely was not) and my water quality. He tested my water saying PH, Ammonia and Nitrite were all high, but I thought that I could see him sneaking extra drops of the solution into the vials. He had me buy all kinds of things to put in the water (70 dollars worth). Something didn't seem right to me, so I brought my water to two other stores, and both of them tested my water to be perfect! Ph was 6.8, only a trace of Nitrite (normal for Day 4 in a new tank), no Ammonia. The ONE issue that I do have with my water is it is too soft in our area. My understanding is that I will need to adjust this with Seachem's Alkaline Buffer (Raises PH Increases Alkalinity (KH), and because I'm adding that I'll have to use Seachem's Neutral Regulator as well (adjusts high or low ph to 7.0). Does this all sound right? Thank you for any and all help/advice. I really appreciate it.

Oh, and what test kit should I buy? The Master? It doesn't seem to have a tester for GH/KH :huh:

THANKS AGAIN!
Shaunna:dive:
 
Please help!

Particularly with my soft water problem. I'm heading to the Aquarium store shortly. :goldfish:

Not sure if I should leave these 3 fish in the tank and treat it, or just watch the fish that don't appear to have Ick (yet), or bring them back and keep the tank empty for a few days....

So confused! It's hard being a newbie :crazy:
 
I'm sorry, I'm no expert by any means but if it were me, I would take the remaining fish back and turn up the heat in my aquarium to about 85/86 degrees and leave it at that for about 10 days. Since there's no fish in it you won't have to worry about hurting them. I'm like you, I don't like using chemicals. I know absolutely nothing about soft water problems...sorry. You might want to check out the fishless cycling method, it takes a little longer but it's more humane.
 
Thank you very much for responding to my post. I am going to follow your advice, take the fish back, and crank the heat. My understanding was it only needs 4 days for the ICK to die with no host? I don't have any live plants, but there is wood in there. I was hoping that 6 days with no fish would be good enough.
 
take the fish backm tell the guy you will never buy from him again. turn up the heat and add some salt to the water. wait a week do a really big water change turn the heat down and go get some fish from someone else
 
There's no need to add salt, as the ich will die without a host anyway. But has your tank really cycled? It seems you were saying that it was tested on say 4; it could not have cycled by then.
 
do not add anything to your water that will change the chemistry of it. your water is fine.

also, you can't really blame the storekeeper for the fish with ich. often times, fish are in and out of a store before they start to show symptoms of ich, which can take up to 2 weeks.

that said, the other things you described may be poor buisness practices. there are some types of kits that require you to add drops until a color shows, but the ones such as the API master test kit will not work if there are extra drops in the vial.
 
Thank you very much for responding to my post. I am going to follow your advice, take the fish back, and crank the heat. My understanding was it only needs 4 days for the ICK to die with no host? I don't have any live plants, but there is wood in there. I was hoping that 6 days with no fish would be good enough.

You're more than welcome Shaunnadavies! :) It seems the common consensus is a week at high temp. without any host for it to attach itself to, it will die on it's own. Good Luck with your cycling and I just love your little Yorkie, she's so precious!!
 
AquariaCentral.com