and the winner is... DIY, by a mile.
I was nervous about going through the hassle of building a DIY co2 reactor so i bought the Junge thing. After wasting nearly 7 of the tabs and hating the fact that the instructions require that the chamber be placed at water level (i have an acrlyic tank with odd cut outs so this was a pain and very ugly), I decided to give the DIY a go.
My biggest complaint was that there wasn't constant co2 infusion. All of the gas is created within the first 2 minutes and then it "absorbs" into the water within the next 2-4 hours. This just doesn't sound right to me, but that is how it works. My concern was that with each water change i was removing some of the co2 that I had just put in the day before... kinda defeated teh purpose... plus the tabs run about $6-$12/month depending on the amount of coverage you have and the # of gallons.
So i went to the grocery store bought some bakers yeast and a cheap 2 liter. Drank some of the soda and then drilled a hole in the cap 2 or 3 sizes smaller than my tubing. Cut tubing at an angle and pulled it through with plyers. Air tight. I did add some sealant as an added measure. Ran a four foot tube down under my stand.
I put warm/hot water in teh 2 liter up to 3/4 full. Then I took one cup of sugar and poured it in the bottle shook it. Then I put one cup fo water in a measuring cup (for liquid) and made sure it was between 100-110F (which was easy as that was the temp of our hot water right out of tap. Added one teaspoon of yeast and gently stirred. waited five minutes and did another soft stir. Poured it in the 2 liter and screwed the lid on tight. Nothing happened right away. I am using the chamber from the jungle kit and there was a small amount of air trapped in one corner... otherwise it was full of water.
When I got up this AM, prepared for utter failure, I didn't see any bubbles. However, upon closer inspection I noticed that there was no water in the chamber... just gas. It was then that I noticed the bubbles coming (probably 2/second). Did some adjustments with teh hose and the bubbles increased. Now I have a constant 450cc of co2 in the chamber. It will burp about every fifteen minutes and some of the co2 escapes. But other than that, it works great and was super easy.
I was nervous about going through the hassle of building a DIY co2 reactor so i bought the Junge thing. After wasting nearly 7 of the tabs and hating the fact that the instructions require that the chamber be placed at water level (i have an acrlyic tank with odd cut outs so this was a pain and very ugly), I decided to give the DIY a go.
My biggest complaint was that there wasn't constant co2 infusion. All of the gas is created within the first 2 minutes and then it "absorbs" into the water within the next 2-4 hours. This just doesn't sound right to me, but that is how it works. My concern was that with each water change i was removing some of the co2 that I had just put in the day before... kinda defeated teh purpose... plus the tabs run about $6-$12/month depending on the amount of coverage you have and the # of gallons.
So i went to the grocery store bought some bakers yeast and a cheap 2 liter. Drank some of the soda and then drilled a hole in the cap 2 or 3 sizes smaller than my tubing. Cut tubing at an angle and pulled it through with plyers. Air tight. I did add some sealant as an added measure. Ran a four foot tube down under my stand.
I put warm/hot water in teh 2 liter up to 3/4 full. Then I took one cup of sugar and poured it in the bottle shook it. Then I put one cup fo water in a measuring cup (for liquid) and made sure it was between 100-110F (which was easy as that was the temp of our hot water right out of tap. Added one teaspoon of yeast and gently stirred. waited five minutes and did another soft stir. Poured it in the 2 liter and screwed the lid on tight. Nothing happened right away. I am using the chamber from the jungle kit and there was a small amount of air trapped in one corner... otherwise it was full of water.
When I got up this AM, prepared for utter failure, I didn't see any bubbles. However, upon closer inspection I noticed that there was no water in the chamber... just gas. It was then that I noticed the bubbles coming (probably 2/second). Did some adjustments with teh hose and the bubbles increased. Now I have a constant 450cc of co2 in the chamber. It will burp about every fifteen minutes and some of the co2 escapes. But other than that, it works great and was super easy.