Lights for a 180 planted tank

For starters, for your information regarding the differences between different types of bulbs, this article is rather useful:

http://www.plantedtank.net/articles/Light-Bulb-Comparison/29/



Next up is a series of post from Aquatic-Eden. There are a few of them to read, but I promise they are worth it and well written:

http://www.aquatic-eden.com/search/label/light


Within one of the blog entries from the above link, comes an article about Amano's lighting entitled "Lighting as a Function of Tank Size". You can review it here:

http://www.fitchfamily.com/lighting.html


From that we get that you should aim for about 240 watts.


And finally, my thoughts: Ultimately you get what you pay for. We all have the urge to go cheap, but the truth is, if you want a high light/high tech tank, and go cheap the first time, you'll only be replacing later down the line...at which time you will have nearly doubled your investment when if in the beggining you could have saved just a little more. Currently I use 6500k CFL's. The problem with these is that they are only about 86% efficient at getting the light to the tank, so I'm wasting 14% of my wattage. My other complaint is that they only come in color temperatures up to 6500k. I would prefer a 10000k bulb.

For these reasons, I am currently in the process of upgrading to ahsupply lights, and therefore recommend them. 4 65w would be nice for you, however:


I also have started to like how metal halides look over a tank, but I hate the way they grow plants. Therefore, when I myself upgrade to a 125g or larger, I plan to consider a combination of power compacts(such as the ahsupply kits) and metal halides. MH are expensive.

Final thought: if you want high light, go with an ahsuppy kit. If you are ok with low-med light, get some shop lights from homedepot and use the GE 9325 bulb.
 
Feafur, sorry for hijacking your thread. Have you made any decisions about what you will be using yet? I'm still up in the air...

rustygmc, thanks for letting me know about the other T5 60" retro kit supplier. These things are hard to shop for.

j_chicago, thanks for the additional links. I'm an engineer and I really appreciated the Fitch Family analysis!
 
no problem, but I think you meant to thank jmhart
 
Ok....
I'll start off by saying that I'm probably the cheapest person you've ever met! hahahha
I have this wonderful tank that I would love to plant, but I would also have
to dig deep into my wallet and I'm hoping to instead BUILD my own lighting.
Here's my question. Is there a chart somewhere that will completely explain or compare all the different types of lighting? I really just need to know how much of each type of light I would need to grow lots of luschious plants!
If anyone can help me I would appreciate it greatly!
I've seen lots of DIY lighting online and want to give it a whirl, but most of them are for smaller aquariums that don't need nearly as much light as I'm sure I'll need.
Thanks a bunch!

Overall, the A&H 4x 96 W will give you plenty of light and a good spread over this tank. Make your own wood box(Home depot has some thin light weight hardwood(semi soft: Popular or harder Oak etc)) and bolt the lamps/reflectors in there.

I think as far as cost, ease of installation, final look, effectiveness of the light, this is about the best for many aquarist looking for DIY light for a planted tank.

Space the rows at least 14-16" apart, this will give you a wide range of angels that the light will hit the plant's leaves.

I have a 180 myself, but I use the HQI metal Halides as well as PC's.
I did DIY the light rail(saved myself 300$ there) and collect my own driftwood etc.



Regards,
Tom Barr
 
AquariaCentral.com