Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

Confused card played. Well done. Someone else mentioned it being hard to keep up with the alias'. Thanks for not being a UD.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

1) You didn't say anything about the suspicions, just made a joke that implied that you thought the suspicions to be suspect, without saying why. It was funny, but didn't add anything.

2) No. I obviously read the post. Kinda. I totally skimmed, saw that someone else thought that Wiz's post was suspicious, and jumped on. Flaky.

1) You must have missed all of my posts aimed at HH before that one as I was pretty adamant that their theory and suspects (specifically me) was not well based. I would like to think I've added quite a bit to the discussion on that topic.

2) So you said you agreed with Tree's thoughts but you didn't actually read their thoughts? Interesting.

 

[Lady G]

To help us lazy people and for later reference, can you post who has not voted yet in the vote count.

Everyone else


Chupa, Uhoh, Rickets, Gunslinger, Nem, Doomsday, BadHaggis, C-note.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

So we've got 17 players still in the game and with 3 hours to go until nightfall, we have 9 votes cast. Should be either an interesting few hours, or a mass suicide of UD's...

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Of course, this has nothing to do with current stuff. Want to ask the question still so I don't forget to do so later.

I just noticed I left the "random event" off in the game mechanics...so don't forget that a random event may happen at a random time..that can reveal information to a random player, switch a witch to good/good to witch, or send a message from beyond the grave to the town.

Is there a ghost chat board where dead players can deliberate? If not any "random" message from the grave will come just from one player's viewpoint, right? If in that case, will we learn the actual source of this message if we get one?

 

[FireDancer7905]

1) You must have missed all of my posts aimed at HH before that one as I was pretty adamant that their theory and suspects (specifically me) was not well based. I would like to think I've added quite a bit to the discussion on that topic.

2) So you said you agreed with Tree's thoughts but you didn't actually read their thoughts? Interesting.

I think that you and I are going to go round and round with no good end. Up until today, when I reread and quoted as fast as I could during naptime, I've been trying to keep up with the game around my sick family and have not processed as well as I should have. Skimming does get you by when it has to.

I quoted things as I read, but I didn't quote much that had lots of other quotes already because I knew that I couldn't remember who said what about who. I think that I thought another player had been arguing with Hammer. I'll go back and reread. As to my skimming/Tree/wiz - it's what happened. I copped to skimming, I *did* explain why I think that Wiz was suspect on d1, and that's that. Not much of interest there.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

Come on.

Really ?

As for my suspect list, Nar and Fire have recently peaked my interests.

I hate when people don't know that the word is 'piqued'.

Ok so they recently piqued your interest. Why ? For Gods sake why ?

I don't like that chup is basically setting me and wing up for tomorrow, regardless of the outcome.

Ok. So is Chup one of your suspects ?

I think people are going to assume that I suspect Tree and HH, although that's not necessarily the case.

You were asked who your suspects are. Not who you think people will think you think your suspects are.

HH's case is flawed because it involves me and I know my role. I certainly do not like how sure they are on Wiz, even going so far as to name him as the boss. The arguments between Tree and I really haven't gone anywhere. I still get a feeling they aren't being candid with the town in terms of their experience, but that would be a weak way to vote. And I could see some players getting a kick out of it, even if innocent.

This has nothing to do with what you were asked.

Just for fun I will post your post in all its glory. In response to the very simply question who is on your suspect list, you said :

As for my suspect list, Nar and Fire have recently peaked my interests. I don't like that chup is basically setting me and wing up for tomorrow, regardless of the outcome. I think people are going to assume that I suspect Tree and HH, although that's not necessarily the case. HH's case is flawed because it involves me and I know my role. I certainly do not like how sure they are on Wiz, even going so far as to name him as the boss. The arguments between Tree and I really haven't gone anywhere. I still get a feeling they aren't being candid with the town in terms of their experience, but that would be a weak way to vote. And I could see some players getting a kick out of it, even if innocent.

Yikes Doomsday. Yikes.

 

[[AC] chupacabra]

I am going to wait until a little before nightfall to post a suspect list. I really want to focus on Wiz. I got sidetracked a little with Doom, but at least they were posting. I am hoping to not get killed by the witches tonight, but think it would be a good idea to post some suspects, just in case. I think the fact that Wiz is voting for me makes me more of a suspect if he comes up as a witch, which I think he will. I think now it is all about damage control for the witches. There are still lots of non-posters and low-posters. I am surprised that no one has parked a vote on one of them.

Why wait? Waiting cannot help the town. If you have other suspects a list cannot hurt, AFAIK.

Seems like I might as well get your vote now, since it doesn't even matter what Wiz is...

Hmph. The "I'm weak and gonna be voted" thing is sooooo game 50s... I plan to observe and think, not vote erratically.

Vote count:

Wizard-(8)- Hammerhead, Tree, Star, IQ, Narwhal, Scoop, Wing, Fire

Tree-(1)- Wizard

Does anyone else notice the massive train on Wiz? Anyone else feel that there are definitely some scum hiding in that train? I want to see the case on wiz, and he has been acting differently from his normal innocent game play, but I'm not getting even a single scum vibe from him. I can't say I think he's scum and vote him while still being honest with myself or others.

So, I'll continue to watch and see how events turn out. I WILL vote before nightfall though.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Sorry I wasn't here. I've been sick with the flu and still running a fever. Makes it hard to focus and clear my head. All the alias names makes catching up even more confusing.

Please bear with me a bit longer. I will NOT UD - and will participate from here on. Will be on and starting to post from now through nightfall.

Welcome back to the game. 48 hours since your previous post? Must be quite the fever...

There's quite a lot for you to catch up on so I expect some decent contributions when you return.

Honestly, I don't really know what to think of IQ at this point. I still think the timing and utter lack of content other than a vote are suspect in the two posts I referenced.. I stated before that they were strange, and I still think so, but I don't really have enouh to solidify IQ as a top suspect ATM. He's not cleared by any means, but put on the back burner for now until I see more, and other top suspects are resolved either by lynching or starting to make some sort of helpful posts.

Thank you for responding. I guess my only follow up question is why single out HI IQ for not contributing at that time when there were others popped in with votes and/or nothing of merit as well?

Why? I think Nar is scum.

See my previous post. I suspect you started following the commotion regarding Wiz a bit earlier than others have. By that I mean your D1 vote does not seem genuine. Just recently you've attempted to throw me into the mix by over analyzing a joke and completely disregarding the rest of my posts.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

For me to have any idea as to which is a witch I'd have to base that mainly on useless posts from D1. Do you think that is a good way to go about things?

As for my suspect list, Nar and Fire have recently peaked my interests. I don't like that chup is basically setting me and wing up for tomorrow, regardless of the outcome. I think people are going to assume that I suspect Tree and HH, although that's not necessarily the case. HH's case is flawed because it involves me and I know my role. I certainly do not like how sure they are on Wiz, even going so far as to name him as the boss. The arguments between Tree and I really haven't gone anywhere. I still get a feeling they aren't being candid with the town in terms of their experience, but that would be a weak way to vote. And I could see some players getting a kick out of it, even if innocent.

Earlier, you stated that me and Hammer were your top choices. I am glad you are adding other suspects. Would you consider yourself a vet or a noob? How many games does it take to be a vet vs a noob? Have I played mafia before? Can you not figure this out for yourself? Does it look like I have played before or does it look like I have not? My point, is why does it matter. I got called out for calling a player by their name, which was the wizard by the way... I need to re-read all of that. Instead of trying to figure out who I am or what I am, why not focus on what I post? The point of playing with alias' is to not have your past be held against you. As the Wiz has found out the hard way. I am sure if he could do it all over again, he would used an alias. He might even had posted that. I am Tree_Hugger, Tree for short. That is all that matters. Judge me by what I post, not my past. I keep going back and forth if you really could be a witch. If Wiz comes up witch and then you are also... I can't think of anything to say that would not look like a personal attack or come off looking obnoxious. Fill in your own blank.