Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

[[AC] RICKETS]

This is interesting to me in that you say you trust me 100%, but your actions show otherwise.

I didn't expect that to confuse you, Hammer, but let me clarify. I trust in your role and I believe the role claim is true fact. That doesn't preclude me from thinking you could make a mistake. Hell, I trust myself too but that doesn't stop me from second-guessing everything or thinking I might be making a mistake. I make mistakes all the time.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

See I just figured you for very detailed notes and saved files. Kind of cements my suspicions about who you really are. Not the kind of person to be confused about rules.

Considering every angle is good but if you're who I think you are, you acuse me of misdirection and trying to confuse the town when I consider every angle.

I agree with HH here the plan seems good and I find your resistance to it highly suspicious.

I'm not sure but I think I'm flattered. Or not?

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

I am not feeling the love here. I have done nothing to deserve this treatment. I helped vote off the head witch. I have answered all questions given to me. This reminds me of some kind of inquisition.

I can also say that letting a perfectly good suspect go almost never works out for the town. You have no case on me but idle speculation.

This post screams scum in the hot seat to me. Inquisition? Well, yes, welcome to mafia. Were you expecting otherwise?

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Solely based on the fact that there was 20 people playing, I am going to assume there was no more than 5 witches. I am also thinking it is no less than 4. I am leaning 5. I think we have 4 of them outed.

1) Wiz
2) Wing
3) Nar
4) Rick

I would be highly surprised if the living ones did anything more than post a vote and hope that a random event saves them. So I do not expect to see any posts. I am sure Rick is figuring out they messed up and will be very quiet from here on out.

So who is #5? If and only if all four of these are witches, who is number 5? I have a fairly long leaning innocent list. I think it is the largest day 3 leaning innocent group I have ever had. I also think there has been lots of damage control. I think the witches only hope is to silence hammer and discredit everyone else. They can maybe take a chance on hitting the warlock to save wing. Then we will just lynch wing the next night, plus hammer will have another investigation to report about. I am hoping Doom is investigated. I am not even sure when Doom last posted. I am sure it has not been that long ago.

You're right that I messed up, Tree, and I believe that's been fully acknowledged now. However, I see no reason to remain quiet. Why should I? Pencil me in on your suspect list. I have no problem with that.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

If HH is telling the truth then it is likely that Wing is a witch.

As for the warlock's spell a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush, there is always room for something to go amiss. The warlock may not cooperate, he might fall asleep and forget, he may get burnt at the stake tonight many things are possible. General Custer thought he had them right where he wanted them too.

As for a top three, I do really have one. I am still debating whom I should vote for.

Ummm, no. If HH is telling the truth then it is definite that Wing is a witch. Seriously, there is no reason not to believe Hammer. We even got hard evidence already that corroborates their claim when Wiz was revealed as high priest.

This post is pure BS.

I retract my vote on Doom and vote to burn Narwhal at the stake.

 

[Lady G]

LG, if a player is turned, are they allowed to share what they know with their new team. Also, if one is turned (either way), please verify that this is not optional. It is part of the game. There could be a spell that turns hammer into a witch, no matter how much they were trying to find and kill witches, hammer would have to be a witch. Would hammer be compelled to tell his new team who their partner was? If a witch gets turned, are they allowed to say who else is a witch? I like games where players get turned. I am not sure what are the rules in this game as far as turns go.

Anyone can "claim" anything they want. If someone is turned, they are for the opposite team and work with that team after they are turned. There is nothing in the rules that say what they can and can not say (some games there are). If they are from a communicating team, their communicating team will not know they have been turned. As stated, anyone can "claim" anything, it can not be confirmed by my PM to them. In other words if 10 ppl wanted to "claim" they had been the turn, they can...if 10 people wanted to "claim" they are herbalist they can, their claims will not be confirmed by any PM. It is up to everyone if they want to believe the "claim"

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

I didn't expect that to confuse you, Hammer, but let me clarify. I trust in your role and I believe the role claim is true fact. That doesn't preclude me from thinking you could make a mistake. Hell, I trust myself too but that doesn't stop me from second-guessing everything or thinking I might be making a mistake. I make mistakes all the time.

Rick, explain how a PR could make a mistake in saying that a player is a witch. I know that no one has directly asked hammer, but I have assumed that Wiz and wing were investigated and came up witch. You trust him, but he could have forgot the results of the investigation? You trust him but he could be wrong?

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

The Warlock is pro-town
Spells can not be changed, once they have happened.

It seems there is a little confusion about the rules (which is understandable) so I am going to revise a little here.

a. The priority of night time happenings is:

Herbalist's Protection
Burn at the stake
Witches death spell
Investigations
UDs

Warlock spells are to be sent to me at the on set of "day" after nightfall, they take affect once I get them, and can not be changed once sent.

You can claim whatever you want in the game, but you can't 'prove it' by posting any PMs received during the game (role assignment or otherwise).

I hope this clears up some misunderstandings. If not let me know and I will try to answer to the best of my ability.

Thanks, Lady G. LOL. :duh:

Sorry to post and dash out but I can't stay............ Still need to stay caught up as much as possible.

I'll be back well before night falls.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

My bad, Rick. I thought your vote was still on Wing when you said that. I'm a bit distracted abd I've never been one to take notes...

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Rick, explain how a PR could make a mistake in saying that a player is a witch. I know that no one has directly asked hammer, but I have assumed that Wiz and wing were investigated and came up witch. You trust him, but he could have forgot the results of the investigation? You trust him but he could be wrong?

A PR can easily make a mistake how they handle the game after role claiming. We've seen a lot of players do a great job at that and some who botched things up completely because they didn't think it through well enough.

I've said nothing to question Hammer's investigation results.