Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Actually, I think you are definitely skilled enough to pull it off...

Do you know who HH is? What are you basing his/her skill level on?

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

When this is over you will all know who was who.

 

[[AC] chupacabra]

Do you know who HH is? What are you basing his/her skill level on?

I think I could put a name on him, two names actually. he and tree could, if I'm right about their identities, pull this off without breaking a sweat. If I'm wrong, well, Wizard could pull it off too, and then they also have a mysterious 4th member, at least. Assuming that they are evil, and that at least one skilled vet is an evil with them (likely, considering how many are skilled vets) they could pull this off.

However, it's irreverent, I've been treating everyone like a hardened vet here so far.

 

[[AC] chupacabra]

Now, besides HH, what does everyone think about my idea? Do you think it has merit (assume players are both long time vets)?

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Now, besides HH, what does everyone think about my idea? Do you think it has merit (assume players are both long time vets)?

I think it's a waste of time.

 

[[AC] Star-Crossed]

Ok, I just got caught up.

Overall, I am seeing Nemesis and Doom as pro-town. I think Rickets is playing devil's advocate and trying to explore all possibilities, but I don't see him as scummy. Wing and Nar on the other hand made me lol hard. I think Chup sees the writing on the wall as well and is starting to lose it. I'd be willing to wager some cash that Haggis is the last scum.

Unless something is off with the spells, I'm all for it being used on Wing. The only question I have going forward is whether we trust wing to play innocent, even if/when turned. I think it is something to consider before it happens so we aren't stuck debating if wing is still feeding us lies because they feel loyal to their team. I understand that they wouldn't win if the scum does pull it off, but that may not change wing's mind.

This is a good point. I thought about this earlier and for me, I will not trust a thing Wing says. It wouldn't be cool of them to out their entire former team. I will be happy that they will count as a warm townie body and not a witch once they are turned. Anything they say will go in one ear and out the other for me.

I've just realized something: How exactly can a turned person fight for the town without completely screwing over the scum team? If they are turned, won't they have to tell us who the scum are? This should have been discussed in the sign up, IDK why no one else noticed it... and if I missed the way they could be townie without giving away their teammates, please do remind me.

See my thoughts above. I doubt your scummate will out you.

I hate RCing, but I do like when someone lies and FAKE Rcs.

All this time we thought you were a confused townie that got lucky with Wiz and made it possible for me and the Prophet to hide. When you turned on me it wasn't that big of a deal because now the hits were 50/50 and we didn't want to have to RC since neither of us like that aspect of the game. Unfortunately we found an innocent on Day 1. But Chupa was found as scum day 2, we tried to make it as non obvious as we could, we didn't want to go in guns blazing and I thought I could talk my way out of the lynch.

Your fake RC as herbalist is proof you are scum. The warlock should use the spell on you, if used on me I will be turned scum and there would be no protection on any townies.

Omg I lolled so hard. My dog looked at me like I was insane.

I vote burn to HH at the stake.

Wings claim has a real ring of truth to it. He makes a good solid argument, he does not display the arrogance that HH has shown. I just do not see that as the way a good player, and the leader of a town should act. Once we get HH out of the way we can work on the rest of the coven.

Again, made me lol hard. You two are a cute pair of witches.

 

[[AC] Star-Crossed]

Now, besides HH, what does everyone think about my idea? Do you think it has merit (assume players are both long time vets)?

I think it's cute you're trying to save your scummy coven.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Not a different game, just a little clueless. I'm beginning to think that the name "Captain Oblivious" fits me quite well... I'm slow on the uptake, and get hyper-focused. Not an excuse, merely my behavior. If it's worth a vote, vote me.

I did a full reread of the game. I saw C-Notes vote and it's relation to Tree's vote. If course I brought it up, and if I wasn't the first person to do so then there is nothing to be worried about there.



wow...

So, with Wing being the only confirmed evil I personally think that voting them would be the wisest thing to do. However scummy an individual is, there is no guarantee that they are evil. Wing, however, is guaranteed evil.

I vote to burn Wing Nut


Hate to be devils advocate, but if Tree and HH ARE evil... we've all been played from the start. If Wiz really was a sacrifice because he couldn't play as well as he would want, then that makes tree golden. HH RC's and says thats how he know Wiz was the HP. Then he says Wing is evil, and everyone votes them. In order to keep their cover for at least another night, Tree makes the suggestion to burn someone else and let the Warlock turn Wing. Since we all think Wing is evil, when turned (if he's innocent) he'd be a real evil, but we'd all think he's innocent. Since we voted someone who had no claims against them, HH would be able to say "I didn't know" and remain golden. Tree would still be golden as well, and Wing would be a hidden witch that could last the game until HH's cover was blown.

Thats just the way I, if evil, would play it out. And I have now scared myself. If we burn Wing tonight though, and they're innocent, we've got HH nailed, and can't be fooled by the evils a second time. So, now I say we should all vote Wing Nut and hope that HH's claim is true.

I definitely are questioning which game you're playing.

I don't honestly believe anyone who has had a serious grasp of this game missed that Tree was the very first one to vote Wiz. I also don't see how you missed Tree all but bite Wiz's head off on D2.

Cnote's vote was a topic of conversation first brought up by HH. You said that no one had even mentioned it, which is false. That is what I am worried about.

You say that wing is a confirmed evil, a guaranteed evil. But now you're indicating that you think HH may have fooled us. Which is it? Who do you actually believe, wing or HH?

 

[[AC] wing nut]

Sorry the errands took longer then expected.

Why would you and the prophet originally think that HH got lucky?

Lucky to pick out Wiz as scum. Calling him the HP we figured was justified from the way the votes fell.

Wing, why did you bring up being on the phone at work?

Because that is how I found out about the RC, the Prophet called me while I was working and we discussed what to do about it. He wanted to come out against HH but I told him to wait and let me since I'm more expendable.

wow...

So, with Wing being the only confirmed evil I personally think that voting them would be the wisest thing to do. However scummy an individual is, there is no guarantee that they are evil. Wing, however, is guaranteed evil.

I vote to burn Wing Nut


Hate to be devils advocate, but if Tree and HH ARE evil... we've all been played from the start. If Wiz really was a sacrifice because he couldn't play as well as he would want, then that makes tree golden. HH RC's and says thats how he know Wiz was the HP. Then he says Wing is evil, and everyone votes them. In order to keep their cover for at least another night, Tree makes the suggestion to burn someone else and let the Warlock turn Wing. Since we all think Wing is evil, when turned (if he's innocent) he'd be a real evil, but we'd all think he's innocent. Since we voted someone who had no claims against them, HH would be able to say "I didn't know" and remain golden. Tree would still be golden as well, and Wing would be a hidden witch that could last the game until HH's cover was blown.

Thats just the way I, if evil, would play it out. And I have now scared myself. If we burn Wing tonight though, and they're innocent, we've got HH nailed, and can't be fooled by the evils a second time. So, now I say we should all vote Wing Nut and hope that HH's claim is true.

First part I disagree with as I'm not a confirmed scum, I'm being called scum by someone who is false RCing.

I like how you,, like Tree, post your plan in the open so no one would ever think it would be true.

I have to say this is a great scum team, well played.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I vote burn to HH at the stake.

Wings claim has a real ring of truth to it. He makes a good solid argument, he does not display the arrogance that HH has shown. I just do not see that as the way a good player, and the leader of a town should act. Once we get HH out of the way we can work on the rest of the coven.

:rofl: This post is amazingly funny if you read it in Elver Fudd's voice... Especially the first sentence.

Actually, I think you are definitely skilled enough to pull it off...

Thanks dude. I appreciate the compliment, truly.
But this time, it's not so.