Because the herbalist would never come out to role claim. They would switch it to the prophet, so the herbalist could protect them. So why would someone come out as the herbalist? In this game, the herbalist can only protect a person once. Wiz truck attacked either me or hammer, as that would what most scum would do, so hammer had to be protected as I was not 100% cleared in hammers eyes at this time. So I knew that they (hammer and friend) did not protect me. So I knew hammer had been protected. Hammer knew they had been protected. The witches knew that hammer had been protected. Hammer was going to be the target of the next night, so they had to come out. The only chance hammer had of not getting hit was if the witches went for the warlock. I did my very best not to appear to be the warlock. I need to read back, I am positive that the person that suggested the warlock to come out is a witch.