Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

Wowie - drama.

Chup...disappointing play.

My view on the Rickets and wing dialogue is that it has the ring of truth to it. As to whether we burn or turn, given the option, I don't know yet. My inclination on the maths is to turn, but we don't really know whether BH will play in the spirit of the game to try and win the game with the town. This is all based on Rickets in fact being an innocent and in fact having a spell and in fact using it. Looking at the position so far though, no one else has claimed thr spell, so I would tend to accept all of that.

Taking it as that Chupa turns out to be innocent and Rickets is innocent, Bad Haggis would absolutely have been the top option for the lynch in my eyes. I had both Chupa and Rickets as suspects with them so need to adjust my focus. I was highlighting Hi IQ from an early point and that is where my search starts.
 
[AC] wing nut;2752782 said:
Okay after careful consideration and being told by Lady I should be helping the town in the "spirit" of the game.

Turn Bad Haggis


But that is the only name I am giving freely. Votes will be based on not knowing who is who and following Trees lead as you guys are.
Click to expand...

Okay I don't like Wing not playing to the best of their best ability for their new team, but I really think if they went beyond stubborness and actually lied G would either mod-kill Wing or call the game. So I believe BH is a witch. Turn or burn I'm not sure on but I am leaning turn.
 
Sorry if I missed this, I was out drinking last night and have to work today. What are the chances that the 'random' event is a turn for the scum team to balance out their lost member? Then rickets is just serving up a big steaming pile of WIFOM?

If wing can't confirm/deny any names we come up with without evidence, then there's no reason he'd have to let us know if Rickets is full of it or not.

I think either way Haggis is scum.
 
[AC] C-note;2752880 said:
Sorry if I missed this, I was out drinking last night and have to work today. What are the chances that the 'random' event is a turn for the scum team to balance out their lost member? Then rickets is just serving up a big steaming pile of WIFOM?<br />
<br />
If wing can't confirm/deny any names we come up with without evidence, then there's no reason he'd have to let us know if Rickets is full of it or not.<br />
<br />
I think either way Haggis is scum.
Click to expand...


Fascinating acronym: http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=WIFOM
 
I think Rickets should NOT cast the spell they have. I think we burn BH and then we can see the results. If BH is innocent, then we will know how much we can trust wing. If BH is a witch, that should leave it down to one. I trust Rickets less than they trust me. Who really knows what that random event did. The event does not state anyone got a PM. Maybe the event turned wing back to a witch. Something about Love was in that spell. Maybe wing loves the witches or a witch. Anyone can claim anything. I can't think of a spell event given to a player where LG would not require silence. The safest move is to have Rickets not take action and burn BH, who is on most peoples list anyway.

I retract my vote on Ricketts and vote to burn Bad Hagis at the stake.

Let's say the spell brought wing back to the witches. And that the other two witches are Rickets and BH. Rickets claims he can turn one, then wing confirms BH is one. So Rickets "turns" BH, now the town thinks that there are two turned witches and there must be only one left and it can't be Rickets. So all three witches would be thought as innocent. While this plan seems to be a little above the skill level of the alive witches, remember they are able to still talk to Wiz.

I am not saying this has happened. There is no way I am going to think for a bit Rickets can be trusted. If chup had not had some sort of personal break down from the heat of being a suspect, then I am sure Rickets would have not been able to hide after trying to discredit me. I am guessing even if the town suggested for Rickets not to cast the spell, they would say, oops, I already did.
 
[AC] C-note;2752880 said:
Sorry if I missed this, I was out drinking last night and have to work today. What are the chances that the 'random' event is a turn for the scum team to balance out their lost member? Then rickets is just serving up a big steaming pile of WIFOM?

If wing can't confirm/deny any names we come up with without evidence, then there's no reason he'd have to let us know if Rickets is full of it or not.

I think either way Haggis is scum.
Click to expand...

I agree. I meant to say that in my post.
 
Lady G said:
A eery fog comes over the town; a faint glow can be seen from within the fog which appears to be a candle, a scent of incense fills the air as a quiet chant is heard....


SACRED WATER FLOW FROM ME TO DRAW YOU EVER NEAR AS ENDLESS RIVERS RUN TO SEA YOUR PATH TO ME IS CLEAR. A LOVE THAT'S TRUE ONCE HERE YOU'LL FIND AND KNOW YOUR JOURNEY'S END. AND YOUR HEART AND SOUL AND MIND YOU'LL KNOW OUR LIVES SHOULD BLEND.
Click to expand...

I am convinced that this did not give anyone a spell to cast. LG posted my spells after I cast them. This is not a spell or giving someone a spell.
 
Vote Count:

Chupa-(0)-Star, Tree, Wing, Doom, Rickets, Bad Haggis, scoop

Bad Haggis-(3)-Star, Rickets, Tree

Rickets-(0)-Tree

Votes on Chupa will not count.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom