Mafia 104 - Dawg the Bounty Hunter - The Play

[Nepherael]

.
The dealer, if they are a vet, would recruit someone who would make the turn seamlessly and stay out of the spotlight. Rich always makes a good turn for that reason, as does Zaffy. That's not to say many others in this game don't also make great turn candidates.

Good answer, rich and zaffy are also on the list.

Neph, you make a good point. Out of those of us that you mentioned, who are you looking more strongly at atm?

Not sure. If I had to rank it currently it would be tied with pap, JB, and labby with zaf right behind (because of my vote earlier) and rich and rb behind because they haven't done anything.

The problem here is I know how good you are JB. If labby is even close to that good (she is) then I don't know if I can really take either of these quotes as genuinely concerned or helpful. At the moment though pap is a little higher because he seems to think me not wanting to lynch an innocent means I'm hiding something.

 

[Zaffy]

No worries guys, I was not turned.

 

[the wizard]

Just did a quick read through to catch up. All I can say is wow. I will need to go back through to look at a few things.

The first thing I want to point out is that if I had read Neph's vote before placing mine, I would have voted Neph. It read as an opportunistic vote.

To explain what I mean, it appeared to me that he waited untill someone else kick the zaffy bush then jumped on it. I could be wrong and will read back through to make sure, but as it reads on the surface that is what I saw.

Unfortunately, I had to run as soon as I voted so couldn't change it. I did find it gnawed at me all day.

 

[Nepherael]

On the other hand I only have a couple games under my belt. My inexperience could be clouding my judgement. Rich makes a good list too (chill and wiz have been around the block a few times too if I'm not mistaken) so with that we've listed almost everyone playing hahaha

 

[Zaffy]

Since we're making lists.

I would tend towards Rich or Chill because they are generally low profile survivors. JB or Lab because they are fun to be on a team with and they're good players. And Neph because he's a newbie who shows great promise.

 

[jbradt]

Good answer, rich and zaffy are also on the list.



Not sure. If I had to rank it currently it would be tied with pap, JB, and labby with zaf right behind (because of my vote earlier) and rich and rb behind because they haven't done anything.

The problem here is I know how good you are JB. If labby is even close to that good (she is) then I don't know if I can really take either of these quotes as genuinely concerned or helpful. At the moment though pap is a little higher because he seems to think me not wanting to lynch an innocent means I'm hiding something.

I think I basically get what you're saying, but there's one thing that really bugs me here. It's the part I bolded, actually. You talk about it like it was a foregone conclusion that Pir was innocent. Up until his role was revealed by Dawg, most of us were still in the dark about that.

I also find it a little odd that you excuse Rich and RB because they "haven't done anything", yet I'm high up on your list.

 

[jbradt]

I find Kash's thoughts here quite interesting. It does seem Pir was cherry picking from Neph's posts to make him look scummy.


Aww, thanks. But why not put your placeholder on Pir after all the points you made about him in your post before? That doesn't make much sense, though if you were just thinking out loud and not ready to heavily pursue those thoughts I guess I could see not voting for him yet.


This post sounds very defensive, way more defensive than any innocent need be on day 1. I didn't see anything personal towards you in Kash's post and I see nothing that indicates she has it out for you. Your defensiveness makes me think you have a guilty conscience.


I agree with Pappy that your defensiveness and accusing her of being out to get you definitely ups the intensity.


Seriously, after Pir getting all defensive when Kash kicked bushes around him doesn't interest you at all? You truly feel a random vote is the best way to vote after today's posts?

I retract my vote on JB. I vote to lynch Pir. AAF also has my attention now.

Labby, what was it about AAF that prompted your final statement here?

While we're talking about AAF, Pappy, have you never heard of eenie meenie miney moe? It surprised me a little that you didn't get this, but you kept on and on about it...

 

[Fishfriend1]

Well, that sucks. Sorry to see you go Pir.

I'm going to skim the D1 posts since it's late here and I need to be up at 6 tomorrow. I may or may not post my thoughts tonight, depending on how long it takes to skim.

 

[jbradt]

Rich made 3 posts over 2 hours prior to and including his post. The order of posts went; Rich, Pir, Rich, Pir, Bally, Rich(vote) If he was just going to vote the last person who posted he skipped 2 chances to vote for Pir. Besides the fact that choosing to vote for the next poster is non-random anyway. It doesn't feel right to me.

Zaffy, I think I missed the point you were making here. You state that Rich passed up "2 chances to vote for Pir". But that seems to assume that you believe Rich wanted to vote for him. I guess I'm just not following... can you clarify what you meant for me?

 

[Zaffy]

Zaffy, I think I missed the point you were making here. You state that Rich passed up "2 chances to vote for Pir". But that seems to assume that you believe Rich wanted to vote for him. I guess I'm just not following... can you clarify what you meant for me?

I meant that rich stated his reason for voting Bally was that he voted for the last person who posted. But Piranha posted twice while rich was apparently active.