Mafia 104 - Dawg the Bounty Hunter - The Play

[dundadundun]

This:



If dun has ever UDed, I don't recall it. The vast majority of the time when someone does UD they are a vanilla townie. To be clear, I'm not willing to make that assumption with Bally. She has UDed many times and role doesn't seem to effect her.

^ glad you clarified. i thought you were referring to nobody coming forth saying they were innocent and their vote was doubled when she UDed the first time.

you are correct. only time i ever missed a vote was D1 this game. i don't see anyone coming forth about that, either...

 

[dundadundun]

to clarify, that's why i'm leaning bally townie.

i'd think an innocent would want to convey that message to the town, personally.

 

[jpappy789]

Those are the people who could have gotten their vote doubled on both N1 and N2 assuming Bally and Dun were both townie. Dawg apparently won't give us Bally's ID, I didn't see that he wouldn't in the rules. It would be a much more useful list if we knew her alignment. As it stands it's much less useful. :/

So assume that Bally and Dun were, in fact, innocent. How does that mean any of those people would have gotten the votes?

 

[dundadundun]

So assume that Bally and Dun were, in fact, innocent. How does that mean any of those people would have gotten the votes?

if i recall correctly, it was labby that asked if anyone had their vote doubled.

 

[dundadundun]

nobody came forward...

 

[Zaffy]

Except he didn't UD...last I checked Dun is still in the game and someone from the opposite team as his just got their vote doubled.

In standard rules he would have UDed. That's what I meant.

 

[Zaffy]

So assume that Bally and Dun were, in fact, innocent. How does that mean any of those people would have gotten the votes?

I'm saying that those people were eligible on both nights to get the doubled vote. It's possible that none of them did and there was over lap elsewhere. However they had twice the opportunity to get it over anyone else on either night. Without know Dun and Ballys roles it's less helpful than I thought it would be. I left it for the town because I thought there was a chance that I'd be killed and Ballys alignment would be revealed.

 

[Kashta]

All I know is I really want that answer from JB why he went for the tie.

And Zaffy.... are you immortal or what? Maybe feline?

 

[jpappy789]

^ glad you clarified. i thought you were referring to nobody coming forth saying they were innocent and their vote was doubled when she UDed the first time.

you are correct. only time i ever missed a vote was D1 this game. i don't see anyone coming forth about that, either...

to clarify, that's why i'm leaning bally townie.

i'd think an innocent would want to convey that message to the town, personally.

Assuming that the innocent in question is still alive or wants to convey that message. For all we know they could either have been killed or even turned afterwards.

What if Pir or the player turned N1 received your vote? What if Neph or DD received Bally's vote?

If that's the case then we are SOL and the silence really means nothing because either you or Bally or both could still be scum.

 

[jpappy789]

I'm saying that those people were eligible on both nights to get the doubled vote. It's possible that none of them did and there was over lap elsewhere. However they had twice the opportunity to get it over anyone else on either night. Without know Dun and Ballys roles it's less helpful than I thought it would be. I left it for the town because I thought there was a chance that I'd be killed and Ballys alignment would be revealed.

So by "eligible" you mean both nights those people voted a place where a double vote wouldn't have effected the lynch, correct?

I see that as a HUGE assumption seeing as both nights are mutually exclusive events and it doesn't take into account that a double vote could have gone to someone later killed or turned.