Mafia 105: Finding Bigfoot The Game!

[IceH2O]

Well the game is on and nothing is happening here

I vote to lynch AAF

I don't like his regurgitating info just before his vote last night which didn't go to anyone he named. In fact if you look he wished it was the game that a dumb question gets you killed,so I'm thinking he wanted that person dead anyway(which was Lab but he named DD,who did die after all)

I think they thought they were down to just AAF after night fall and why AAF posted he shouldn't have UDed and Neph posted sorry then somehow realized he was still alive. Someone in the den or PM from them? Then Neph played it off by pulling a post from DD. I know he posted a reason of personal life but that has been used so much in these games its hard to overlook anymore.
Also his little fight with Neph looks scripted,not that someone wrote it for them but like hey grill me a bit and I will grill you a bit.

I chose AAF because I feel the case on him is better, the team theory is just that a theory. Fact is AAF played in a way as to make sure he ended up with no blood on his hand even after naming 3 suspects and what he thought about their actions then not voting any of them.

 

[Nepherael]

1st I'd call this a preemptive OMGUS vote. But I was leaning voting AAF. I did think you'd move after I did it though.
2nd Its a theory, the game is built on throwing out theories.
3rd What defense?
4th. There were 5 votes still being withheld, no matter which of the players with 1 vote at the time is Bigfoot they weren't in enough danger that the hippies would out themselves.

1. So you were baiting me by saying stuff you knew I would think was suspicious? Doubt it since what really made me vote you wasn't your comment on AAF and I, it was saying the hippies wouldn't switch their vote to save Bigfoot in a hypothetical situation.

2.what theory? I was pointing out that you shot down Pir's theory (not theory but just possible scenario he tossed out there) by saying something wouldn't happen when it is highly likely that it would in the hypothetical situation he described (not the set-up, the saving Bigfoot part). If that's not what you're talking about then I'm not sure what you're referring to since I didn't quote one.

3. AAF defending himself against my vote with his posts trying to use past games to define why I shouldn't vote for him this game

4. Makes me more suspicious since I wasn't even saying that that's what happened. I said in that hypothetical situation the hippies would definitely save Bigfoot

We'll played with the "pre-emptive OMGUS vote" comment.

I think you're a hippy and I can't allow it

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

 

[Nepherael]

Its a legit question. If youre innocent you dont want to cause confusion. Scum are the ones who like to confuse people.

But he wasn't serious. I guess I'd get better at the game if I started reading a bit more into posts I think are jokes but I think when people make a post that looks like a joke (whether they're joking or not) and someone calls them out on it I seem to always end up seeing someone question the person that called the other out. It makes people go "hmm was he just looking for something to jump at just to get that guy lynched"

Lol I could be wrong though. Was just a thought process I had. Kinda thinking out loud.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

 

[Nepherael]

Ice just so you know I was told by Zaffy himself that I was still alive. He sent me a funny pm that made me laugh and then get excited that I could play again.

Also why is someone saying their personal life has been hectic a reason to think they're scummy? Granted I haven't played that many games but I feel like it's easy to tell if that statement is legit or not. Like I could've UD'd but got lucky and said I've had stuff going on. How is that suspicious if I actually missed nightfall? If I came in with no posts right before nightfall and made a vote then maybe that would be a bit scummy but, like I said, it seems it should be fairly easy to tell the difference.


Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

 

[IceH2O]

1. So you were baiting me by saying stuff you knew I would think was suspicious? Doubt it since what really made me vote you wasn't your comment on AAF and I, it was saying the hippies wouldn't switch their vote to save Bigfoot in a hypothetical situation.

2.what theory? I was pointing out that you shot down Pir's theory (not theory but just possible scenario he tossed out there) by saying something wouldn't happen when it is highly likely that it would in the hypothetical situation he described (not the set-up, the saving Bigfoot part). If that's not what you're talking about then I'm not sure what you're referring to since I didn't quote one.

3. AAF defending himself against my vote with his posts trying to use past games to define why I shouldn't vote for him this game

4. Makes me more suspicious since I wasn't even saying that that's what happened. I said in that hypothetical situation the hippies would definitely save Bigfoot

We'll played with the "pre-emptive OMGUS vote" comment.

I think you're a hippy and I can't allow it

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

1. No, not baiting. But I felt if my comment on you 2 being team mates was right that you'd end up moving when I voted AAF, you just moved before I actually voted.

2.Pirs scenario was shot down because at the timing it wouldn't be worth making that move. Why would they risk outing themselves out when 5 other votes would still be played.

3. I thought you meant my defense not AAFs. I was like I haven't made any defensive posts so I thought you were trying to pull a fast one.

4. Of course if they had to they would, but in that scenario they had no reason to make the move and risk themselves.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice just so you know I was told by Zaffy himself that I was still alive. He sent me a funny pm that made me laugh and then get excited that I could play again.

Also why is someone saying their personal life has been hectic a reason to think they're scummy? Granted I haven't played that many games but I feel like it's easy to tell if that statement is legit or not. Like I could've UD'd but got lucky and said I've had stuff going on. How is that suspicious if I actually missed nightfall? If I came in with no posts right before nightfall and made a vote then maybe that would be a bit scummy but, like I said, it seems it should be fairly easy to tell the difference.


Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

I don't think you're scummy because you said life has been hectic. That excuse has been overused and found to be a lie so I just don't let it influence me.

 

[Nepherael]

1. No, not baiting. But I felt if my comment on you 2 being team mates was right that you'd end up moving when I voted AAF, you just moved before I actually voted.

2.Pirs scenario was shot down because at the timing it wouldn't be worth making that move. Why would they risk outing themselves out when 5 other votes would still be played.

3. I thought you meant my defense not AAFs. I was like I haven't made any defensive posts so I thought you were trying to pull a fast one.

4. Of course if they had to they would, but in that scenario they had no reason to make the move and risk themselves.

1. So your theory had no merit because I moved before you voted...

2 and 4. I kept saying I wasn't referring to pir's set-up scenario but the hypothetical saving of Bigfoot. You have now conceded that they would do that but I feel like it took us too long to get her

3. Lol right on XD

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

 

[Nepherael]

I don't think you're scummy because you said life has been hectic. That excuse has been overused and found to be a lie so I just don't let it influence me.

Ok I feel ya there. Even in the few games I've played I've seen it multiple times

As far as your comment earlier about no one participating, I don't think anyone thought that was anti town specifically (because everyone wants people to post and play. almost every game I've played someone has said "quit floating by guys and start participating. You're not helping the town" or something like that because of a number of people hardly posting.) It was the phrasing of it "thanks for reminding me why I quit". Like a give up kind of attitude for this game. Just thought I'd toss that out there since I think that was the reasoning behind people commenting on it

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!

 

[IceH2O]

I gotcha...I didn't mean this game. I played most of the games since the start but I got tired of non participation and coat tail riding so I quit playing all together. I play once in a while now when I feel like torturing myself.

 

[Nepherael]

I gotcha...I didn't mean this game. I played most of the games since the start but I got tired of non participation and coat tail riding so I quit playing all together. I play once in a while now when I feel like torturing myself.

Lol. I love it. I'm just glad to find a group that plays (not that I even knew what mafia was til I came here). There's been a lot of comments on people floating through and not adding much so I see where you're at but there seems to always be a core group that really plays.

On a game related note, the more I think about it the more I winder about AAF again. My vote probably won't go back his way (though that is always possible with a whole 'nother day before nightfall) but I'm interested where more of the votes will land since I suspect more than just AAF and Ice here.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!