Mafia 106: Pokemafia

[Coler]

I think Rich is very questionable right now. I would lean him to the scum side slightly but that is tough to say without knowing how nightfall plays out tonight.

Dawg...again I get that you have quoted the mod set up - and again I really want PIR to clarify the position - as regards how many scum there are.

You are, yet again, pushing that there are two of them, i.e. assuming that there is in fact another nightfall if we get this one wrong.

As I have pointed out, the sense of the game thread conveys that there is a Giovannia/Don, a Jesse and a James, i.e. 3, in which case we are in a lynch right or lose environment on the assumption that their hit also goes home, as we have no protection. Or have you forgotten that ?

I really do not like that you are so non-committal on rich subject to how nightfall plays out in circumstances where to my mind the far more likely scenario is that we are dealing with 3 scum and hence cannot make any mistake tonight.

 

[Coler]

I think Rich is very questionable right now. I would lean him to the scum side slightly but that is tough to say without knowing how nightfall plays out tonight.

I don't suppose you would care to set out why you find Rich questionable and why you lean him scum, by the way ?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg...again I get that you have quoted the mod set up - and again I really want PIR to clarify the position - as regards how many scum there are.

You are, yet again, pushing that there are two of them, i.e. assuming that there is in fact another nightfall if we get this one wrong.

As I have pointed out, the sense of the game thread conveys that there is a Giovannia/Don, a Jesse and a James, i.e. 3, in which case we are in a lynch right or lose environment on the assumption that their hit also goes home, as we have no protection. Or have you forgotten that ?

I really do not like that you are so non-committal on rich subject to how nightfall plays out in circumstances where to my mind the far more likely scenario is that we are dealing with 3 scum and hence cannot make any mistake tonight.

The mod list how many scum there will be based on numbers. The setup seems to be written for any number of players not just for this game. That's why I think Jesse/James is listed with a slash between them. I think that could mean there is only one.

I'm not pushing that there are two. The Mod said there are two.

I don't think I am making a mistake tonight. I think you are non-commital on everyone. I have said I am leaning Rich scum right now. How is that non-commital? I tend to lean Rich scum because his conclusions are not in line with what I am thinking right now. I am stating that I won't know for sure because I could very well be wrong. But I don't think I am.

 

[Coler]

The mod list how many scum there will be based on numbers. The setup seems to be written for any number of players not just for this game. That's why I think Jesse/James is listed with a slash between them. I think that could mean there is only one.

I'm not pushing that there are two. The Mod said there are two.

I don't think I am making a mistake tonight. I think you are non-commital on everyone. I have said I am leaning Rich scum right now. How is that non-commital? I tend to lean Rich scum because his conclusions are not in line with what I am thinking right now. I am stating that I won't know for sure because I could very well be wrong. But I don't think I am.

Really ?

And the others whose conclusions are not in line with what you are thinking right now ? How are you feeling about them ?

 

[jpappy789]

Jesse/James (mafia):You are standard scum. You talk with other scum and help Giovanni decide who to hit. Jesse replaces Giovanni and James replaces Jesse should one be removed from the game.

What worries me about assuming there is only two is that Pir lists all 3 roles here in order of succession:

1) Giovanni
2) Jesse
3) James

In that order...if there are only two, why would Pir list all three?

 

[dirtydawg10]

FF I am leaning innocent right now based on the gift.

JPap should be obvious.

Coler should be obvious.

Neph has me stumped to tell you the truth. Not really sure.

Met hasn't said enough to get a read but I'm thinking innocent right now.

That leaves me and Rich. I think you can figure that out

 

[dirtydawg10]

Jesse replaces Giovanni and James replaces Jesse should one be removed from the game

What if one didn't start the game? I'm thinking the same thing happens.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I'm willing to let Pir confirm his rules but it seems clear in the rules.

 

[Coler]

Quick point - you're still trying to canvass that there must only be two scum, despite what people have shown you in the set-up posts which indicate the opposite.

FF I am leaning innocent right now based on the gift.

JPap should be obvious.

Coler should be obvious.

Neph has me stumped to tell you the truth. Not really sure.

Met hasn't said enough to get a read but I'm thinking innocent right now.

That leaves me and Rich. I think you can figure that out

So...you have me, jappy and Rich as your scum suspects. Neph you are unsure about. And you think there are two scum.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Quick point - you're still trying to canvass that there must only be two scum, despite what people have shown you in the set-up posts which indicate the opposite.



So...you have me, jappy and Rich as your scum suspects. Neph you are unsure about. And you think there are two scum.

Yes...unlike you I don't have the luxury of knowing who are scum and who are innocent.