Mafia 107 - Tank of Terror!

[plantling]

Plant, what does this bold sentence said to Ice mean? That since not everyone bought the idea that the evils didn't put in a hit because they were not around at nightfall, they will put in their hit tonite. A lynched townie and a hit townie = town loss.


Why are you wanting people to follow you on to Rich? You haven't shown anything to say that he is scum and have said more than once now that you aren't very sure of his game play. I don't get how Ice naming you GBR makes you more sure of Rich being scum than Ice.

I didn't want to come out b/c I didn't want the doc to have to protect me. I wanted to get Rich lynched by the town so I stated as heavily as I could without being positive that he was the convict. Didn't work, bc Ice caught it and started to frame me up as the GBR.

 

[jpappy789]

Isn't the "catfish" an innocent? The pleco?

I think Plant was attempting to RC as the Cory since she is now saying she investigated Rich.

 

[plantling]

Plant, if that is the case why did you say this earlier? Seems to me that if Ice was making a false RC, and you already knew Rich was the convict, you should have been pretty sure what Ice's role was from the moment he said you were the GBR.

Like I said, it was a dumb play on words as Ice had said something similar to me earlier.

 

[dirtydawg10]

lol...ok I took that the wrong way. Rereading it makes more sense

 

[plantling]

I think Plant was attempting to RC as the Cory since she is now saying she investigated Rich.

I had read some games where RC wasn't allowed, but since Ice was heavily giving clues such as that I was speaking German, I thought it to be ok, too, especially since the rules did not prohibit it.

 

[IceH2O]

Well if we are going to just come out and role play instead of trying to cleverly use a play on words. I am the Cory.

I investigated Plant hoping she was innocent and the Betta or Pleco so we could communicate. When I found out she was the GBR I went right after her. I didn't try pussyfooting around to much because I knew we needed to get a scum tonight.

 

[jpappy789]

I didn't want to come out b/c I didn't want the doc to have to protect me. I wanted to get Rich lynched by the town so I stated as heavily as I could without being positive that he was the convict. Didn't work, bc Ice caught it and started to frame me up as the GBR.

That line alone makes no sense. The doc/pleco's best protection is on PRs...since Tank is gone, the only other PR is the det/cory role. Why wouldn't you want the protection?

Your thoughts on Rich were so wishy-washy that there was absolutely NO WAY you would have convinced the town of anything. To me it looks like the only reason you eventually vote Rich was because Ice called you out first.

You obviously are aware that we need to lynch scum tonight. For you, as the supposed detective, to not come out when you have a 100% scum because you didn't want the protection is absolutely the worst way to play this whole thing out. Either you're lying or very rusty from being away from the game.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I retract my vote for Neph and vote to lynch Rich

 

[plantling]

That line alone makes no sense. The doc/pleco's best protection is on PRs...since Tank is gone, the only other PR is the det/cory role. Why wouldn't you want the protection?

Your thoughts on Rich were so wishy-washy that there was absolutely NO WAY you would have convinced the town of anything. To me it looks like the only reason you eventually vote Rich was because Ice called you out first.

You obviously are aware that we need to lynch scum tonight. For you, as the supposed detective, to not come out when you have a 100% scum because you didn't want the protection is absolutely the worst way to play this whole thing out. Either you're lying or very rusty from being away from the game.

Yes, I am rusty and yes I have sweated that I would maybe need to come out if not enough votes were on Rich. but Ice beat me to it and I knew he was going to frame me up..., he's doing a great job, btw.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Just for clarification I'm voting for Rich because of this line...unless there is an explanation I'm missing?

If you guys want to make it me vs Plant I'm fine with that. Just make sure if you are innocent that you vote me