Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[plantling]

You could obviously add me to that whole "odd" thing!!
Seriously as a kid and even sometimes now I feel like Charlie Brown who always gets the rock. Santa would be passing out cookies to all the kids but he would miss me. Maybe that's why I reacted to that Sploke thing because I was a nerdyish kid whose favorite subject was Spelling.

"Yes, Jmax does, and I was wondering why Ice didn't mention that. Also I was wrong about the 4 way tie. JM actually had 3 votes when Ice pulled off of you and voted for Z and then switched to me which tied us. Can't help but wonder if there's a connection there"
This is really what I wanted to comment on, of coarse it wont bring it over in my quote..since it was a quote w/in a quote...but yes I was wondering that myself, that would be why after he posted it I pointed out Jmax had one also and then started looking more into things as they were posted and decided she fit the whole "bat" theory best IMO.

Since this was brought up I do at this time want to retract my vote for Plant...and vote to burn Jmax

Of coarse this is subject to change at anytime, others it may be switched to would be DC, back to plant or Ice.

Fair enough

I'm allergic to pet dander as well, but I do have a small chihuahua mix dog. I take Allegra-D to keep my allergy symptoms at a minimum. I am also allergic to mold and dust mites. I am basically sick all the time =/

I take over the counter 24HR claritin, but I really should go get an RX as it's prolly cheaper. Though I don't take it everyday, just when I know I'll be exposed to the elements. My sister still kids me about my "snot rags" (kleenex) that I usually carry around just in case.

I need to go check on the baby. BBL this afternoon.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, I know I said I was going but had to post a thought here:

I wasn't questioning DC's excuses for being gone. I was wondering why he then turned it around on jm.

And if I remember correctly, you said before that jm usually acts like this and now you said it again. So why are you defending DC for using this to justify a vote?
I believe it was also pointed out that she has only played 3 games 2 of which she was "bad", so if she is posting like usual then...logic would put her evil, no?

She could very well be a witch but I think that using her not posting her thoughts every second is a lame idea. And I sometimes understand why she posts all her excuses...like DC said...you get qoute-unquote "crucified" in this game for having a life
Again this is something she did last game, lot's of excuses and EVIL.:evil_lol:

So now it seems like you are flip-flopping sploke. Not a good townie strategy imo...

And how the plantling vote working for you? I believe you said you would go along with it and see how it works out because you didn't have anyone else...any thoughts on that yet?

 

[jpappy789]

I'm not voting for JM because of her low post counts. I'm voting based on her allusion to having info on the first day. The first day is always a mad grasp for straws. We all know this. Once again I'd like to reiterate a point I've made before, low posts have never pointed to guilt or innocence. In the the BioBadlands game, BKW was quite vocal and was the leader of the badguys. We need to find better clues than this person doesn't talk much.

If you haven't played with jm then I understand this but I think your friend sploke pointed this out already...this is normal for jm.

And I find it odd that you have yet to really talk about anyone other than jm and yourself this game...

 

[Sploke]

How exactly am I flip-flopping? I am (trying to) defend the same position I took up last night, i.e. suspicion of JM and DD, although I haven't posted anything about DD at all today. I then voted for plantling because of some of the commentary from others, and so far I haven't seen any reason to change. First day is a crapshoot anyway, as we all know. For the innocent anyway, the witches should have a pretty clear idea of who to vote for. Anyway, tell me where in there I'm flip flopping around and I'll try to explain my thoughts.

 

[jpappy789]

Lady G. I understand the point that she has been evil more often than not so any normal activity for her could be taken the evil way.

But I think it would be more "evil" of her to suddenly change her style of play after being caught last time for all the wierd things she said.

I mean if she is evil again, why would she continue with the excuses unless they are real and she has nothing to hide and she is not really evil???

 

[jpappy789]

How exactly am I flip-flopping? I am (trying to) defend the same position I took up last night, i.e. suspicion of JM and DD, although I haven't posted anything about DD at all today. I then voted for plantling because of some of the commentary from others, and so far I haven't seen any reason to change. First day is a crapshoot anyway, as we all know. For the innocent anyway, the witches should have a pretty clear idea of who to vote for. Anyway, tell me where in there I'm flip flopping around and I'll try to explain my thoughts.

I meant flip-flopping with defending DC's point on jm and you own point about her acting normal.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, one last thing since I brought it up to Jpap...here is were it was posted about how many games Jmax has played and how many were evil.

games 4,5, and 12, I believe. I'm not stalking you I just have a weird memory. It's been ages, but while in France I was able to utilize French I'd learned in highschool.

Ice, I was going to change my vote but the more you post the more I think you may indeed be witchy. Ogre, Z, and Lady G are indeed good players and does look like a list that the witch's may want gone. I suppose I'm on there because I voted for you and even though it was just for a reaction, it must have hit a nerve. A witchy nerve.

Your right, lol, and two out of the three I was mafia, so, I guess, none of you actually know my innocent style, lol...

Personally I haven't noticed a difference yet.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, if we are looking to RB's posts as clues for who we ashould be focusing on, this is what I've come up with.

a noted and posted difference in white/black witches, AND the three foldfold train of thoughts, so soon! Some folks have been reading up! Great! - post 34

Noting that there are noticable differences in witches and that the town is doing a little homework.

Go away evil dreams
its not what it seems
go away go far away leave my dreams sight
give me at least one good night - Post 126

Perhaps this is saying it's someone experieced, a veteran of the game. One who is usually voted off early. Perhaps, this is Ice..... whether it's saying that he is evil is to be determined. It says to go away evil dreams, it's not what it seems. Perhaps it's saying that he is a PR.


"Cast of a shadow I am thee, make the ones who look, not see me.
I am thin air not to be seen, I am a shadow invisible both silent and lean." - Post 127

I am led to believe this may be Judge. Cast of a shadow make ones look... that to me is saying that the very witch we spoke about in the upper left hand corner of her avatar is precisely the one mentioned here. Thin air, not to be seen....yeap, tells me it's Judge.


"As it be thought in the mind of others
both familiar and strange
both sisters and brothers
may it be heard in mine own head
loud and clear as if it'd been said." - Post 188

This to me is saying that there is someone who we have in common on our suspected lists but we aren't making too much of a big deal about it, maybe we just aren't coming together with it. Perhaps this is saying we should be looking at a newbie.


tail of rat
wing of bat
allow this cat to chit and chat! - Post 190

Not really sure of this as the visuals are all over our avatars and names. However, I do see the points brought up by you guys but I do think that either we are reading either too far into it or not enough. If I were to guess at a glance, it is saying to me that someone who drinks the witchy brew is quite talkative. That can be LG, she's got 67 posts here, while Z has 35posts and is in 2nd place then we have 3rd place Ice who has 27 posts.

 

[jpappy789]

Sploke I am trying to figure out how you went from point A to point B with your thoughts on judge.

I've seen this pattern from JM before. Its aggravating but not necessarily incriminating, she goes off about how she's picking up on clues no one else sees and has things figured out, but then doesn't tell anyone whats going on. Not exactly new...

This does not seem like you are entirely suspicious of jm at all. You even said it was not necessarily incriminating.

Also, JM seems like she's kind of blowing everyone off regardless of what they say about her, and as usual the shopping list of why she may or may not be active at any given moment. Seems like someone trying way too hard to seem like they're not trying to seem innocent..

Then you jump to saying she is suspicious??? If I read this correctly, you don't think her clue thing was suspicious but her excuses were???

Well, just checking in for the day. Doesn't look like a whole lot has happened since last night, more of the usual first-day maniacal suspicions. I want to laugh at the efforts to pull clues out of Rb's postings, but at the same time, having been in some of his games where he actually did throw in clues, I can't really blow them off. Anyway, I'm going along with the plantling vote for now, since there doesn't seem to be any solid reasoning for anything else as far as a first-day vote. I'll be watching most of the day so we'll see how this develops. I vote to burn plantling.

Funny how you didn't see a solid reason to vote anyone and just chose plantling to go along with it but now you come back after being questioned and say that you agree with people about their suspicions of her. I have no doubt in my mind that you wouldn't have ever mentioned your vote on plantling again unless you decided to switch to another innocent tonight...

How exactly am I flip-flopping? I am (trying to) defend the same position I took up last night, i.e. suspicion of JM and DD, although I haven't posted anything about DD at all today. I then voted for plantling because of some of the commentary from others, and so far I haven't seen any reason to change. First day is a crapshoot anyway, as we all know. For the innocent anyway, the witches should have a pretty clear idea of who to vote for. Anyway, tell me where in there I'm flip flopping around and I'll try to explain my thoughts.

 

[jpappy789]

Ok, one last thing since I brought it up to Jpap...here is were it was posted about how many games Jmax has played and how many were evil.




Personally I haven't noticed a difference yet.

Same here. So why is everyone assuming she is evil based on her posting this game when she has played good and evil the same way?