Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[jpappy789]

I don't think we can just not look at the clues. They weren't put there for nothing. Like I stated earlier in this novel of a thread I think it shows innocents and witches.

I don't think anybody said not to look at the clues at all. But if you think the clues contain innocents and witches is it worth a few dead innocents to find the witches? I am not sure what to think...

 

[IceH2O]

I don't think anybody said not to look at the clues at all. But if you think the clues contain innocents and witches is it worth a few dead innocents to find the witches? I am not sure what to think...

I think if we can figure out who the innocents are we won't end up lynching them.

It doesn't help the witches because they know who is innocent.

If we figure out the innocents and then they are lynched we can look at the names on that particular person to get a good read on the witches. It might also be a deterrent to the witches to try and lynch the known innocent, therefore they would have to hit them, in essence it makes their game longer.

 

[Lady G]

I dunno but mg had a very similar av so every time he posts I'm like, "why is mg posting in here..he's not playing.."

LOL, that was my first thought also!! I believe King saw the posts about if ppl changed thier avatar it would seem odd at this point and switched trying to get something started quite honestly, I'm not sure if he was gunning for witches to come out or innocents though.

I'd believe Blue is more witch then B is. JM hasn't posted much at all so how can she say a lot and say nothing?

I probably should stop posting so soon after I wake up, coming to the rescue might have been a bit of an overstatement. After I thought about it I thought you might be together as a team but the Herbalist/Prophet. I've thought about it and don't think Ogre is innocent, you still strike me as innocent though.

As for DC, I only posted that hoping people would post more. DC looks like DC to me though his vote for JM is pretty whack. JM said before the game4 started she had a lot on her plate so I'm not going to hold it against her. I think as the game wears on she'll post more as will DC.

KOTD was pretty non existent in posting also, but I don't recall to many people questioning him.
Yes, I noticed that too..but everytime I say something about the fact KOTD hasn't posted much I get a lynch mob formed around me, everyone saying "he always does this on day one" so I figured why bother posting it.

I merely pointed out that it was about the HP and it fit you in a way. I admitted it was stretched. If I were to just go after you I'd say it fit you to a T.
Actually I have to agree with this also, sorry I know what Plant said made sence (at the time), but after reading DD's look into things I am leaning more toward her version of Ice.

Actually Sauron was a shape shifter, he had a body and was not invisible or quiet. How does someone quiet push their will upon others?

# "Did Sauron have a physical form during The Lord of the Rings?" (Tolkien Newsgroups FAQ ) http://tolkien.slimy.com/faq/Creatures.html#SauronForm

I also wanted to say that yes, I too believe DD's theory on the spell being about you, it really makes alot of sence IMO. I also could see the chit chat spell being about me, but not as me being evil if you are really reading what it say's.





I don't think its all witches. I think there are clues to clear innocents also.We just have to figure out who is what. I think its part clues and part fun on Rbs part.
:iagree:






Post 147 JM posts her list




I don't think we can just not look at the clues. They weren't put there for nothing. Like I stated earlier in this novel of a thread I think it shows innocents and witches.

Just wanted to post a few thoughts on this post from you Ice

 

[jpappy789]

Honestly I think all the conversation about the clues is giving the witches perfect cover for today and possibly later, especially if people think that the clues contain both innocents and witches. All they have to do is come out and agree with what other people are saying or come up with their own twists. If an innocent ends up dead than its ok because it was in the "clues" and it was just read wrong.

Take this any way you want but this is my honest opinion.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I like when i come home and their are lots of posts to read. I will re-read and post my thoughts before night.

 

[jpappy789]

I like when i come home and their are lots of posts to read. I will re-read and post my thoughts before night.

Oh no! Posting before reading!?

You sir are a witch!
:headshake2:

 

[Lady G]

that would be a good one to describe the snitch.....hmm mafioso witches. that would be interesting. Fly by on a broom and get shot. :werd:

:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

 

[BrkD]

x_x confusing.. but
i retract my vote for charlie and will vote for no one right now.

 

[IceH2O]

Honestly I think all the conversation about the clues is giving the witches perfect cover for today and possibly later, especially if people think that the clues contain both innocents and witches. All they have to do is come out and agree with what other people are saying or come up with their own twists. If an innocent ends up dead than its ok because it was in the "clues" and it was just read wrong.

Take this any way you want but this is my honest opinion.

The more I look at the "clues" the more I think they aren't clues. I think Rb is just casting spells.



The 1st one I think is one for me to use to protect myself so I can get through night 1.

The 2nd one is just acknowledging the HP

The 3rd is probably just acknowledging the Prophet

None of them actually point to any one person IMO. The last post does but not as to their game status.

The last one I think its more a spell he casts to get low posters, Blue and possibly JM to post.

 

[IceH2O]

x_x confusing.. but
i retract my vote for charlie and will vote for no one right now.

Just make sure you vote before 8 PM EST or you'll die an untimely death.

A vote for “NO ONE” cannot be used on Game Day 1, only on game day 2 and following Days.