Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

Actually no, his list is from yesterday, but the same day/night cycle gamewise. And, he hasn't posted anything in here since about 10pm last night, which was a post about people being too silent. Is he in school?
 
sploke said:
I agree swayde, I'm still really feeling it was a newbie/confusion issue over waiting for direction from someone. I have lots of leaning innocent, but not as many leaning guilty, and i'm far fuzzier there anyway...not a good sign for the time being. Based on Ice's analysis, I guess plantling has moved over toward the innocent side for me right now, after the voting last night. That alsl fits in with B being innocent. I also (obviously) want to believe in Ice, but he;s good so I'm hesitant to go off in that direction just yet. Bluerat I also think is making newbie errors without realizing how lightly you have to step on the eggshells before someone hangs/stakes/burns you for cracking a few. Thats it for now, I have to head to bed. We shall see what the morning brings.
Click to expand...

sploke said:
I voted for plantling mostly based on Ice's analysis of the clues. For a first day vote, it seemed to be as good a decision as any.

As far as rb's clues go, the first one could have been as simple as saying, hey maybe we'll actually get a bad guy on the first night, since it hasn't happened yet in any game I've played.

Jpappy seems really eager to jump at people given the slightest chance or provocation, which is making me nervous.

I'm not seeing anything strange from Bluerat, I've talked to her a good deal in chat and yes, she is always a bit hard to understand. I think its more the typing style than anything else, i.e. rather poor grammar and almost a complete lack of punctuation. Thus, it comes off as cryptic where its more likely lazy chat speak.
Click to expand...

Sploke is really jumping out at me. He has gone back and forth on plantling based only on Ice's analysis of her. Is he trying to latch on to an innocent? Why no thoughts of your own splokey???

I agree that I don't like DC coming out as the herbalist. It seems like he threw that out there too quickly when people began questioning him. Especially when he said specifically why he wouldn't protect Lady g. I don't think anyone questioned why the herbalist didn't save her, but thats just an opinion. Also, the investigation of swayde is weak. Either the team doesn't really know what to do or he threw out swaydes name because nobody was questioning her and her innocence would seem likely. I can't trust him yet...

My vote will probably fall off of Brks as is was a rushed vote but I don't have a really strong suspect yet.
 
sploke said:
Party because, with the exception of Ogre, his top guilty suspects are my top innocents.
Click to expand...

Sploke, my top suspects included Brkd, who is becoming less suspicious, DC who was and maybe is a top candidate for lynching depending on what progresses today and you. The rest are 5's or just leaning innocent. Hardly a reason to vote for someone.

And I was taking the psat this morning so again lame reasoning. My suspcious of you are getting stronger sploke.

I also find it interesting that you have yet to make a list yourself. The most I have seen is you throw a few names out there but you keep saying you have a lot of people leaning innocent...

I retract my vote for Brks and vote to burn Sploke at the stake
 
I retract my vote from DC and vote to burn brk.

I thought that brk had only two votes. It's obvious I haven't been keeping up and I apologize.

I'm not quitting, but I'm probably not going to be very useful this game. Unless something is glaring obvious to me while I'm reading, I probably won't get much.

With DC being the herbalist, that kind of limits my suspect list to Ice and brk.

DCs revelation makes it more likely to me that Ice is a witch. Because it is much less likely that he is a power role. I guess he could still be innocent, but I'm leaning witchy for him.
 
I didn't like DC coming out either, but I've noticed from previous games that he gets fairly jumpy when a few people start tossing his name about, especially only a few hours from nightfall. I've seen it with him playing both good and evil, so its no surprise (to me anyway) that he felt forced to come out to save himself. Not saying it was the right time, but it was from his perspective.

Jpappy...you say that me not agreeing with your list is not enough reason to vote someone? If you are a witch (which I think you are), then you know exactly who are not witches...i.e. me, DC (apparently), B the newbie who's easy to make a case for, and possibly K who's always quiet so no one every knows whats going on with him. Throw in a fellow witch who's name has come up a few times (Ogre) and you have yourself a viable list thats easy to sell to the masses. Well, this villager is not buying.
 
Sploke I did not say because you don't agree with me that makes you a witch, in fact it seems like that is why you think I am a witch because my top suspects were your supposed innocents. Funny how nobody knows who they are except you because you have yet to put out a list.

And ogre and KOTD are 5's on that list. I still don't know what exactly to think of them yet.
 
Well I figured you'd be able to figure it out from my posts but I'll say it explicitly, I'll even rate everyone. (10=good, 1=evil)

lady 10 - confirmed
judge 10 - confirmed
sploke 10 (me)
swayde 10 - confirmed by DC (going with this until someone can prove otherwise)
deputy - 10 (see above)
BrkD - 8
bluerat - 7
zsand - 6
DD - 6
ice - 6
kotd - 5
plant - 5
ogre - 4
charlie - 4
jpap - 3

So obviously I'm not 100% sure on the guilty side, but the bottom half is basically what I was left with after picking out who I think is actually innocent.
 
Sounds kinds witchy to have others guess where you stand on people. Not really taking a side, just agreeing with other people and throwing some names out there...

sploke said:
Well I figured you'd be able to figure it out from my posts but I'll say it explicitly, I'll even rate everyone. (10=good, 1=evil)

lady 10 - confirmed
judge 10 - confirmed
sploke 10 (me)
swayde 10 - confirmed by DC (going with this until someone can prove otherwise)
deputy - 10 (see above)
BrkD - 8
bluerat - 7
zsand - 6
DD - 6
ice - 6
kotd - 5
plant - 5
ogre - 4
charlie - 4
jpap - 3

So obviously I'm not 100% sure on the guilty side, but the bottom half is basically what I was left with after picking out who I think is actually innocent.
Click to expand...

So my guess is that you think plant and kotd are pretty suspicious seeing as they are 5's...at least that is what you thought with my list.

Interesting how my exact two top suspects from that list yesterday are your top innocents...I really thought you were just exagerating that but seems like you needed to make your false statements appear to be true.
 
Dude I don't know what your deal is...I said it before, and I reiterated it. It adds up because its what I really think, not because its some elaborate plan that I'm making up as I go along. Why are you surprised when I said "your guilties are my innocents" and my list actually states that?
 
sploke said:
Dude I don't know what your deal is...I said it before, and I reiterated it. It adds up because its what I really think, not because its some elaborate plan that I'm making up as I go along. Why are you surprised when I said "your guilties are my innocents" and my list actually states that?
Click to expand...

Because if you said otherwise you would look even more like a witch than you already do. I doubt you would have put out a list unless I or someone else actually asked you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom