Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

Charlie, I can't blame you for your votes as I thought DC was evil also, but not till day 2.

But the fact that you were on both is suspicious.

I need Ogre to answer why he was so dead set on voting Ice DC Bkr as a team when he admits he wasn't reading.
 
Chas I find it odd for you to really agree with anyone...

You cant trust ogre but you cannot name him as a suspect because I am both of your top suspects...is that your reasoning for having him leaning innocent before?
 
IceH2O said:
Charlie, I can't blame you for your votes as I thought DC was evil also, but not till day 2.

But the fact that you were on both is suspicious.

I need Ogre to answer why he was so dead set on voting Ice DC Bkr as a team when he admits he wasn't reading.
Click to expand...

All of your posts were odd. bkr's looked suspicious, especially how their voting and later evidences looked like they were being coached.

Ice, I think what did it for you was the early day 1 list of five. We still don't know how many witches there are, but you had this list and seemed very dead set on it.

DC, I agreed with other's arguments against him and added him to my collection.


jpappy... the fact that I repeated the same thing several times is not an indication of how weak my arguement is... it is the argument. And yes, it is my opinion that Z is not playing like he has been in the past. It is my opinion that his posts are little more than agreeing with others, asking weak questions, and basically saying that he has no opinion on anyone. In other words, camo-fluff.

Look at what he wrote... but then you're his partner in evil aren't you. Now you are defending him, like he's been defending you.
 
If we were both witches we wouldn't be defending each other in the first place. I just think your case for Zs is weak and the fact that you are using that to justify your suspicions of him is why I believe you are a witch.

You kept saying Zs was "noncomittal" on day one. What is he supposed to do, name a few people he already thinks are witches? Remember...DAY ONE!!!
 
jpappy789 said:
Chas I find it odd for you to really agree with anyone...

You cant trust ogre but you cannot name him as a suspect because I am both of your top suspects...is that your reasoning for having him leaning innocent before?
Click to expand...
While i don't fully trust Ogre, if he is supicious of you and King, and i am also supicious of you and King, I have to think to myself, "He wouldn't name two of his evil teamates would he???" While it might be distancing, the fact he seems to be looking in the same direction i am makes it look like he is innocent, at least to me
 
Update thru post 747....

To burn at the stake....

ogre (1) by blue 713

kotd (4) by sway 675 plant 678 zsand 689 jpap 690

jpap (1) by charlie 672

bluerat (1) by DD 711

zsand (1) by ogre 656

8 of 11 having voted...

3 with no current votes... Deputy, Ice, KOTD...


Nightfall at 8 PM EST, Friday, 10/19
 
What if Deputy votes Ogre, I'll jump on Ogre that'll make it 4-4 KOTD will either jump on a nobody or Ogre, Ogre will have to jump onto KOTD to save himself. If anyone jumps on KOTD or Ogre after the fact we'll know is protecting them.

If the consensus is they are both witch then we have nothing to lose right? A tie becomes random which in this case one of the evils go. I turn the other one the following Day.

I do want to say though I am not convinced KOTD is evil but on a witch to innocent scale 5 being the middle he is hovering at a 3.25 to 3.75.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom