Mafia #14 -- The Play

[johnlarson66]

ok, so since we are waiting, lets talk, we all feel strongly about several people, my top three would now be,

Jensons, since RB said she can "claim" it at any time, if she isn't killed for telling on herself,then we know she lied. which, would be a stupid move on her part. I also belive her to be old school, specifically, because she played in some of the first games. (I think she also played In the first)

Blue, since most of us are in agreement that RB picked the roles, I believe she is in the new school.

Mad, seems odd to think him guilty, because they are trying to get the old school to hit him, could be they thought he was the dr, were proven wrong, and now they just feel since hes innocent, it doesn't matter? < opinions on this welcome.

Ogre: hes a good player. I think he might just be our last old school, after all, logically, he started all of the mafia stuff, and, it would be very smart, since he has layed so low.

Ice still has me concerned, always does, ..hes just a little more mild then usual IMHO, strange to me, thats all.

JL, I can never read him. makes me nervous.


I think we need to start looking very carefully innocents at our choices, we are perched on a steep ledge, and it will only take a little shove, to send us over, please consider what we do very carefully, if at any point we loose LG.

I am at work and have some time to post. So I will discuss things with you.

I am not sure who your top three are. You listed six names and the third one you think is innocent, so maybe you can clairfy your top three.

I agree with some of the things you said,

Jensons, since RB said she can "claim" it at any time, if she isn't killed for telling on herself,then we know she lied. which, would be a stupid move on her part. I also belive her to be old school, specifically, because she played in some of the first games. (I think she also played In the first)

I am not real sure if she is the blackmailee or the blackmailer. If she was the blackmailee and she told everyone she was being blackmailed, then she would be killed. I the blackmailer is allowed to say they are the blackmailer, I had assumed that the mafia were the ones to blackmail, but the rules do not say. I think Jensons is trying to say they are a power role and they have left hints to prove it. I think she is mafia and is just trying to confuse the town. I think Lady G will investigate her soon.

Blue, since most of us are in agreement that RB picked the roles, I believe she is in the new school.

I think she is not only new school mafia, but the Don.

Mad, seems odd to think him guilty, because they are trying to get the old school to hit him, could be they thought he was the dr, were proven wrong, and now they just feel since hes innocent, it doesn't matter? < opinions on this welcome.

I do not think he is mafia, could be. I am also trying to figure out who "they" are. I would also not let CL posts distract anyone. Maybe once we have more information, we can tell what the posts meant. I do not think the mafia has had a hit go through for the last 2 nights, we will learn a lot from who they hit next.

Ogre: hes a good player. I think he might just be our last old school, after all, logically, he started all of the mafia stuff, and, it would be very smart, since he has layed so low.

I also agree that Ogre could be mafia, he has made some comments that have had me concerned.

Ice still has me concerned, always does, ..hes just a little more mild then usual IMHO, strange to me, thats all.

I also agree that Ice is a good concern, if Ogre is mafia, then I think Ice is. There is some sort of Ice/Ogre connection. I can't quite point it out, but there is something there.

JL, I can never read him. makes me nervous.

I hope not many people can read me and that I make most people nervous. With that said, I am suprised I am still around and I am glad the last two mafia hits have been stopped.

I think we need to start looking very carefully innocents at our choices, we are perched on a steep ledge, and it will only take a little shove, to send us over, please consider what we do very carefully, if at any point we loose LG.

I do not think we will lose Lady G anytime soon. I also think we will have a days notice, because the Doctor will have to go first. I also think we will have some known innocents to follow. The list of suspects is going to be short.

I think we can talk all we want, but we have a very active and public Detective that has been leading us to mafia and with the mafia not being able to hit anyone, the town is in great shape.

 

[jpappy789]

I do not think he is mafia, could be. I am also trying to figure out who "they" are. I would also not let CL posts distract anyone. Maybe once we have more information, we can tell what the posts meant. I do not think the mafia has had a hit go through for the last 2 nights, we will learn a lot from who they hit next.

I agree jl with this jl. I also think that at this point, all both mafia teams can do is fish for the doc to them get Lg out of the way. Hopefully, they kill some other mafia in the process and the town rids of the others before they find him or her.

 

[judgemax]

I am at work and have some time to post. So I will discuss things with you.thank you as well, for replying!

I am not sure who your top three are. You listed six names and the third one you think is innocent, so maybe you can clairfy your top three.jensons, blue, mad, at this point.

I agree with some of the things you said,



I am not real sure if she is the blackmailee or the blackmailer. If she was the blackmailee and she told everyone she was being blackmailed, then she would be killed. I the blackmailer is allowed to say they are the blackmailer, I had assumed that the mafia were the ones to blackmail, but the rules do not say. I think Jensons is trying to say they are a power role and they have left hints to prove it. I think she is mafia and is just trying to confuse the town. I think Lady G will investigate her soon.I think she is implying that she is the blackmailer, in which case, she can "tell", if she were saying she was black mailed, she would die?.



I think she is not only new school mafia, but the Don.I can not agree more with this sentiment.



I do not think he is mafia, could be. I am also trying to figure out who "they" are. I would also not let CL posts distract anyone. Maybe once we have more information, we can tell what the posts meant. I do not think the mafia has had a hit go through for the last 2 nights, we will learn a lot from who they hit next.they, as in mafia, I am sorry, i do tend to generalize alot. I was trying to say, maybe the mafia, are either trying to use reverse phsyc, or are just trying to rid themselves of another innocent.



I also agree that Ogre could be mafia, he has made some comments that have had me concerned.I do think he is playing "odd" at the risk of sounding redundant, and using the same words over again.



I also agree that Ice is a good concern, if Ogre is mafia, then I think Ice is. There is some sort of Ice/Ogre connection. I can't quite point it out, but there is something there.Again, I can't either, but the more I see the more interesting it becomes.



I hope not many people can read me and that I make most people nervous. With that said, I am suprised I am still around and I am glad the last two mafia hits have been stopped. I think most of us feel that way, lmao !




I do not think we will lose Lady G anytime soon. I also think we will have a days notice, because the Doctor will have to go first. I also think we will have some known innocents to follow. The list of suspects is going to be short.I agree, however, I just don't want people following, and not doing any thinking for themselves. not that she is a bad person to follow, just that, if people are just waiting on her, what will happen if she gets an innocent investigation back? everyone, who has ridden on her shoulders is going to flounder.

I think we can talk all we want, but we have a very active and public Detective that has been leading us to mafia and with the mafia not being able to hit anyone, the town is in great shape.

yes, but it won't take much, to turn that around, and I don't want the innocents to simply because they didn't do any thinking from themselves. its OK to follow, as long as its not blindly, if she has mafia great, but what happens when she gets an innocent?..

 

[judgemax]

It should say I don't want the innocents to lose simply because they didn't do any thinking for themselves.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice, you're using 'lynch' and 'hit' interchangeably again....

I don't know why I do that, I'm just meaning get. I'm not even meaning the method.

Ice, I'm not the doc, bu you're becoming quite the expert on how folks should and shouldn't behave as power roles.... Maybe you should have given yourself some advice last game, when as a power role, you willingly switched sides and shafted the townies.

If I played quiet I'd be hit or lynched right away. I tried to lay low the start of the game and was being called on it. I've played outfront to many games to change now I guess.

My thoughts on who's who:

Swayde - New school mafia
ogre - old school mafia
Dangerdoll - dead - o.s. mafia
lady g - detective
jpappy - thief?
madcrawdad - o.s. mafia
clown lover - almost dead - mafia
cooldude - new school mafia
johnlarson66 - doc
jensons - blackmailer
blueiz - new school mafia
deputychief - new school mafia
judgemax - innocent
ice - ?
hooked newbie - dead- innocent
dwarf puffers - ?
djmajor - dead - innocent
charlie stubbs- dead- innocent

Who would you change me and/or DP with and on which team if you thought one of us was mafia? How is it possible for us to be question marks if you have your mafia players?

I don't think Ogre and Mad are both mafia on the same team.

I'm leaning to

OLD- DD CL Ogre Blue

New- JM DP Sway DC

I just thought that this was interesting...

Pretty funny I thought too. Not claiming innocence anymore but I'm innocent lol

 

[OgreMkV]

Just a notice here, but JMax and JL seem to be reinforcing each other and with nothing more than a feeling... that's kind of odd to me.

 

[OgreMkV]

I guess I should add with the me/Ice thing.

 

[johnlarson66]

Just a notice here, but JMax and JL seem to be reinforcing each other and with nothing more than a feeling... that's kind of odd to me.

You feel that our feelings are odd? That hurts my feelings.

 

[IceH2O]

edit not Sway I meant Jensons.

I was wondering why she put Sway as mafia and JM as innocent when I was posting.

 

[judgemax]

I don't know why I do that, I'm just meaning get. I'm not even meaning the method.



If I played quiet I'd be hit or lynched right away. I tried to lay low the start of the game and was being called on it. I've played outfront to many games to change now I guess.



Who would you change me and/or DP with and on which team if you thought one of us was mafia? How is it possible for us to be question marks if you have your mafia players?

I don't think Ogre and Mad are both mafia on the same team.

I'm leaning to

OLD- DD CL Ogre BlueI would switch blue and add jensons here

New- JM DP Sway DCi would take me out, add blue, and maybe cooldude, he always seems to appear, just when he needs to, nothing like a nudge that says they are talking get out there.




Pretty funny I thought too. Not claiming innocence anymore but I'm innocent lol

I hate that I can't just type in someone else's quote, i always have to write something down here to.