Mafia #14 -- The Play

[johnlarson66]

CL, can you clarify this post? It sounds like you're saying that if DP is mafia, let's keep him around. If we think he's a townie, let's get rid of him....

Is this the "pocket mafia" tactic?

It appears that DP has voted, so they will not die and UD.

Maybe we can get some better input from DP.

At this point, I would be okay with a day one lynching of any of the following:

Charlie
Judge
DP
Lady G

 

[clown-lover]

And I dont really understand your second response, I never questioned the list I infact agreed with it. All I said after that was that I like the list but I do not like how everyone seems to be agreeing with those same suspects. Although it is night 1 and there is not a whole lot to go on I still think people who appear too friendly and agreeable right off the bat are mafia trying to blend in with the town who ends up butting heads with one another and picking each other off the first few nights...

Ok I see what you are saying now.. And what I meant oveall is that his list has possibilities.. Not that I agree with everyone on it, but there is one or two that I consider of merit.

 

[jpappy789]

Is this the "pocket mafia" tactic?

It appears that DP has voted, so they will not die and UD.

Maybe we can get some better input from DP.

At this point, I would be okay with a day one lynching of any of the following:

Charlie
Judge
DP
Lady G

Sort of appears that way...personally I think any good mafia is a dead mafia. If he is mafia he's not doing them any good, but he would be if the town kept him around long enough for the mafia to win...and it's not like he is hurting the town or his mafia team which ever side he is really on. I agree w/ Lg that it comes down to numbers...

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Well, I'm off to bed. My vote stands and unless something rather spectacular happens tomorrow, it will stay where it is. See y'all tomorrow evening. Keep kicking!

 

[johnlarson66]

Ok, guy's with 2 teams of Mafia..I think we may have a good chance of lynching one, if we (innocents) work together. Day one always seems to turn into a free for all and the mafia get a free ride. They have an advantage,
though in this game with 2 teams. I can say when I played the games with CIA/FBI and Old/New Mafia...being on the bad side was easy to look innocent since you could really look for baddies and "appear" to be innocent.
I ususally wait until later in day one to vote, because I like to see who votes who and reactions to these votes. But with haveing the 2 teams I think things are different, so I am going to get a vote out there.

For now I Vote to lynch Jmax, this is obviously subject to change. At this point if I were to change it would be to Charlie or JL I believe.

Yes Dp is still out there for me, but for now I think there are bigger and better because I'm almost positive he will "forget" to vote one night and suffer a UD. I realize he is not helping the town if he is innocent...but he is still a number and I would not want to take him out right now because of that. This game is all about numbers in the end, IF he is innocent, no he is of no help as far as finding Mafia...but he is a number.

I agree that the two teams can just sit back and watch. I was on a bad side, I think I was FBI. We mostly killed CIA. I was kinda glad to kill the other rebel team. Looking back, I was not good for my own rebel team.

I am curious of why you would change to me, besides having you on my top four list, I do not know what I have done.

I also agree that DP will most likely "forget" to vote. If not, I think either DP will get more involved or will be lynched.

 

[clown-lover]

I also agree that DP will most likely "forget" to vote. If not, I think either DP will get more involved or will be lynched.

DP has voted for HN.. Did you not see the post where HN stated basically How typical??

 

[clown-lover]

mad.. did I answer your question???

 

[Lady G]

CL, can you clarify this post? It sounds like you're saying that if DP is mafia, let's keep him around. If we think he's a townie, let's get rid of him....

Hey, Mad how do you post a quote inside a quote??

Funny you should mention that Lady G... Something I noticed about Judge is that she tends to use 'LMAO' ALOT when she plays scum. Kind of a nervous laugh I guess. I've actually been watching for it. I've seen it a few times so far, but nothing worth lynching on at this point.

With that said, when someone has a certain scumtell, it's not a good idea to broadcast it in the thread on Day 1. Pretty much makes that tell useless.

Yeah, I thought about that AFTER I posted it...I'm horrible about posting what I think at the time and not thinking first:duh: It was just something that really stood out to me when she was mafia before and I noticed it now.

 

[johnlarson66]

DP has voted for HN.. Did you not see the post where HN stated basically How typical??

I pointed out that they voted.

I meant in later days.

Skimming?

 

[clown-lover]

I pointed out that they voted.

I meant in later days.

Skimming?

Ok.. NO not skimming but I didn't see that part in your post and am not good at reading between the lines sometimes. :duh: