Mafia #14 -- The Play

djmajor said:
I would believe you may be innocent for sure but wrong on the topic of newbie :) I am just seeing alot of accusations and some definite team playing
Click to expand...

So point out your observations. If you are a townie, you should be sharing your thoughts and point of view with the rest of the town.
 
jpappy789 said:
woah djmajor you are insinuating quite a lot...first you say hn is innocent "fore sure" and then you think me and Chas are a team? care to share some evidence to back up your observations???
Click to expand...

Read more carefully Jpappy. He was replying to JL.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
I'm trying to put a full list together, but there are a few that are more gut feel than anything else and I hate saying "I just have a feeling". Still trying to connect some dots. Appreciate the list though. I think everyone should post their thoughts and suspects.
Click to expand...

Well, I was thinking about this myself since I was hit by mafia first night last game...I am a little paranoid and was thinking I should but my feeling out there just in case. Most are mainly "feelings" some have true meaning behind them. but here is what I see so far. I am going to do a numbered list at this point, since it is day one. 1 is innocent 10 mafia.

Swayde-6

Ogre-7

DD-6/7

JPap-3/4

Mad-4/5

CL-5

Cooldude-6

JL-7

Jensons-8

Blue-8

DC-5

Ice-6/7

HN-3/4

Dp-7/8

DJ-5

CS-8/9

Jmax-9

LG-1

Of coarse if I am not hit tonight and am still here tomorrow, these may change as things come about.
 
Madcrawdad said:
I disagree with you here, JL.... as the game progresses, it becomes beneficial for the townies to come together and focus their voting in the later days of the game. On Day 1, I would highly caution against the town voting together....the mafia's not going to lynch their own, so everyone piling on the same person is unlikely to lead to lynching a mafia member.
Click to expand...

Hooked Newbie said:
I see your point here Mad and would completely agree if there were only one team of mafia. With 2 teams, even a "train" can present information based on timing and swings in vote count. The way I see it, if the town puts a few votes on someone from team A, team B may be late to the station in order to blend in and since they don't know the other mafia team they may be satisfied with getting rid of a POSSIBLE innocent. At the same time team A may be busy presenting cases and votes for another to save their own.
Click to expand...

On day one, I do not think a mafia member would vote for anyone on their own team. I also think the team would want to point in another direction.

I do not see anyone coming to Charlie's aid. Someone was accused of doing that, I need to double check, earlier, but since his "I am gonna UD myself post, no one has come near him.

I did pull my vote off of him, but there are plenty on him. He is most likely my top suspect. I wish he would post for himself. What is odd also, I do not see the DangerDoll drama with Charlie this game. A few games back she was all torn to vote him and last game she was fooled by him. There was a "sigh" quote or something.

Even though my vote is on DP, I will stand behind voting for Charlie. They both have created problems for themselves and both seem to be playing anti-town.

I know that my random votes on day one have not been good for the town in the past, so I think voting "with" others is better for the town than being a lone vote. I can see how if it is 17 - 1 how the town learns nothing also. I do not think we will see that. If the vote is close (and it was) then the same team mafia will have to vote for the other vote getter to take the votes off of their teamate.
 
too many people are asking for hit, regular towns folk are just watching and hearing the talk on the streets, I am inside chasing two little boys and will be here till there is the hit and it will be a good hit i am sure with the group of experienced players
 
djmajor said:
sounds very much like team here, like you and Charlie
Click to expand...
WOW, quite the accusation to just "throw out there" DJ.

Hooked Newbie said:
Read more carefully Jpappy. He was replying to JL.
Click to expand...
Did I miss something there HN? Dj had quoted Jpap, how was it meant for JL? Please show me what I missed.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Read more carefully Jpappy. He was replying to JL.
Click to expand...

got it...i was confused because you quoted him, i thought you were responding to him, i should have read more carefully...my mistake. still it doesn't matter who I still think the fact that he said he would "believe you to be innocent for sure if you were not wrong on the topic of newbie" is still a little too much...maybe just my opinion but then he thinks me and chas are on the same team? how?
 
djmajor said:
too many people are asking for hit, regular towns folk are just watching and hearing the talk on the streets, I am inside chasing two little boys and will be here till there is the hit and it will be a good hit i am sure with the group of experienced players
Click to expand...

what about the lynch? do you think that is good? why the comment on the hit...what made it necessary to say...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom