Mafia #14 -- The Play

[judgemax]

Since you decided to reference this, I decided to read back through it. You've repeatedly said that you don't know how people play, but yet you point out that Charlie can never be trusted. Isn't that true of everyone in this game? I think there's been alot more info brought out since post 410, but you reference only this? Where's your vote currently?

this is what I have been saying when it came to her, and no one else paid attention, I am glad she did it again, so some one else caught it, I feel like someone else is paraphrasing for her. she speaks like she has played several games, and this is her first. Either she is a closet mafia reader, or mafia, being coached.

 

[jpappy789]

Jpap,You mean ones like this?

Yea I would definitely add that to my collection of suspcios posts by dj also his post about me and chas being on a team...which he still hasnt fully addressed...must have realized his mistake

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I am here. I am reading the posts.

I will not die an untimely death. I appreciate the townies thoughts on this issue. Not a good idea. Got it.

I did not propose this plan to be unsportsmanlike. Please understand, I was thinking (admittedly not carefully) about what is best for the town. Keep in mind, when i was the snitch, I even lied to my teamates about my role, as to do otherwise was in violation of the games rules. I am unwilling to go outside of the rules of the game in an effort to win. I would not like it if that is what people thought i was trying to do.

I will re read the thread, more carefully and look for clues. I will vote before nightfalls.

 

[judgemax]

I think the dj thing is only coming out, because he is a scape goat, ...something isn't right in wonderland

 

[Madcrawdad]

Normally they wouldn't and might not be right now but with 2 teams we don't know that Team B isn't on Charlie and Team A is spread out.

Also a chance that they are also afraid to not be on Charlie and write him off as a lost cause.

With 9 people on Charlie I doubt all the mafia players are on him so I'd imagine if he shows mafia that his buddies are the ones spread out onto other players. If Chas shows mafia, another good place to look for suspects would be anyone hopping on Chas after his back was broken... while Chas has been a suspect for awhile, there was a really late movement of votes onto him.
If he shows innocent then we have to look at the people that either started the Charlie train or the ones that finished it. Not expecting that we'll have to do this.

Ice, thoughts in blue above...

 

[Hooked Newbie]

As far as I can see, DJ may have been an attempted save. Not enough bit on it and now Charlie will vote. We may have forced their hand well enough to have two night's worth of scum. (fingers crossed)

 

[Dangerdoll]

Getting very chilling and reading all this going back and forth will enabe me to shut up and get out of view. If anybody can help me with my choices please help me.

OMG it is getting worse and worse for you, dj. First you sputter something off in "hitting" and now you are confessing that you are "going to shut up and get out of view"?? you are new but I am with everyone else, this is looking very mafiaish and think that we should concentrate on dj some for after nights conversation. I don't think anything good can come out of switching votes, it may just be what the mafia wants. Last game, I changed a lot late night and it did me no good but did the witches grand.

 

[IceH2O]

I think the dj thing is only coming out, because he is a scape goat, ...something isn't right in wonderland

Don't see how that helps the mafia. All it does is give us a lynch for tomorrow.

 

[judgemax]

OMG it is getting worse and worse for you, dj. First you sputter something off in "hitting" and now you are confessing that you are "going to shut up and get out of view"?? you are new but I am with everyone else, this is looking very mafiaish and think that we should concentrate on dj some for after nights conversation. I don't think anything good can come out of switching votes, it may just be what the mafia wants. Last game, I changed a lot late night and it did me no good but did the witches grand.

I did the same, in the last few games. I decided to not try the late night swing, unless its really needed to push an absolute mafia out the door.

 

[judgemax]

Don't see how that helps the mafia. All it does is give us a lynch for tomorrow.

yes, I agree, but, he comes out saying things, that make us extremely suspicious, enough so, to maybe swing votes his way ,rather than charlie, ..ie:decoy. I can't believe you needed this explained?...