Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Hooked Newbie]

Ok, Ice I missed how that could be taken I guess...sorry about that. I did find it odd that they both went after her at that point. What I meant by Charlie being Charlie was simply I've seen him do this many times, come out and accuse out of nowhere...not that I don't think him mafia or not suspicious for doing so, he is hard for me to get a grip on sometimes. Do you not think he is playing like "Charlie"?
I wasn't really contradiciting I don't think...can't I find it odd for them to do that, while still seeing the fact he is playing like himself (good or bad)?

The difference this game IMHO is that he didn't accuse out of no where, he agreed with someone who did. When has Charlie ever agreed with someone on Day 1? Who has he actually accused this game? I can't find anyone.

 

[judgemax]

Thanks for the advice. I was posting at the same time, but I've read them since and your response to Ice doesn't address all of my concerns.
Seriously? We'll be down a townie? I guess we should all just take that tidbit as gospel and assume you're telling the truth huh? Any suspects besides those that you expect? C'mon, since you think so much like Rb, you should be able to name them right?

ok. point taken, lol, i always hate when other people preach their innocence, and here I am doing it. give me a few need to check the players roster, to make sure I don't over look anyone. , and I will give you my best educated guess as to who I think he has where, ..

Ummm, Jmax..I think you should add me to that list. At this point you are standing out pretty big to me also. Your responses bring goosebumps to me and alarms are going off with each post of yours.honestly, I thought I had.

I think at this point I am leaning you Highest up there right now, with Charlie and Dp following right behind. Although this is pretty early still in day 1 and everything is subject to change.

Again, I always look guilty to all of the more experienced players, the same as you all look guilty to me.

 

[Blueiz]

You pegged me becasue I am smart and because YOU think that you think like RB..some pretty solid reasons there.

I guess time will tell. no, not I am not defensive, many of the other players know when I am defensive, and this, is not it.

are you admitting it?

I am smart, and YOU said that you think like RB(

i happen to think, that RB and I think very similar

)... I see no room for admitting things that are known facts.

It's really not a smart idea for words to be taken out of context, nor use partiall sentences to read as you want them to.

As usual, grasping blindly at straws.

 

[judgemax]

OK, heres who I would put in mafia, and what school.


OLD School:
Jensons
OGRE
JL
DP

NEW :
blue
swayde
lady G
and possibly DD

I would also In my head, make HN, chas, or jpap as the dons..of which I am not sure.

now, I am curious to see how close I really am, I may have the "schools" wrong, but I bet I have a good 75% mafia right

 

[Madcrawdad]

HEY HEY ALL! I am so ready to play! I am hoping to last more than a day or two this time! LMAO, welcome to the game blue!
Its nifty that we are now a sticky! yay, easy looking now!
welcome back jensons! It will be good to play with you again!

For the simple fact that blue is smart, and new, I expect her to be mafia, because RB is smart enough to know you will all leave the newbies alone, ...I vote to lynch BLUE..no hard feelings blue, its the first day, and its subject to change as always!

Early vote simply because Blue is smart & new. You expect her to be mafia?

i think blueiz is a scumbag.

i think this because as we all know, the "random" role assignment is sometimes tweaked.

people will accuse me of going after the newbs.

they will be my next suspects.

You think she's a scumbag based on what really? That the role assignments may be "tweaked"? Or that it was the first "case" available to jump on?

Still not a lot of posts. Here's one that I found interesting, though. In JudgeMax's first post of the game, she actually tosses a vote. Not just a random vote to start discussion, but she actually claims that she expects Blueiz to be mafia.

Keep in mind that at this point, Blue had posted 'hello,' and that's it. Yet Judge thinks she's mafia because she believes that rb is hand-picking the roles and that he would give Blue a mafia role.

Kind of an anti-town post...

I would have liked this post had it not come immediately (15 minutes) behind Charlie's.

HN, I find this post interesting. You claim that you would have liked my post, but find the timing suspect. Apparently you liked it enough, that you basically regurgitated it (including casting suspicion on Charlie) in your post.

Also interesting that you're also trying to link Clown Lover and me, as CL agreed with my assessment.....since you followed Clown Lover by 10 hours or so in agreeing with me (even though you find the timing of my post suspect), I think that it's possible that you and CL are linked....

If you find a particular post suspicious, it's probably not a good idea to lift the ideas from that post.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

HN, I find this post interesting. You claim that you would have liked my post, but find the timing suspect. Apparently you liked it enough, that you basically regurgitated it (including casting suspicion on Charlie) in your post.

Also interesting that you're also trying to link Clown Lover and me, as CL agreed with my assessment.....since you followed Clown Lover by 10 hours or so in agreeing with me (even though you find the timing of my post suspect), I think that it's possible that you and CL are linked....

If you find a particular post suspicious, it's probably not a good idea to lift the ideas from that post.

Mad- Not all of us have the ability to be on throughout the day. I merely posted my logic and things that I found as possibilities, Have you read the posts since I made this one?

 

[judgemax]

I am smart, and YOU said that you think like RB()... I see no room for admitting things that are known facts.I am not denying saying I think we think similar?...was never stating as a fact, just that I think so. maybe you should see below and read your own advice.

It's really not a smart idea for words to be taken out of context, nor use partiall sentences to read as you want them to. read back, everyone does, it,. ...I was just questioning why you phrased that sentence that way?..It seemed to me that you were inadvertently admitting That i "pegged" you.

As usual, grasping blindly at straws.

and, yes, I am sure you can use those words,roflmao, because you have played so many of these with me?...:raspberry:

 

[IceH2O]

OK, heres who I would put in mafia, and what school.


OLD School:
Jensons
OGRE
JL
DP

NEW :
blue
swayde
lady G
and possibly DD

I would also In my head, make HN, chas, or jpap as the dons..of which I am not sure.

now, I am curious to see how close I really am, I may have the "schools" wrong, but I bet I have a good 75% mafia right

That would make it 10 mafia vs 8 innocents, not plausible at all.

Anyone can throw out a list of 8 players and have some of them right. Half the town is mafia. The odds are great to be hitting one tonight. Another reason why night 1 in this game is not totally random.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

OK, heres who I would put in mafia, and what school.


OLD School:
Jensons
OGRE
JL
DP

NEW :
blue
swayde
lady G
and possibly DD

I would also In my head, make HN, chas, or jpap as the dons..of which I am not sure.

now, I am curious to see how close I really am, I may have the "schools" wrong, but I bet I have a good 75% mafia right

So, you have 6 out of 8 listed? Wow, that would be a day 1 record easy! If I'm to believe or place weight on this list, I know the two Dons.

 

[judgemax]

That would make it 10 mafia vs 8 innocents, not plausible at all.

Anyone can throw out a list of 8 players and have some of them right. Half the town is mafia. The odds are great to be hitting one tonight. Another reason why night 1 in this game is not totally random.

Not saying they are perfect, just whom I would make mafia as my choices, ..I honestly have no idea how many there are ...just those would be my top choices for mafia. and I am saying 75% not 50.