In the Werewolf game I saw DP viewing the thread for awhile, he never posted. I finally called him on it and he went away. That was on Day 1, he got lynched because of it and was a Werewolf.
Mafia #14 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
In the Werewolf game I saw DP viewing the thread for awhile, he never posted. I finally called him on it and he went away. That was on Day 1, he got lynched because of it and was a Werewolf.
sigh...this is a very interesting day to say the least...but here are my thoughts on pretty much everyone
Chas's UD thing has me worried. Usually he is all over anyone who even votes for him, even when he is innocent, but now he is going "sacrifice" himself for the town!? trying to seem noble and buy yourself another day puny waterboy? not a good idea imo and I think a townie would recognize that.
Dp...its hard to pinpoint where he is going sometimes, especially with all the vote changing and then the KOTD style response to the votes.
Lg does seem all over the place but not sure how much of that I can attribute to her being scummy or her playing aggressive as usual
the blueiz vs. jm debate seemed to have quieted down. Both appear mafia to me just based on reactions and such but I do not feel comfortable with a vote on either of them
Dj's last post kinda reminded me of bluerat last game with that last post of theirs...not sure what the heck that is supposed to mean or who that is directed towards...but a newb so I will cut them SOME slack but not much after last game
Of course I am still a little wary of a few people in particular: DD, Ogre, HN, Mad, Ice...well you all know the list. All are appearing helpful but with the number of mafia in this game there is a good chance that the majority are going to be mafia so I can't trust any of them at this point. Swayde also plays very well and I always want to expect that she is innocent but I have to tell myself that there are no guarantees in this game so my eyes will be open.
I would have to agree that cl and jensons will be tough to figure out this time because they have not played fo a while now. Sometimes cl doesn't really make sense and jensons, well, nothing seems weird from her yet.
jl and dc are acting normal but I still have to question their motives as usual because their laid back style usually is a cover for anything else they are doing behind our backs...
cooldude is a newb so not sure what to think there...
All in all I find Charlie the most scummy, soooooo...
I vote to lynch Charlie Stubbs
Chas's UD thing has me worried. Usually he is all over anyone who even votes for him, even when he is innocent, but now he is going "sacrifice" himself for the town!? trying to seem noble and buy yourself another day puny waterboy? not a good idea imo and I think a townie would recognize that.
Dp...its hard to pinpoint where he is going sometimes, especially with all the vote changing and then the KOTD style response to the votes.
Lg does seem all over the place but not sure how much of that I can attribute to her being scummy or her playing aggressive as usual
the blueiz vs. jm debate seemed to have quieted down. Both appear mafia to me just based on reactions and such but I do not feel comfortable with a vote on either of them
Dj's last post kinda reminded me of bluerat last game with that last post of theirs...not sure what the heck that is supposed to mean or who that is directed towards...but a newb so I will cut them SOME slack but not much after last game
Of course I am still a little wary of a few people in particular: DD, Ogre, HN, Mad, Ice...well you all know the list. All are appearing helpful but with the number of mafia in this game there is a good chance that the majority are going to be mafia so I can't trust any of them at this point. Swayde also plays very well and I always want to expect that she is innocent but I have to tell myself that there are no guarantees in this game so my eyes will be open.
I would have to agree that cl and jensons will be tough to figure out this time because they have not played fo a while now. Sometimes cl doesn't really make sense and jensons, well, nothing seems weird from her yet.
jl and dc are acting normal but I still have to question their motives as usual because their laid back style usually is a cover for anything else they are doing behind our backs...
cooldude is a newb so not sure what to think there...
All in all I find Charlie the most scummy, soooooo...
I vote to lynch Charlie Stubbs
Ok, home from work early.:dance2:
Some interesting stuff to read through today. My initial thoughts after reading through are as follows.
Charlie still seems the best choice for mafia for me. The proposed plan cannot possibly help the town as others have already pointed out. The main curiousity to me is the late swing onto DP. I agree that he's not a bad choice, but I don't believe he's the best choice. I think this may be either an effort by Carlie's team to save him or the other mafia team going somewhere safe. 5 people still haven't voted which means that tonight's lynching is far from determined. If those not voting are townies please make sure to get one in before nightfall! If you're mafia, feel free to skip tonight.
I'm going to go back through and try to post a list of possible suspects. Until I see someone better, my vote stays on the Waterboy.
Some interesting stuff to read through today. My initial thoughts after reading through are as follows.
Charlie still seems the best choice for mafia for me. The proposed plan cannot possibly help the town as others have already pointed out. The main curiousity to me is the late swing onto DP. I agree that he's not a bad choice, but I don't believe he's the best choice. I think this may be either an effort by Carlie's team to save him or the other mafia team going somewhere safe. 5 people still haven't voted which means that tonight's lynching is far from determined. If those not voting are townies please make sure to get one in before nightfall! If you're mafia, feel free to skip tonight.
I'm going to go back through and try to post a list of possible suspects. Until I see someone better, my vote stays on the Waterboy.
I don't see how this helps the town at all. If we lynch you we lose a townie, if you are one, and the mafia hit someone. Worst case is 2 townies lost. If you UD then we lose you could lynch a 2nd and then lose to a hit. Thats 3 townies.
Was an innocent question, wanted to see what DC would reply with. I don't think JL is mafia at this point. JM is mafia, I believe, and it could be sort of a latching onto JL in case he is hit and shows innocent. But in either case it was weak reasoning, more for response then votes.
Explained in the post to LG
While I was reading the thread I was thinking about Charlie and DP. Charlie could be faking a UD. If we think he is going to die then all the votes would fall onto DP.
At this point and because of Charlies plan I think DP could be innocent and Charlies fake out will get DP killed, though Charlie would go tomorrow, but it gives them numbers and time for an investigation.
For this reason I retract my vote on LG and vote to lynch Charlie
Not that I think LG is any less mafia IMO.
I have 3 non-voters according to my records so far. Blueiz, Clown Lover, and DJmajor. I hope the newbies understand they have to vote or they will die an untimely death (UD). Clown Lover hopefully noticed the change in rules as well. Of course if their mafia, the more that don't vote, the better for us =)
I believe there are 4. Charlie retracted, Blue, Majr, and Mad. I could be wrong though, I'm still updating my notes from the postings today.
I had actually not considered that possible Strategy...CS threatening an UD to get votes off him and onto DP. It is possible. But, they could still be both be mafia, just on 2 different teams. Seems like a risky ploy. There didnt' seem to be very many votes on DP at the time CS posted his UD plan either. I don't like CS's plan at all, but if he's going to UD himself, then I don't see any point in voting for him when there are so many mafia floating around. I just can't fathom Charlie's motivation, I've never seen him do anything like this before and I just don't know what to make of it.
