Mafia #14 -- The Play

[IceH2O]

Yes Ice, I do remember this, but the question I have is, has this ever happened in any game? Like I mentioned in an earlier post, people are always talking about the 'sacrificial lamb.' I don't believe that there's been a game here on AC where the sacrificial lamb has actually materialized.

I'm not sure myself if its ever been used but there is a 1st time for anything. If there was a good time to do it this would have been it. Let a newb die and save an experienced player.

When DJ started babbling his nuttiness, you said something to the fact that it helped confirm your vote for Charlie.

Because of the thought sated above


Here's a quote where you're explaining that DJ is now the sacrificial lamb to take the heat off of LG. Your assumptions were off with the DJ/Chas link, so why are you now trying to link this babbling newbie to LG, claiming that he's once again the sacrificial lamb? This guy (DJ) seems to be making it awfully convenient for you to finger more experienced players...

Sorry did you assume DJ was innocent? By my account you also had a vote on him. I thought LG was mafia, I was wrong.


Even here in an earlier post, where JL questions why mafia players aren't coming to Chas' rescue on Day 1, you explain that the other mafia players wouldn't want to expose themselves. I think that most of the regular players here would agree that you don't come running to a mafia teammate's rescue on Day 1, so why assume that the mafia would start exposing themselves so openly on Day 1, especially when if you think Chas had said something so awful you'd just take both of them down anyway?

Alread y explained it above. I'll add that it isn't to hard in the early going to get lost in the mix of players. If Charlie could have stayed out of the spotlight he might have slipped through the cracks. You know I've answered all these already right?



Finally, just curious as to why you still have me leaning mafia. Apparently I made it there in the first place, because I didn't vote for Chas. Then you claimed you understood why I didn't. Then you even started moving Chas voters onto your newer lists. You're not just keeping me there so if I start questioning you again, you can say 'Mafia! Mafia!' again, are you?

Mostly because I have a hard time reading you. Probably the same reason you think I am.

ok, so not much has materialized, besides DD's silly accusations, ( not saying they couldn't be mafia) , but they just seem desperate,

on the other hand, could this be "distancing", since she is doing it so sarcastically, maybe they are rolling the dice, thinking we will all exclude ICE, and Ogre off the lists for awhile?..would be a smart tactic?....hmmmm.,....I still think RB picked those roles, and that would be one hell of a team.

Don't know about Ogre but I can say I'm not on anyones team that is able to communicate.

OI posted number four becuase there has been mention of an argument off site, and dd keeps posting weird stuff about talking somewhere else with LG.

I wouldnt call it back peddling, more like something struck me that was really weird and I just put my finger on it. I am not saying anything about anyone. Im simply putting thoughts out here to get views on them. I retracted my vote for dd becaues at this time Im not sure this is not a ploy of some sort. What in the world it could be, Im not sure...why im posting my thoughts out.

DD is implying that her and LG are on the same mafia team which allows them to speak.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I said why i asked about the dr. To see what the reaction would be.

A stunt? I only posted my thoughts and asked what everyone else thought of them to bring a clearer understanding to myself and possibly bring out something that has not been looked it...

Theres a first time for everything.

As for your doc response, 'setting a trap' always seems too convenient of an explanation when someone 'steps in it.'

With regard to your questioning DD's guilt/innocence, I'll explain something to you. This game feeds into the townie's paranoia. Even when something seems to be a 'done-deal,' all it usually takes to get some townies to question everything all over again is someone (usually the mafia) whispering 'Psst, you could be making a big mistake.'

Fortunately, DD has ADMITTED to being mafia. So the fact you're whispering that she might be innocent will not influence anybody.

 

[Blueiz]

As for your doc response, 'setting a trap' always seems too convenient of an explanation when someone 'steps in it.'

With regard to your questioning DD's guilt/innocence, I'll explain something to you. This game feeds into the townie's paranoia. Even when something seems to be a 'done-deal,' all it usually takes to get some townies to question everything all over again is someone (usually the mafia) whispering 'Psst, you could be making a big mistake.'

Fortunately, DD has ADMITTED to being mafia. So the fact you're whispering that she might be innocent will not influence anybody.

Point me to where I have said that DD is innocent.

 

[Blueiz]

to add to the above, or where I have inferred or insinuated that she is.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Point me to where I have said that DD is innocent.

to add to the above, or where I have inferred or insinuated that she is.

You pulled your vote off of her. Also said that she may be trying to draw the mafia out....only an innocent would do that.

 

[IceH2O]

to add to the above, or where I have inferred or insinuated that she is.

Pulling your vote insinuates it I believe.

From reading you past posts it seems you think its a mafia ploy between 2 players against the town. If you believe this then why remove your vote from DD as she has to be mafia.

Your squabbling with LG I can understand if you believe them to be playing the town but from responses I'm sure its not as you think.

 

[IceH2O]

You pulled your vote off of her. Also said that she may be trying to draw the mafia out....only an innocent would do that.

????? slip????

 

[IceH2O]

Ok I think I know what you meant there.

Only an innocent person would try to pull the mafia out.

DD has already admitted to being mafia.

For some reason I thought the last part of the post was about Blue.

 

[Blueiz]

You pulled your vote off of her. Also said that she may be trying to draw the mafia out....only an innocent would do that.

I explained why i pulled my vote off of her, I want input from others on my thoughts before my casting my vote. Same reason why I posted my thoughts of why she may be doing what she is, for imput . Theres a differnce in having a thought and thinking something. Im looking all the way around, not focusing on her saying she is mafia. As I posted, the way it all came out is very weird..

 

[Blueiz]

Pulling your vote insinuates it I believe.

From reading you past posts it seems you think its a mafia ploy between 2 players against the town. If you believe this then why remove your vote from DD as she has to be mafia.

Your squabbling with LG I can understand if you believe them to be playing the town but from responses I'm sure its not as you think.[/quote]


Can you clarify what you mean there?