Mafia #15....The Play....

[brains2]

As far as being "indecisive", I wasn't sure about your guilt or innocence. The entire thing was confusing. That's why I posted the question to Rb. I did not speculate before he confirmed it was possible. To me it was (and still is) proven that you editted. Indecisive? My vote has been where I first put it after making my case for Ogre. I'm not sticking up for anyone, nor do I have any "buddies" except for those that help find mafia.

Oh yeah, you may want to let your wife know that she needs to vote. :silly:

I'm considering removing you from my list, you must be an innocent, you are way to confused to do the Mafia any good.
Oh and by the way HN, I'm Female... :silly:

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I'm considering removing you from my list, you must be an innocent, you are way to confused to do the Mafia any good.
Oh and by the way HN, I'm Female... :silly:

Thanks, but I really don't care if I'm on your list or not. My "job" is to vote for who I think is mafia and post what I can to help the town. Why was your list only of people who entered into the Weezer debate? No other suspicions or just defensive by nature? As far as being female, why bother making that declaration besides again trying to defend against being Weezer? At this point I don't care who you are, you've not been very pro-town IMO.

 

[bkw1982]

I vote to lynch Brains2

The more he post the more i wanna vote for em. this is my best pick right now and prob wont change.

Now im off to go get ready for the Pat v Colt game. GO COLTS!!

 

[IceH2O]

I have to say I thought it was odd but that weezer was posting in the thread and not being deleted but that was as far as it went - I didn't register weezer as brains until re-reading the thread today.

Don't know what it means. Weezer = clearly brains for some reason, and apparently brains was told to remain anonymous. It could as likely be an innocent-friendly game stunt by rb as a mafia-friendly one.

So here you admit you know that weezer is brains.

Then you claim it doesn't mean anything one way or the other that he could be innocent or mafia ( no ****). But from reading his posts and denying over and over and trying to implicate I'm lying doesn't equate mafia to you?

hmmmm...I've been thinking about the brains/weezer thing...

1) brains is weezer - that seems to be a given
2) I kinda feel that rb may have put weezer in as brains to get away from the whole 'a & b live together so they are both mafia/both innocent etc. etc. It would have made weezer & mee-mee's lives easier without having to fool with the sacred random number generator. It's just a possibility. If it's true then weezer was just kinda blushing for blowing his own cover.
3) Other possibility - there is some significance in brains being the unknown player of which we are not aware. I think this is less likely myself but that's really only my gut.

Final thought on this...if it is an innocent explanation (and I don't care what anyone says that is at least plausible) then you have to kind of look at Ice who jumped all over it, and I must say I have/had Ice down as innocent except for this.

I will unvote plantling for the moment while I think a little more.

I agree with the 1st 2.


Do you seriously think your final thought is even plausible?

I showed the original post. I then put up both his posts including the edited version and his 2nd post that followed is chastising me for lying to the town.Id weezer isn't playing why is he giving the town direction. He shouldn't have said anything. He still hadn't switched over to brains and posted under his SN again.

Hmmm, I'm wondering do we have a "team" here?


For one, Blue and Brains could easily both be mafia...just different teams.
For two, she could be trying to look helpful by doing this...ppl would think/say "why would she do that if she was mafia"

I skimmed nothing Ice, you were very good at catching it, and made a very good case about it, just another reason, I saw no reason for Blue to do that.

Yes you did make the case, I believe you and it is very obvious. Not sure it MAKES him mafia, not sure it makes him innocent. But yes, I believe him to be one in the same.


Why are you so offended DD, did I name one of your teamies? Yes ppl asked and Rb could of answered it IF it really needed addressed, there was no reason for her to go and do that, plain and simple.

Actually DD, I have said something about Rb doing that before.

I am freaking about nothing DD, I just saw no reason for her to take it upon herself to do that. Yes, I believe it shows her mafia, trying to look innocent.



It had already been concluded that they were one in the same Blue.

Very interesting who came to your defense on this matter.

I'm guessing Ice Blue DD is the team. Well if their trying to oust mafia also then I welcome them.

Well guy's I have to go to work, and I need a vote in before I go b/c I most likely wont be back on until close to nightfall.

There is only one person I really feel SCREAMS mafia and that would be Ogre. Yes, I believe Blues move shows scumness to it, but a vote her way would do nothing. We have to remember we have 9 mafia on this game and everyone jumping on the same person shows us nothing.

There is just too much against Ogre and as much as I hate a entire town vote on one person, I do believe we have a mafia member here.

Sorry I haven't been much help so far this game it's been very busy around here and I will be able to play more after today.

Anyway I vote to lynch Ogre

So if everyone piles on 1 player it doesn't help us but then you pile on?

Are you so sure that no one would follow you to Blue because you have no case?

If you were smart you'd have jumped on me since I'm mafia in your eyes made it 4 votes and had the rest of your crew jump on also. Or would that show to much?

I don't think any mod would take that chance and jeopardize the game, On the other hand it dose appear that she is siding with ICE..



She just may have been thinking out loud... Maybe..

I have done some looking into the post ICE provided, weezer doesn't have a 125 and neither do i, was this an over site by ICE ? he was the only one to supposedly see it, i think there team decided to try to eliminate any one they don't know, And yes i see ICE is not voting for me, well you go through all the work on the post and getting people wound up then step back and watch while a townie goes down, and your clean because you didn't vote for me, this is a known mafia tactic, at this time i believe ICE is Mafia.

ICE's Mafia Team
1. ICE --- for obvious reasons and deceit
2. CS --- for voting to lynch me in the beginning for no reason. {part of there plan}
3. HH --- for being so indecisive, and looking like he's sticking will his buddies.
4. Blue --- appearing to lean to ICE's side.

Because of the plot ICE and his team conjured up, and reasons stated here and before,


I VOTE TO LYNCH ICE..

To funny. I give you an A for effort though. You'll be my vote tomorrow.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I am splitting G's post up because there are a couple points I find of interest.

Hmmm, I'm wondering do we have a "team" here?

For one, Blue and Brains could easily both be mafia...just different teams.
For two, she could be trying to look helpful by doing this...ppl would think/say "why would she do that if she was mafia"

For one, there aren't 2 teams of mafia that I know of... I thought just one. Half are mafia, half are townies. 4 of each can communicate with their prospective team. which brings me to wonder.... if half are mafia, is it that only four of those mafia (which is half of them) that can communicate or is it half the mafia are communicating mafia's and half are communicating townies... rb?

Why are you so offended DD, did I name one of your teamies? Yes ppl asked and Rb could of answered it IF it really needed addressed, there was no reason for her to go and do that, plain and simple.

Actually DD, I have said something about Rb doing that before.

I am freaking about nothing DD, I just saw no reason for her to take it upon herself to do that. Yes, I believe it shows her mafia, trying to look innocent.

offended? What would give you the idea that I was offended, G? I was only explaining the point. I will also say, since you are keeping it out there, that Blue also came out with her post after rb had come out and explaned that as a mod, he cannot see if the post had been edited any more than other members can. Maybe an admin can but as mods, it cannot be done. To me, it was just confirming... as I also confirmed the point as well as one or two others. Why is it that you are on Blue about it? Funny how you are so bent about a rule being broken. This case, I don't believe it was.

hmmmm...I've been thinking about the brains/weezer thing...

1) brains is weezer - that seems to be a given
2) I kinda feel that rb may have put weezer in as brains to get away from the whole 'a & b live together so they are both mafia/both innocent etc. etc. It would have made weezer & mee-mee's lives easier without having to fool with the sacred random number generator. It's just a possibility. If it's true then weezer was just kinda blushing for blowing his own cover.
3) Other possibility - there is some significance in brains being the unknown player of which we are not aware. I think this is less likely myself but that's really only my gut.

Final thought on this...if it is an innocent explanation (and I don't care what anyone says that is at least plausible) then you have to kind of look at Ice who jumped all over it, and I must say I have/had Ice down as innocent except for this.

I will unvote plantling for the moment while I think a little more.

ok wait.... big deal if weezer and mee-mee live together, we know that brains is weezer, so it's the same difference. This doesn't mark brains on my list, it is the mere fact that he denies it while he completely got busted making a post he thought was brains but was indeed showing up as weezer...... and then comes out today saying he is a she....

 

[Rbishop]

18 players that are Townies in ACville.

9 are Innocents and 9 are Mafia.

4 of the Innocents can communicate with one another, outside the game.

4 of the Mafia can communicate with one another, outside the game.

 

[Dangerdoll]

ok, so just to confirm, then all 9 mafia are not able to communicate....?

 

[Rbishop]

Correct, only 4 of the Mafia get to communicate with one another, just as they are the only 4 to know that each other is mafia.

The same is true for the four Innocents.

 

[Rbishop]

Update, thru post 248....

To lynch...

ice (3) by capt 23 ogre 91 brains2 235

plant (1) by zsand 41

ogre (9) by hook 52 ice 64 kotd 94 cs 214 plant 216 DD 226

blueiz 230 lady 233 judge 238

lady g (1) by jl66 179

brains2 (2) by joan 239 bkw 243

16 of 18 voting....

no votes from mee-mee and Coler.....

Nightfall in just 4 hours...

 

[Coler]

I vote to lynch ice I will have to wait and see on Plantling.

I think the brains/weezer thing is a complete red herring...and ice went ott on it.

That's my vote and will almost certainly not be back on.