I decided to take a look at JL today, maybe he could be tomorrows lynch.
Maybe this will clear him...Lets find out.
I vote to lynch brains2
Now the game is going!
So this is a 1st days vote, usually means nothing. Or does it mean they aren't on his team so chances are good they are innocent and need to go.
I agree with this.
vote change
I vote for Lady G
Here he decides voting for Brains wouldn't be a good idea because Brains could be a decoy. So he switched to the other player he named LG.
Here is the string of posts.
I agree that if Brains was told to remain anonymous, then they are a decoy. Besides not knowing who Brains is, I see nothing that makes them more mafia than anyone else.
Protecting Brains. At this point the ball was just rolling on Brains and he was leading in votes. Trying to derail the train JL? Also the Ogre display was on and not a peep about Ogre or a vote for him, you went straight to LG.
We had a 50/50 chance of getting mafia this first night.
I think that if he was part of the group in the know, then they would have at least attempted to put the votes on someone else. Looking back, I am guessing he was in the group that was not in the know and was trying to reach out to them in his "red" post.
At this point, I doubt the mafia members in the know are going to do anything too rash and are going to lay back.
Not to be totally stupid, but is weezer mee-mee's husband? If mee-mee was brains2 in the zombie game, then she might know something, but also, rbishop created the name and I am sure knows the password also.
While mystery players annoy me, I am not going to stay focused on them or get side tracked.
I voted for Lady G, and I think it was a good vote. There is something about her this game that seems a little different. Call it a gut feeling.
For now I am willing to pass on Brains2 and think there are better suspects.
I vote to lynch Lady G
The 1st bolded comment was about Ogre. I myself think Ogre was part of the communicating mafia and was trying to tell the others he was mafia hoping for some feedback so they didn't hit them.
The 2nd comment did happen, they knew Ogre was caught and they sat back and let him die alone, even Ogre didn't try to save himself. Only 4 ppl weren't on Ogre I believe 3 of them to be mafia.
3rd comment is that mystery players annoy him but not to the point of sidetracking him or voting for them. This comes into play later in the post.
I see in no way there is any distancing between LG and myself. At this point she is calling me Mafia.
I have my vote on her and it is true that I have often voted for her in other games.
I have stated my feelings (one of my "real" input posts) about brains2.
I think he was told to be anonymous. Maybe he messed up. Maybe he is part of rbishops twists. Besides not knowing who they are and them trying to cover up who they are, I see nothing mafia about them.
HALF the town is mafia. The one mafia person that was caught was Ogre. Who after mee-mee is one of the worst bad guys there is. Even though last game, his team did win, but most everyone thought he was mafia.
I think the people that are pointing fingers and trying to convince others who to vote for are mafia.
I am not asking anyone to follow me on my vote for Lady G, I am not even real sure if she is mafia or not. I have a "feeling", nothing more - nothing less.
I am glad that my rp is "good". I am having fun posting it and will continue while I am still alive.
This is a strange format. I am not sure how it will work out. I am not even sure if it is a real mafia game. It is really 4 groups of people with two groups being able to talk amoung themselves. If one is not in one of the groups that can talk to each other, then they are cannon fodder.
Nothing Mafia about Brains, already into Day 2 and no mafia vibe. At this point Brains has 6 votes on him and is again leading the votes.
vote change
I vote to lynch Brains2
I do not like mystery players or the concept behind them. While I do not think that are allowed to tell the truth on who they are, I think the game will be better without such a distraction.
As far as people thinking I am mafia because of my role playing, OMGUS!
The last time I really attempted to role play was the werewolf game, I was all into it, but then ZS and company hit me.
My role playing has no bearing on me being innocent nor mafia.
Later in the Day JL has a change of heart and doesn't like Mystery players after all. Votes Brains as I believe he sees no way past it with all the talk about it.
I think anti-town is anti-town. That is why I am voting for Brains2.
It took you to late into Day 2 to figure that out? You spent 3 and a half days trying to tell us it didn't mean anything.
Yes HN i do have some what of a list going, there are 8 possible Maf. left,
I'm not sure of any just suspicions, posting tactics, demeanor's, guiding the way..
My quick list since HN asked, These players seem to be agreeing alot with a certain person, Always subject to change..
1. ICE
2.JL
3.DD
4.JO
5. ?
6. ?
7. ?
8. ?
Man of coarse this is all getting interesting when I have to head off to work. Anyway because of resent events, I think I need to rethink my list a little, I can't imagine he would name 2 of his teamies.
I will be back on but it will be late tonight.
It is a trick, of course he would name his teamates. It is called distancing.
Here is Brains list, lol. LG mentions she doesn't think Brains would list 2 of his teammates. I don't think he named team mates in the sense of talking team mates but I think he mentioned 1 he thought mafia.
I am sure rbishop will tell us at the end of the game who brains2 was.
At this point it really does not matter. It is taking a lot away from the town.
Brians2 has had plenty of chances to defend themselves and all they have done is made it worse. They have been anti-town and most likely are mafia.
Also, this next night the mafia will hit someone. I think we will know much more day 3.
Now he is making a strong case for a player that is long on the way to being lynched. Where were you at the start of Day 2? Thats right defending Brains.
:iagree:
I do not care who brains2 is.
I think this is a big distraction and will be glad to be past it.
I also think that the mafia have a fairly good shot at hitting one of there own in the closet players.
I think day 3 will be interesting. I will post a scaled list then.
Its been Day 3 for about 40 hours now, still no list?
Two mafia in two the first two nights, I think that is a record. I agree with going for the hat trick.
I will miss charlie, it will also reflect my role playing. I had it worked out where DD gave him the clap, now that is gone. Aww the things I think about while at work.
Now that brains2 is gone, I would also like to ponder the idea that maybe mee-mee was both herself and brains2. There was a quote where brains2 mentioned being a mother with 2 kids or something to that effect. Also brains2 was kinda acting like mee-mee at the end there.
But there is more, on the sign-up thread, mee-mee signs up, rbishop thanks her, I make a post and then brains2 signs up, all within one hour.
I am guessing that rbishop pm'ed her with the idea.
Now this does not make mee-mee mafia, but I think I am on to something here.
Until I here what she has to say for herself,
I vote to lynch mee-mee
Could you imagine how hard it would be for any of us to play 2 different roles.
Is there a brains2 - weezer - mee-mee connection???
Again trying to bring it up. I believe I mentioned this late day 1, just not catching up?
Who was brains2 before? Besides the person who had the name before, who has the password?
Weezer has posted that he isn't playing, even though Ice posted that he was in fact posting as brains2.
This is the only post that I can see were brains2 gave us any personal insight.
I wish rbishop would just tell us who brains2 was, but that would be too easy.
So mee-mee are you going to school p/t have any kids?
My guess is no and that I am barking up the wrong tree.
The minute I saw Brains post he was female I knew he was lying. Anyone that believed the post from Day 1 I caught would know he was lying.
JL thinks he might be barking up the wrong tree but his vote stays on MM.
Coler, I think you are getting pretty defensive and I am not sure why. I do not even see a lot of votes for you, but you are acting like there is a train on you.
Being overly defensive is often a mafia tell. Care to defend yourself?
Let me get this staight, a good targeted attack by two people was made on Coler and he responds by voting for himself. Which is odd, because there are a couple of votes on Lady G and a "good targeted attack" on her also. She too has been overly defensive. Now there is mee-mee with a "good targeted attack" of two on her also, she seems to be handling it just fine.
I think voting for yourself is plain old anti-town. The first game ever was lost due to this, and they were innocent. There are way too many good suspects to freak out about two votes. I think this is overly dramitic and suprises me coming from Coler.
I have both Lady G and mee-mee as good mafia suspects.
vote change
I vote to lynch Coler
If you are going to vote for yourself, I will help you.
Here I have to agree with JL about Coler. I think that the Mafia being down has them flustered. They are taking chances and because of this showing their colors. This leaves no room for other mafia players to defend them so they need to jump the train. What gets me though is that JL has pretty much the entire game thought LG was mafia. Why vote Coler when LG is leading in votes and he could be the deciding vote?
I agree, I am very interested in the vote shifts. I think both are good suspects.
I think the shifts have already begun.
I think I came out with you a while ago, you missed it. Skimming??? So my having you as a suspect has "peaked your curiousity"? None of this even makes since, I am fairly sure that I you listed me as possible mafia after I had mentioned you, not the other way around.
Either way, I even half-way defended you for not being as defensive as Lady G and Coler were, even though there are a couple of votes on you and that you are being questioned.
I think at least two if not all three of you are mafia (Coler, Lady G, & mee-mee). I am not sure if you are all in a group that can talk to each other, but I am pretty sure at least two of you are mafia.
Have to agree here too.
Whats the deal JL, hoping to be the remaining mafia player? With the numbers you have or will have after tonight you won't have the power to control lynches at all. If you just follow the innocents you're not going to win. You might end up being the last mafia player and if played well you might get to the end and fool someone to vote for the 2nd to last remaining innocent and win by tie but man thats a long shot.
Ha !
if you want to put me on your list go for it...hands up anyone who thinks naming your suspects is a pro-town move ?
I wanted to add this about Coler. Since when is putting out a list anti town?
