Mafia #15....The Play....

HN look at the last two votes in 1058. You can see my idea evolving there. Got an appointment this morning. I wish we could all look at more suspects than just Coler, but for the good of the town.

I retract King, and vote to lynch Coler

Now go ahead King and twist that however you like.
 
plantling said:
Below are posts made by brains before the nightfall when he was lynched.




Just thought I'd bring this up again. Brain's suspect list only included the names he bolded. I asked Brains what he thought of coler and zsand as they also voted for him, but he never did respond. Now IF Wheezer is Brains, and I really think so, these posts suggests to me that Coler is indeed Mafia and on Brains Mafia team, which I now believe is the team that can communicate. When I played New Mafia w/Mystery Player, aka Wheezer, his list of suspects tended to be pple who voted for him or put him on their suspect lists. He also tended to come to my defense as well as DC's, which was sweet and well intentioned but wasn't helping any of us look any more innocent.:grinno:

I think old habits die hard, so I'm now convinced Coler is Mafia. If this were the only reason, I would prolly overlook it but I have posted other reasons why I think Coler is Mafia. Therefore, I vote to lynch Coler.


My list: (And I'm willing to vote for any one of these)
Coler -per this and previous posts
CCMan- per the case I made at the start of day 2
Lady G- Her confusion about Ice's post then sudden enlightenment did remind me of Ogre's reaction to the same post a day earlier. It seems she was trying to distract from the issue of Brains. I strongly feel she is connected to Brains and Coler. They've got each other on their lists, but Coler hasn't gone into any depth on Lady and Lady's description of Coler is quite tame.

I'm still uneasy about Z and realize Brains/Wheezer did not list him as a suspect either, but am willing to just put Z on a watch list for now.
Click to expand...

mee-mee said:
Just got home from work, almost 24 hour shift...

So plantling are you suspecting, just because when Brains was MP the last game he played...okay, he was on your team though, remember...





And he put these people on his list because in his posts they were going after him.


Well, anyway. I have to get to bed, very sweepy.....

I vote to lynch Coler...


I wont be on until after 5 pm central time. Have to get as much sleep as possible. Till then lets bag us another Mafia...
Click to expand...
Meem's, I explained in post 720, the top post, that MP/Wheezer was New Mafia w/me (meaning he was on my team) and he tended to go after those who voted for him or suspected him. However I have posted other reasons for suspecting Coler and Z, so no it's not just because of that.
 
plantling said:
LG's list is mostly accurate. I'm not so sure she would do this if she were part of the communicating Mafia. Also could she have gotten the investigation for the Mafia. Is the result hidden in this post? Not that we should trust a known Mafia so much but IMO this list makes her look like a lone Mafia who wishes they were innocent.

I am concerned about JM, though. Maybe it's the nyquil, but her going after King when cases were made on Coler and Z reminded me of Game 12 when she was reluctant to vote for Ewurm and wanted to go for HN, whom most pple had leaning innocent. And also as a lot of pple seemed to trust HN, her investigation should have been on Coler or one of the pple on her list or most ppl's lists. However if no other innocent comes forward by next game day then can we assume JM did get the innocent investigation?

Alright, it's way early for a Sun morning. Going back to hopefully catch some more ZZZZ's. Will check in before Nightfall.
Click to expand...


The reason I investigated HN, is because he is my foe, in every game I play with him, he always goes after me, do any of you realize when I actually got the investigation?, There really weren't any lists, ands I had logged on, and received the PM, I had only a few short minutes, and debated between , ICE, HN, lady G, and DD. I chose HN, because he knows, that he and I never ever think each other innocent, ever. so, if I had to choose someone, that would think enough to actually know, or at least be reasonable it would him. sorry, If you feel I didn't investigate the correct person, maybe next time, you will get it, and you can do it exactly right.
 
well, for this to work, we need more people to vote myself, and a few less on coler, although, I hate saying that, to do what we want, some people need to move.
 
judgemax said:
The reason I investigated HN, is because he is my foe, in every game I play with him, he always goes after me, do any of you realize when I actually got the investigation?, There really weren't any lists, ands I had logged on, and received the PM, I had only a few short minutes, and debated between , ICE, HN, lady G, and DD. I chose HN, because he knows, that he and I never ever think each other innocent, ever. so, if I had to choose someone, that would think enough to actually know, or at least be reasonable it would him. sorry, If you feel I didn't investigate the correct person, maybe next time, you will get it, and you can do it exactly right.
Click to expand...

The reason I investigated HN, is because he is my foe, in every game I play with him, he always goes after me
Click to expand...

Ok, let me get this straight. You didnt investigate based on the going ons of the game, but because he is your foe? That doesnt seem to much like you were working for the best interest of the town.

I have posted what concerns me about you. Your posting style has still changed from what it was before last nightfall. Is it still the nyquil, or are you trying to appear to work with the town now to save yourself?

I vote to lynch Judgemax. (subj to change)
 
no, i choose a few, whom I can never ever figure out, and I then worried, that if they came back innocent, I had nothing, the goings on at that point, weren't much, so I chose someone, who in the long run, would be wise enough, IMHO, to believe what I was saying, and at least be level headed about it, So, if he came back innocent, I would at least have a chance and not be shot down immediately as mafia. I don't know what else to tell you, and please don't change your vote, for this to work, we do need more people to vote me.
 
Wow

Does anyone read posts?

Since HN posted his idea to split up the votes on 3 people in post 1012

KOTD JO MM and Z all vote Coler. KOTD switched to Z after being reminded of the idea but **** does anyone read posts?

One of 2 things might be going on here.

Coler is innocent

or

All the mafia are jumping onto him because he is going to be protected by him. That way the vote is canceled no matter how many are on him.

Everyone I suspect is sitting on Coler right now.



Z how is voting for Coler the good of the town when HN the known innocent wants to split votes up. You and JM think KOTD is mafia so why not stay there and have JM switch to him. Maybe 2 more mafia can join you and force a 3 way tie as DD would have to come off JM.
 
Right now its

Coler 6

Z 4

JM 2

We can force a tie if DD and Blue jump to Z

Its the only choice we have now I think.
 
Well 6-6 if Coler doesn't vote for himself again or some off the wall person.
 
If Coler votes for himself again then I think my second scenario in the above post is the right one. That the protection is being used on him.

If he is innocent theres no reason to vote for himself.

If anyone else switched to Coler during the game day they are going to be very suspect.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom