Mafia #18 The Santa Game
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
If Plant was evil she'd have a good idea that you're not evil and therefore an innocent anyway. Unless you're the lone evil then she is taking a chance.
That makes sense, there is definitely much to the game that isn't expected at first to a new player. Appreciate you helping a new townie out.
Never said that you said that you were lynched...I think you misread that part. Once again, what might seem trivial isn't always trivial. But, I think you'll see as the game progresses, that people become less and less likely to focus solely on what seems trivial. On Day 1, there is rarely much else to go on than the trivial stuff (Anyone remember Swayde being lynched as an innocent on Day 1, just for saying she'd be busy that particular weekend? :grinyes. As the game moves on, voting patterns, possible alliances, etc. are established. So while the trivial items may not stand alone, they sometimes do help put the pieces together.
Again, thanks. This is the kind of stuff that isn't evident when you start to play. I even thought Clown and Coler might actually have a personal problem between them at first.
Yes, I'm seeing that. Bala's post with the numbers of innocents to evils in our town really hit home for me.
I have to run errands but I'll be back later.
It was fun helping you out yourself and your teammates Beth. Maybe we can do it again later.
It was fun helping you out yourself and your teammates Beth. Maybe we can do it again later.
I've noted the same thing and it is a factor in why I've not yet changed my vote for tonight.
I'll try to do that. I've changed what I was going to do at work today for tomorrow...have a nasty headache. Good side of that is I'll not fall so far behind before nightfall.
I hate to bust your bubble, Beth, but if I were evil, you would not be my pick for a hit.
And you are my top pick because of your illogical thoughts. I felt that you may be the last of the non-communicating elves, evil yet no one to talk to so you don't know if you should be voting for good or for evil. Logically an innocent would not vote themselves knowing they are innocent if they had suspicions on anyone, even small suspicions.
Coler is playing differently, but I'm not sold on him being evil because he was knocking doors in. I think CL was evil and IMO, Coler wouldn't have voted him unless they were not communicating.
The Niko/DD arguments I haven't really decided on who would be evil if any. They could be both innocent and I felt the first day back and forth was just misunderstanding, nothing big that escalated and it did seem both DD and Blue were after Niko for awhile, but then Niko has come up w/some strange posts lately. However he and I butted heads last game and we were both innocent and he's acting just like he did then. So I'm not sold on Niko either.
I'm leaning HN innocent atm as his posts seem to be helpful and have logical thought to them.
No hard feelings here either, you were only questioning. The sooner that innocents can clear things up the sooner we can focus on the behavior of those that are acting suspect. I obviously agree with you on Niko, and I do find HN suspect but in case I've missed something is there anything that I should be looking at other than the first day innuendos about elves and Keebler?
Charlie I found your posts in #550 about HN
I'm a bit confused why HN would have planned to vote Coler if he was so strong feeling about you. Was he more certain of Coler? If so why add to the risk the lives of innocents by not voting for whom he felt stronger about being evil?
Originally Posted by Hooked Newbie
You seem to be defending Chas... is there a reason or do you feel he's innocent?
Well, on the other end of the spectrum, you seem to be convinced I'm guilty. Why was I your best "suspect" again???
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hooked Newbie
I still suspect Charlie strongly. I am voting Coler to see what he has to say about the hit since he was so certain he'd get killed tonight.
Well HN, getting on the Coler train early are you??? I suspect you're only there to help get it rolling, but you will move your vote back to me once its gained enough steam to get to the finish.
I'm curious, do you have a conspiracy theory in regards to CL, who has shriveled from the light???
I'm a bit confused why HN would have planned to vote Coler if he was so strong feeling about you. Was he more certain of Coler? If so why add to the risk the lives of innocents by not voting for whom he felt stronger about being evil?
