Mafia #18 The Santa Game

Actually Ice, when it comes to choosing who to vote for, I am solid on Charlie still, but my next wouldn't so much as be Hooked. I am not as suspicious of him as I am of you.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Comments in red above. I fear I've made the end game easy for you guys. Thanks for the attention after I posted that list.
Click to expand...
Uh huh. It took awhile, but I think the others are starting to see what I see. This could be the game where despite a record number of UD's, despite the loss of our Doc, we can still turn this around. It has to begin with you. It is my obligation to the town to see to it you hang tonight. Its getting harder for you and your friends to hide, my elven friend.
 
johnlarson66 said:
The UD's are going to be the end of the mafia games. While I like the rule, I also know that life happens. I myself have died a UD and almost died a second one.

I posted a list that I think is not even close to anything at this point. Coler really seemed guilty, at no point did I get any type of vibe of him being a PW. Most everyone I have suspected so far have been innocent.

At this point I am most suspicious of charlie and beth. I am not going to do a bunch of quotes, but I think it can be seen where they have defended each other. I even think at least one of them has been called on it. I am fairly sure they are linked.
Heres what's troublesome John. I think you mean Grins here. She was "called out" for defending me. We have been "linked" by HN. I don't recall Beth ever defending me, or vice versa. But you would have to have been reading the thread to notice this, not skimming it :nono:
I am okay with voting for either one.

I vote to lynch bethkira2000
Click to expand...
my comments above, in red
 
charlie_stubbs said:
Uh huh. It took awhile, but I think the others are starting to see what I see. This could be the game where despite a record number of UD's, despite the loss of our Doc, we can still turn this around. It has to begin with you. It is my obligation to the town to see to it you hang tonight. Its getting harder for you and your friends to hide, my elven friend.
Click to expand...

Go ahead and lynch me, if you're evil you win. If you're innocent, you've been played along with myself. If you are innocent and somehow the town survives after lynching me, start looking at who in this game is good enough and could play the both of us. The only chance will be to nail the Grinch.
 
Well I have sucked this game but with that being said I really thought coler was at least evil...not the "doc"...but the UD's are really killing us.

So now I have to basically go back to my list and figure out what the heck is going on. At this point I can see these people as evil:

Beth- things have been pointed out
Chas- still a gut feel
Hn- the switch to niko was odd
jl- not so much the lack of posting but overall the lack of imput within the posts
DD- still not comfortanle with the whole emial thing

I will possibly be popping in and out today.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Comments in red above. I fear I've made the end game easy for you guys. Thanks for the attention after I posted that list.
Click to expand...

Your lists the entire game have been filled with innocents, why should we trust you now?

Of course when you listed me I have to show where you are wrong. Am I supposed to let the town follow you into another mistake? I know you're wrong on me and I'm not letting the town lose because you want to throw the illusion that I'm a better player then you are.

Hooked Newbie said:
:mad2::wall:

Crap! Tonight sucked! Maybe I've been reading things all wrong and the evil elves just haven't made many if any mistakes. Maybe it's Mad, Ice, Jpap, DD, Blue, Grins...

I do still think Charlie is guilty, but I thought Coler and Lady G were as well so I'm going to keep an open mind. At this point I can relate to LG last game and would almost invite a lych out of frustration.

Sorry I helped to kill you Niko.

I vote to lynch Jpappy. Not much of a case, but I think we've been led around by the noses and he's been just helpful enough to stay active without raising any suspicions.
Click to expand...

Your list after night fall includes 7 people, there are only 5 evils. So for sure 2 are wrong. Given how correct you've been this game its more likely possible that more are wrong.

Of your list the only ones that do seem evil to me are DD and maybe Jpap, only for his vote being the kill vote. But you and Charlie jumping to Niko when he was already dead make you two look more likely.

I'm assuming Charlie will jump off you if the votes are close and you can talk some others into voting an innocent up against you.
 
Dangerdoll said:
Actually Ice, when it comes to choosing who to vote for, I am solid on Charlie still, but my next wouldn't so much as be Hooked. I am not as suspicious of him as I am of you.
Click to expand...

Maybe you should look through the posts again and build cases against both of us and then rethink your allegation.

The only reason you could even come to that conclusion is that HN is on your team.
 
IceH2O said:
Your lists the entire game have been filled with innocents, why should we trust you now?

Of course when you listed me I have to show where you are wrong. Am I supposed to let the town follow you into another mistake? I know you're wrong on me and I'm not letting the town lose because you want to throw the illusion that I'm a better player then you are.



Your list after night fall includes 7 people, there are only 5 evils. So for sure 2 are wrong. Given how correct you've been this game its more likely possible that more are wrong.

Of your list the only ones that do seem evil to me are DD and maybe Jpap, only for his vote being the kill vote. But you and Charlie jumping to Niko when he was already dead make you two look more likely.

I'm assuming Charlie will jump off you if the votes are close and you can talk some others into voting an innocent up against you.
Click to expand...
I wont be changing votes. HN and DD are evils. I am not.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom