Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[Dangerdoll]

gah!! I had a feeling G was innocent!! sorry G... I know things were rough for you in the day leading up to this night and I know how tough it is when other things are going on and you are questioned here... I just was not feeling it. It was questionable, but nothing more than that. As for Andi... I don't know why they would have decided on offing her... other than to try to confuse the town. This was the way I did it when I was Mafia.. looked to see what would confuse the town. This leads me to believe that maybe Charlie is wearing little elven shoes.... while thinking this, I wonder just where are you, Charlie, dear? I see a lot of confirming posts in your 13 posts, but no kicking down doors.

I also still have Niko in as a good suspect. Nothing can erase that 1st day post and his trying to wiggle out of it.

And CL... well, not sold on CL yet either, which is why I never switched to either him or G. I saw a lot of pointing fingers but nothing that screamed elf to me.

 

[IceH2O]

at this point yes...but tomorrow may be different I dont know. I voiced my opinion and I have been seeing different gameplay from you.


Me thinks they protest too much, this looks like sibling like banter, which leads me to think they are trying to distance themselves from eachother cause thay are on the same EVIL team

That was post #291 and in it I have the quotes that back up my statement, and I've seen CL slide by before.

I vote to Lynch CL

Well Andi was mostly on Clown and Coler. I've already posted my thoughts on Clown being likely innocent for Nikos non vote, may as well be considered one considering where it ended up.

Coler is another player that bears watching, though Niko could have not voted for Clown because he is evil too and putting his vote on LG would have been the vote that killed her.

So I'm at a cross road here.

Niko evil for his non vote

Clown could be evil because of Nikos vote, so I take back my thoughts of innocence on him. Last game whenever people questioned Clown he turned them or hit them, same thing could be happening here.

Clown could be innocent, therefore Niko couldn't vote him either for the same reason he couldn't vote LG.

Coler could be either, but we wouldn't know without lynching him or Clown or investigating him and that does only 1 person any good as they can't come out and tell us.

My vote stands for now as its the one I'm most sure of at the moment.

 

[Rbishop]

Bala has been requested to deliver Present "A"......

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I fear my initial gut feel was correct. Coler has seemed to be daring folks to vote for him (over-compensating, I think) and I am going to again indulge him. I vote to lynch Coler. Come on, attack me like you did CL.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Ok that sucked. How did Sploke not vote?

At least they didn't get a power role from the UDs/Hit and we did get an evil elf.

LG I hate you made that move because its the main reason I voted for you.

I'm going to start where I left off before night fall and get some answers from Niko.

I'd love to know why he decided to leave a vote on a player that wasn't even in the running and ended up being a UD when he either could have voted CL or LG to break the tie.

I vote to lynch Niko

Ice, why did you find LG's vote for herself scummy enough to come off of Andi, but not CL's? You also could have broken the tie, by voting CL (who was first to vote for himself) instead of LG....

I'd also like to add that since Niko didn't vote either player that I'm thinking that Clown Lover might indeed be innocent and thats why Niko ran off with the vote tied as either way he would have been the deciding vote on an innocent.

You seem a little anxious to clear CL here. Makes me wonder again why you came of Andi, and voted LG when CL was in danger of being lynched.

 

[Rbishop]

Present "A" has been delivered....

 

[Grins]

Here is the last online times for the quiet ones...knock of 5 or 8 hours from the times shown to get your own times...

Kuhli - Last Activity: Yesterday 05:03 AM
Grins - Last Activity: Today 02:08 PM
KOTD - Last Activity: Today 06:35 PM

Um, no way....I was not anywhere near a computer at that time. Either I neglected to log off or your facts are screwy...or you're up to no good.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice, why did you find LG's vote for herself scummy enough to come off of Andi, but not CL's? You also could have broken the tie, by voting CL (who was first to vote for himself) instead of LG....




You seem a little anxious to clear CL here. Makes me wonder again why you came of Andi, and voted LG when CL was in danger of being lynched.

Read further into my posts and you'll see I retracted my thought of innocent on Clown.

LGs vote wasn't the only reason. Her taking the easy vote on Beth, a newb, was the 1st thing that caught my eye. Then voting herself was the reason I switched.

I didn't vote Clown for his vote on himself because at the time I wanted answers from Andi which I got but weren't satisfactory.

I went to LG because I wasn't sure if Coler or Clown were the evil one and still not sure which is which.

I wasn't going to save either because I wasn't sure that either were worth saving.

 

[Madcrawdad]

gah!! I had a feeling G was innocent!! sorry G... I know things were rough for you in the day leading up to this night and I know how tough it is when other things are going on and you are questioned here... I just was not feeling it. It was questionable, but nothing more than that. As for Andi... I don't know why they would have decided on offing her... other than to try to confuse the town. This was the way I did it when I was Mafia.. looked to see what would confuse the town. This leads me to believe that maybe Charlie is wearing little elven shoes.... while thinking this, I wonder just where are you, Charlie, dear? I see a lot of confirming posts in your 13 posts, but no kicking down doors.

I also still have Niko in as a good suspect. Nothing can erase that 1st day post and his trying to wiggle out of it.

And CL... well, not sold on CL yet either, which is why I never switched to either him or G. I saw a lot of pointing fingers but nothing that screamed elf to me.

DD, you were more sold on Niko being scum based on the 'investigate me, it's a waste of time' posts, but nothing sold you on CL?

your post explains nothing. If you are so convinced "whoever" this is, is in fact evil... why not vote for them tonight? I still find it illogical to hide anything from the town. Your explanation of "well, so and so can just change their behavir" only tells me this is what you would do... or maybe what you in fact already do.



of course, this is coming from someone who holds both votes. Talk about convenience.

And to think, I almost moved my vote.

DD, in this post from Day 1, you mentioned that you were considering moving your vote....who were you thinking of changing to?

 

[charlie_stubbs]

What a blood bath. The UD's really drive me nuts, KOTD in particular. It seems to me KOTD doesn't bother to play unless he has a special role. Thanks King, I hope you like screwing us.