Mafia #18 The Santa Game

Grins said:
I was afraid this was going to say another innocent was lost. I can't believe we lost 3 all in one night. Is this normal for the game?
Click to expand...

Unfortunately it has been pretty much the norm lately.

It won't happen every night though.
 
I have to clear something up.

Earlier I had said that it was the main reasoning for voting LG, her voting for herself.

My vote was on LG because of her vote and reason for voting Beth.

I kept it on her for the main reason that she voted for herself after being called on it right after she voted beth for doing the same thing in her eyes.
 
/game off

I HATE after-death postings, I just wanted to apologize for screwing this one up...not going to make any excuses. Again, wasn't intentional, sorry townies.

/game on.
 
Dangerdoll said:
Mad, I cut your posts into 2 because I want to be sure to answer both of your questions.

what are you assuming I am missing from CL's posts that would have "sold me"? Apparently, they weren't enough to sell you either as you voted for G... after switching from Charlie, after switching from Coler... when exactly did you think CL was scum enough to vote for him? oh wait... or is it because you never wanted to get a "response" out of him and others, such as the excuse you already used.

I happen to think that Niko is quite sharp.... too sharp to make those posts as he did, they were clearly mis-posts. Do you think it's a good idea to discuss and investigate an innocent if we have a chance to figure out who the elves are? I would find that interesting if you did and would be interested in your reasons why.


I was considering Coler if you must ask because of his combative posts. From what I have noticed, is he is attacking and provoking people.

looking back... Grins even puts it in her vote for CL that he is one of those "provoking Coler"... funny, I see the opposite.
Click to expand...

IceH2O said:
Huh?? For Hooked?

But you were answering Mad.
Click to expand...


I meant for this paragraph to say
what are you assuming I am missing from CL's posts that would have "sold me"? Apparently, they weren't enough to sell Hooked either as he voted for G... after switching from Charlie, after switching from Coler... when exactly did he think CL was scum enough to vote for him? oh wait... or is it because he wanted to get a "response" out of him and others, such as the excuse already used.
In addition to this Charlie, and Pappy, and plant, CL, and Ice didn't think he was scummy enough to either.
 
Hooked Newbie said:
I'm sorry that I was wrong about you Lady and I'll accept the inevitable blame. Hope RL improves for you.

Overall, tonight sucked! At least Kuhli was evil. King- you have a bad habit of going by way of the UD.

Wow, hit on Andi... I gotta think that makes Ice, Coler, Mad, or My suspects close or them guilty. (I included myself for fairness). I think they're probably fishing for Santa. I wonder what they saw about Andi to waste a shot... will review. Seems that Charlie is once again my best suspect, but I do look forward to hearing from CL since he was so close to the block. Time for thoughts folks, no more secret hunches... we have the numbers, but not by much.
Click to expand...

HN, maybe I'm dense, but how do I figure in with Andi? Other than admiring her avatar from afar, I'm pretty sure that I didn't even mention her at all this game....

Hooked Newbie said:
I fear my initial gut feel was correct. Coler has seemed to be daring folks to vote for him (over-compensating, I think) and I am going to again indulge him. I vote to lynch Coler. Come on, attack me like you did CL.
Click to expand...

Also, in post #504 (above)you mention that Charlie is your best suspect, yet 10 posts later in #514 (also above) you vote for Coler. Neither Charlie nor Coler posted anything between posts 504 and 514... How did you end up voting Coler, when Chas is your best suspect?
 
Dangerdoll said:
I meant for this paragraph to say
what are you assuming I am missing from CL's posts that would have "sold me"? Apparently, they weren't enough to sell Hooked either as he voted for G... after switching from Charlie, after switching from Coler... when exactly did he think CL was scum enough to vote for him? oh wait... or is it because he wanted to get a "response" out of him and others, such as the excuse already used.
In addition to this Charlie, and Pappy, and plant, CL, and Ice didn't think he was scummy enough to either.
Click to expand...

yeah, but they didn't make it a point to come out and say that they didn't find CL scummy afterward.... IMO your case against Niko was pretty weak. C'mon, he said he was innocent, yet invited you to investigate him? CL was interested in chasing down Blitzen (as opposed to scum) and when voted for by Coler, he voted for himself (and unlike LG and Beth, who claimed confusion, CL claimed that he did it as a fact-finding mission).

One other question... Regarding your post from Day 1 (where you told Niko that you had considered switching votes), you later told me that you had considered switching your vote to Coler. Why in your early post on Day 2 did you only mention Chas and Niko as suspects? Apparently Coler had made it onto your radar by then...
 
johnlarson66 said:
For the record, my day one history has been to a) vote for the first role player or b) jump all around on voting for people.

At this point everyone really looks evil.

If I had to list my top 7, it would be (in no particlar order):

Coler - lots of posts, highly agressive
atnixon - posting changed mid-day
clownlover - "on" coler and voted for self.
plantling - something seems fishy, gut feeling?
gupman - newb with low posts
KingOfTheDeep - low posts
kuhliloach - low posts

Also, of course I am keeping an eye on Ice, HN, Charlie, DD & Lady G who at this point there is no telling.

There also seems to be a fine line between being too vocal and not being vocal enough. I do not want to vote for someone just because of how many posts they have or don't have.
Click to expand...

Coler said:
JL - I'm surprised to be your top suspect to be honest but so be it.

I am not surprised at the lack of any team effort to vote me out - the bad guys are going to kill me tonight and they know it.

CL and I are most certainly not on the same/any team. If we are on the same side it will be because CL is good, as am I...I am thinking deeply about the vote, remembering Ogre from zombie mafia and a prior game where CL got kicked early but I'm keeping it where it is for now.
Click to expand...

Coler, I never said you were my "top suspect" as a matter of fact, I clearly stated that the list was "in no particlar order", see the bolded statements.

My top suspect was plantling, but really when you look at things, I kinda agree with her on a few things.

Also, Coler, you played the "I am gonna get hit tonight card". So today, you are my top suspect.

I vote to lynch Coler
 
///off game

The game was great! Stayed on our feet the whole.

///on game
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom