Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[IceH2O]

You can almost guarantee I'm evil??? Thats a bold statement to make.
You are in damage control mode now, thats certainly apparent. Off to the chat room then, to see if your friends can help you squirm out of this.

I agree that almost guaranteeing evilness is a bold statement.

While I had you leaning evil, DDs explanations don't bode well with me.

If she does get lynched and turns up innocent then I believe her. If she gets hit and turns up innocent I believe her.

If she is lynched and evil, then my suspicions of you are removed.She won't be hit by the evils if she is evil because that would be a wasted hit.

 

[Grins]

Ice my head is spinning from reading that. I think I need a matrix to keep up with the game and who is acting suspicious and who has given good reasons for actions or inactions.

::Grins trudges off to find Tylenol and perhaps a computer programmer to build that matrix:::

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I agree that almost guaranteeing evilness is a bold statement.

While I had you leaning evil, DDs explanations don't bode well with me.

If she does get lynched and turns up innocent then I believe her. If she gets hit and turns up innocent I believe her.

If she is lynched and evil, then my suspicions of you are removed.She won't be hit by the evils if she is evil because that would be a wasted hit.

Well I suspect tomorrow I will be dead. I think I'm proving to be too much of a thorn to them. But I did help to identify my killers.
HN- scum
DD- scum
Niko- probably scum

 

[Madcrawdad]

sure thing, however clever this post is, I still have a hunch you might know exactly what this means. In games past where Charlie and I were in the game, Charlie has done a post or or ten of role playing. He comes up with a story, one balanced on the game in which we are playing. When he does this, he is usually the main character and me, his love. Now, Charlie did mention me being led astray this game but it wasn't in a role play. This is very unlike my Charlie. Nope, not in one bit unless there is something to hide....

Another thing that bothers me is who the elves took last night. This also leads me to believe Charlie is a bit elfy. He would like the same game play. When we were evil, we were 1 hair close to sweeping the town. We started off confusing the town and did rather well until subtle hints were let out. Here, I believe that same tactic is bing used. It wasn't someone very veteran to the game like Ice or Hooked, Coler... it was Andi. A newbie. Wow, I've done this same thing before. Why in the world would they take Andi. She was of no harm to anyone. Why... so that a mass confusion could happen and we could scuttle around aimlessly in this mass confusion. Typically, we would try to check lists and see just why the elves would have taken whoever.... well, I have noticed a post where andi is hot on Coler and CL (post 291). Could the elves have assumed that since Andi was taken out and she being a newbie to the game, that this post wouldn't hold much weight?

This doesn't take the heat off of Niko because I still think he may be guilty but I am feeling it stronger for Charlie right now.




interesting you would say this, Charlie. Nice subtlety for the group. Is it that you are disconnected from the group?

I vote to lycnh Charlie, sorry sugar... something just isn't right... you fooled me once, maybe even twice.... I'm not going for a 3rd.






Check out AOL Money & Finance's list of the hottest products and top money wasters of 2007.

DD, my main concern here isn't the cut/paste job. Early in this post you cast suspicion on Grins for not knowing about your's and Chas' virtual romance. But let's be honest, it's not like you guys are Bogie and Bacall (or Ogre and Z, for that matter ).

You end the post with a vote for Charlie. Do you think that Charlie and Grins are evil and linked?

As a side note, where the heck has Coler been? Also, sure would like to hear more from Niko before voting.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice my head is spinning from reading that. I think I need a matrix to keep up with the game and who is acting suspicious and who has given good reasons for actions or inactions.

::Grins trudges off to find Tylenol and perhaps a computer programmer to build that matrix:::

I tend to over analyze a bit.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

Whoa! Good catch Blue. Did DD just pull a mee-mee?!

DD?

This post caught me by surprise. You went quiet after our "discussion" this morn, I thought maybe you were busy writing. Thank goodness DD screwed up the font and such in the change over, otherwise it was a well written and very convincing post, don't you think??

 

[IceH2O]

DD, my main concern here isn't the cut/paste job. Early in this post you cast suspicion on Grins for not knowing about your's and Chas' virtual romance. But let's be honest, it's not like you guys are Bogie and Bacall (or Ogre and Z, for that matter ).

You end the post with a vote for Charlie. Do you think that Charlie and Grins are evil and linked?

As a side note, where the heck has Coler been? Also, sure would like to hear more from Niko before voting.

Well Niko is on the thread so he should be responding.

Coler must think its a lost cause and has given up the ghost. He hasn't been on since right after the nightfall where he made a quick post.

 

[bethkira2000]

#749 I was reading through and just wanted to say Grins is right usually I am very articulate. first thank you for the compliment. Second you are right I have not been making much sense sometimes. I know what I want to say, and sometimes it seems that I have not worded it right. I have also been so caught up in a certain post that I hurry to answer it instead of taking the time.
My top three choices were for:
Coler
Plantling
IceH2O
I have read Charlies posts, and I have not played with him before, so I don't know if he is out of character or not. Also I cannot say for certain if I see him as evil or innocent.
Grins I would say innocent, because you haven't said or done anything to make me think otherwise.
Blueiz again not sure either way, she asks me alot of questions but that doesn't make her evil or innocent, it simply means she is trying to find things out for herself.
DD a little sketchy agreed on the e-mail post problem, but does that make her evil, not really.
And Coler who was posting all the time the first day, and has now become silent is very troubling, he was also the most defensive.
Niko alot of people agree he is evil, I still don't know if he is evil or not.
I promise that if I make it through tonight I will double my efforts to get evil out of the town. I originally voted for Coler and I am now having second thoughts. That is all I will say for now.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

DD, my main concern here isn't the cut/paste job. Early in this post you cast suspicion on Grins for not knowing about your's and Chas' virtual romance. But let's be honest, it's not like you guys are Bogie and Bacall (or Ogre and Z, for that matter ).

You end the post with a vote for Charlie. Do you think that Charlie and Grins are evil and linked?

As a side note, where the heck has Coler been? Also, sure would like to hear more from Niko before voting.

Bogie and Bacall??? I like to think we're more like Jimmy Dean and Natalie Woods, some might speculate we're even like Bonnie and Clyde.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

It certainly looks like it, as my beloved seems to have changed her font, and everything else. Who wrote this for you Double Dee???? Was it HN??? Go back to the chat room and tell him it didn't work. But it did add a third name to my list:
HN
Niko
DD

This is a good list.

Wasn't me... even IF I were evil, Ice taught me the lesson (mee-mee gate) not to try something that! :silly: