Mafia #19 50/50

The only flaw in your logic Plant is the switch could have happened on what was that night 3 when the mafia was ahead? Couldn't he have switched then??? I'm not saying the switch happened last night. I'm saying the switch happened this game.

Big difference and blows a complete hole in your last statement.

But the mafia wasn't ahead after night 3.

night 1- DD lynched -- I 7 M 6

night 2- Blue lynched, jm hit -- I 5 M6

night 3- Beth lynched, malbri hit, jpap UD -- I 4 M 4

night 4- DC lynched, jl hit, swayde hit, andi dropped -- I 3 M 1

none of these take you into account

OK, lets apply some logic to y'all's strategy:
Just for arguement's sake, lets say I switched. The three of us vote out LG tonight. Tomorrow night I suddenly turn on Niko and plant and vote against one of them. They'd immediately vote to lynch me, as you have done. So tomorrow night I'd be out and the innocents have won.

At best I'd be delaying an inevitable outcome by one day.

Now let's see what could happen if y'all lynch me tonight.

Niko and plant find out after the lynching that there are mafia left. You and LG vote to lynch one of them, you both have to vote for the same person or it's pointless. They turn and vote to lynch one of you, and the tie has to go to rb for a decision. He could decide to let niko or plant be lynched. This is the only way that you and LG can possibly stay in the game and win.

I'll bet that sounds really far-fetched, huh?

Mark
 
How about we all lynch Brains first since he's admitted to being an innocent and then Wes as we are only speculating about the switch atm?

One, last thing real quick:

OK, Yes Plant this would make since but...my reason I think we should take Wes first is simply b/c I am still not 100% sold that our vote to Brains will count. He may actually be a "decoy" so to say. I think he wins either way, I believe the game will end once we really kill the last remaining Mafia, which no I am not going to sit here and scream I am innocent, but I believe the last remaining to be Wes, unless you or Niko were offered the switch and it is one of you two. I am saying Wes, because of what he said...why did he bring that up? I believe he brought it up because he was switched and he wanted others to think a mafia switched to innocent instead of a innocent being switched over to the evil side
 
But the mafia wasn't ahead after night 3.

night 1- DD lynched -- I 7 M 6

night 2- Blue lynched, jm hit -- I 5 M6

night 3- Beth lynched, malbri hit, jpap UD -- I 4 M 4

night 4- DC lynched, jl hit, swayde hit, andi dropped -- I 3 M 1

none of these take you into account

OK, lets apply some logic to y'all's strategy:
Just for arguement's sake, lets say I switched. The three of us vote out LG tonight. Tomorrow night I suddenly turn on Niko and plant and vote against one of them. They'd immediately vote to lynch me, as you have done. So tomorrow night I'd be out and the innocents have won.

At best I'd be delaying an inevitable outcome by one day.

Now let's see what could happen if y'all lynch me tonight.

Niko and plant find out after the lynching that there are mafia left. You and LG vote to lynch one of them, you both have to vote for the same person or it's pointless. They turn and vote to lynch one of you, and the tie has to go to rb for a decision. He could decide to let niko or plant be lynched. This is the only way that you and LG can possibly stay in the game and win.

I'll bet that sounds really far-fetched, huh?

Mark

Actually no Wes, if you are found to be innocent then EVERYONE would lynch Brains as he would HAVE to be the last. IF we lynch Brains or myself tonight and we come back innocent, then you have me or Brains to still go after that gives you 2 more nights to try and come up with something.
 
Now, I really have to go
 
AquariaCentral.com