Mafia #19 50/50

[Lady G]

Just a quick observation...

DD and Blue seem to have decided Niko is worth considerable effort. Could those two be aligned? Could all three be aligned and have cooked this whole thing up between them as a disinformation campaign?

Mark

I was wondering the same thing, about all three being aligned. DD and Plant have gone after Niko before. It would look "normal" for them to continue to do it. Then in doing it could be distancing from Niko in the process of.

Although we have to keep in mind there is a group of innocents that can communicate also, but I wouldn't think the innocents would want to draw attention to themselves and risk ANY being lynched...at least I hope they wouldn't since they are the only innocents that can communicate.

We also have to keep in mind not all Mafia can communicate, so there so many possibilities it's hard to say.

I kinda see a few things here:
1. DD and Blue can communicate and think Niko is innocent or evil, whichever they are not and want to get him lynched.

2. One is evil, the other innocent..the evil trying to connect with a person they think innocent so if the other is lynched, if the evil is lynched we would think the other was also and lynch them, thus lynching a innocent or if the innocent one is lynched we would assume the other is too.

3. They all three can communicate and are trying to distance from the start.

There are so many ways this can be looked at though, I don't really know. I just think, Blue calling Niko out on such a thing, then saying Plant looked suspicious for asking her if she was serious is kinda odd, JMO.

 

[Lady G]

here you go: you know how when someone tells a joke to someone, and the other person doesn't get it? You need to explain the joke out so that person does get it. Sure, takes the funny out of the joke, but at this point, I never got the giggle. Get it?

Ok, DD..I will accept that, for now. *sigh*

 

[Lady G]

I was wondering the same thing, about all three being aligned. DD and Plant have gone after Niko before. It would look "normal" for them to continue to do it. Then in doing it could be distancing from Niko in the process of.

Although we have to keep in mind there is a group of innocents that can communicate also, but I wouldn't think the innocents would want to draw attention to themselves and risk ANY being lynched...at least I hope they wouldn't since they are the only innocents that can communicate.

We also have to keep in mind not all Mafia can communicate, so there so many possibilities it's hard to say.

I kinda see a few things here:
1. DD and Blue can communicate and think Niko is innocent or evil, whichever they are not and want to get him lynched.

2. One is evil, the other innocent..the evil trying to connect with a person they think innocent so if the other is lynched, if the evil is lynched we would think the other was also and lynch them, thus lynching a innocent or if the innocent one is lynched we would assume the other is too.

3. They all three can communicate and are trying to distance from the start.

There are so many ways this can be looked at though, I don't really know. I just think, Blue calling Niko out on such a thing, then saying Plant looked suspicious for asking her if she was serious is kinda odd, JMO.

That should say DD and Blue not Plant in the second sentence. Sorry Plant didn't meant to throw you in there.:drool:

 

[plantling]

Its obvious plantling which posts have been "defending" Niko. Go back and read, even if that was not your intention, it sure does appear that way. Both you and LG have been all over me for asking the question as well as the back and forth that occured when Niko chose to ignore the question, then avoidied directly answering it.

Yes, most of my posts have been related to Niko because hes the only one thus far that I have asked a question to and them not answer it. Go back and look at your posts, where do they focus at? I see that you have "bantered" and then focused on looking at me and why I asked the question concerning Niko's psot. If you care to look back, I asked beth a question as well, she answered without so much drama. Im looking at everyone, not focusing in one place, what are you doing?

Ummm, I think you may be the one who needs to go back and reread if you think I defended Niko when I asked you that question as I did say he very well could be scum at the time. And also it was you that jumped on me for asking a question, not the other way around. Then you decided to link me w/Niko and LG who I still do not see that I have defended.

As far as my bantering, perhaps that's my way of relating to players and trying to get a feel for them. Much nicer than an in your face approach that only riles ppl's heckles even if they were innocent. Rest assured that though you have piqued my interests, I am looking at others. There are 7 Scumbags, after all. And my guess is most are laying low and haven't posted much perhaps so nobody can call them out on anything.

That should say DD and Blue not Plant in the second sentence. Sorry Plant didn't meant to throw you in there.:drool:

LOL, LG. I got what you meant as you were quoting Wesley.

I'm not so sure that since there are only 3 communicating Mafia that they would want to draw attention with a staged argument.

 

[judgemax]

well, that was alot of reading, for nothing, i think, That that was a typical squabble, although, It happened really early in the game, ..I have to assume, that one, of either DD, or blue or guilty, I am not sure which, I am wondering, whether it might be DD..

 

[Lady G]

Ummm, I think you may be the one who needs to go back and reread if you think I defended Niko when I asked you that question as I did say he very well could be scum at the time. And also it was you that jumped on me for asking a question, not the other way around. Then you decided to link me w/Niko and LG who I still do not see that I have defended.

As far as my bantering, perhaps that's my way of relating to players and trying to get a feel for them. Much nicer than an in your face approach that only riles ppl's heckles even if they were innocent. Rest assured that though you have piqued my interests, I am looking at others. There are 7 Scumbags, after all. And my guess is most are laying low and haven't posted much perhaps so nobody can call them out on anything.


LOL, LG. I got what you meant as you were quoting Wesley.

I'm not so sure that since there are only 3 communicating Mafia that they would want to draw attention with a staged argument.

This is true, also...but then they could be counting on us thinking that. Really I do not think the three can communicate. I am leaning more DD or Blue evil, not sure on Niko at this point, possible one of the two along with Niko?? All I know is HALF the town is evil so there are many out there, the likely hood of us getting a Mafia on night one are higher in this set up then others. I'm pretty sure at least ONE of Niko, DD and Blue are mafia, just trying to decide which.

 

[plantling]

I'm not sold on all 3 being Mafia or all 3 being innocent, either. And I agree 50% chance of lynching a Mafia is pretty good. I'd like to go for one of the communicating Mafia, but will be satisfied w/one of the 4 non-communicating ones. This game is a lot about numbers. We lose if after the 4th day the Mafia outnumber us.

 

[jpappy789]

I am glad to be back, I missed the last few games, but for good reason! So watch the Disney X-mas parade because I'll be on it! Right now I'm trying to decide between some of the people I haven't played much with. Malibri(sp?) and Niko have my feathers ruffled a little. Jpap and DD have my attention as always. But for right now I'm going to start up an old comfortable feud and
I vote to lynch Swayde! HAHAHAHA!

I think the gist of this post is a joke DC but these sentences confuse me...are you sayinf that you are already deciding to vote to lynch some people that you havent played with before? If not what are you deciding on? And how do I have your attention? I posted 2 times I believe before this post. It would be one thing to say that you are wary of me but it sounds like I have done something suspicious in your opinion...please explain what.

I personally dont get how Blue could have misunderstood nikos post but I can let that part slide when I have done the same thing in the past. What I do not like is her insinuating that plant, niko, and lg are a team. Plant? Honestly I do not see exactly where she is defending niko...mostly its her questioning you, Blue. And DD jumping on there...from a distance it looks like she fuled the fire so to speak by claiming that blue had a "nice find"

And andi...sorry but you come in during the middle of this and post absolutely NO opinions on what is going on. None of them have any relevance to the game either. Methinks you are intentionally not trying to get into the mix.

Right now I have DD over Blue as mafia but it could easily be both. Also andi. Jl is also worrying me, his post on niko seemed off to me...unlike him. Usually he has some pretty in depth analysis within posts and that one was not what I would have expected...

 

[Blueiz]

What strikes me here is that DD vehemently went after Niko, and now silence. Silence on her part as well as Niko's part. The thought that I may be being set up has crossed my mind.

For anyone that cares to go back and look, to sum up the happeenings, I asked Niko a question, Niko didnt answer, I called him on this, several posts later he answered the question. That is the point that I stated thank you to him for answering the question and left it at that, only responded to others on it when asked about it.

Plant, yes it raised my suspicions that you were so against me thinking it could mean more than one thing, LG, you have raised mine as well in post number 83 with this

DD, you are kidding here right? How exactly is that a nice find DD??? Niko made a joke toward me (the way I took it anyway)?

I took this as you defending Niko, were you actaully defending yourself?

 

[jpappy789]

I think atnixon is up to something. I am not sure what was up with the post with the slip and what was even meant by it. It is a strange slip and I really do not know what was even meant by it.

I do see some votes going on atnixon, and I really can't see anyone much better to vote for, but I am always a little leary of day one trains, but someone has to go. It might as well be the most guilty acting.

I do not like the whole defintion thing and the evading questions, but this is nothing new.

There was another post that seemed to defend atnixon, before I jump on atnixon, I want to find that thread, it might not even be atnixon, but there is a post that has me concerned.

This is what I am talking about. Jl usually types pretty clearly and actually makes sense...does anybody else think that this id weird or am I just imagining things? Atnixon appears quite often in the post and he repeats himself in the red part...I could be just making something out of nothing but I personally thought this was odd