Mafia #19 50/50

[brains2]

Why did you say "JL now thats lame"?

Because you called my bala comment lame..

Here are the votes per your request Beth

Andi - Jl(395), Blue(406), Swade(407), DC(410)
JL - Plant(413), Beth(469), Niko(503)
Plant - Blue(482)
Blue - Judge(492), Wes(493), Andi(499)
Beth - brains2(504)
Jpap - brains2(504)
Niko - Jl(522)

If andi who was at the top of your list was one of your suspects why the JL vote.. I'm not saying he is or isn't mafia but normally if people have a list of suspects they'll vote for any of the list.. you out of the blue put a second vote on JL..

 

[brains2]

I retract my vote on Jpap and put it firmly on Beth

 

[johnlarson66]

JL, you don't think that Blue trying to cast suspicion on JM of all pple is a bit scummy?

I kinda had a strange thought about the whole DD thing. It was real real obivious that DD was mafia. Also judgemax really put her neck out there to get her lynched.

What if DD's death was part of the mafia's plan. What if she was a non-communicating mafia and the communicating mafia felt they could lose DD and then make themselves look good.

Now this would not make sense in most games, but in 50/50 they could afford to lose one, if that meant not losing any others and creating some sort of leadership.

So, do I 100% trust judgemax? No.

 

[wesleydnunder]

What if she was a non-communicating mafia and the communicating mafia felt they could lose DD and then make themselves look good.

Maybe I don't know enough about the game rules, but how would the communicating mafia know jm was non-communicating mafia?

Mark

 

[johnlarson66]

Because you called my bala comment lame..

Here are the votes per your request Beth

Andi - Jl(395), Blue(406), Swade(407), DC(410)
JL - Plant(413), Beth(469), Niko(503)
Plant - Blue(482)
Blue - Judge(492), Wes(493), Andi(499)
Beth - brains2(504)
Jpap - brains2(504)
Niko - Jl(522)

If andi who was at the top of your list was one of your suspects why the JL vote.. I'm not saying he is or isn't mafia but normally if people have a list of suspects they'll vote for any of the list.. you out of the blue put a second vote on JL..

True, I voted early for andi. I did not like the fact that she voted for judgemax.

 

[plantling]

I kinda had a strange thought about the whole DD thing. It was real real obivious that DD was mafia. Also judgemax really put her neck out there to get her lynched.

What if DD's death was part of the mafia's plan. What if she was a non-communicating mafia and the communicating mafia felt they could lose DD and then make themselves look good.

Now this would not make sense in most games, but in 50/50 they could afford to lose one, if that meant not losing any others and creating some sort of leadership.

So, do I 100% trust judgemax? No.

Believe me, I've thought about that scenario also, but wouldn't the REAL innocent who got the investigatin have come out by now. I will be very pissed at them if they allow JM to do something like fool us, but I just don't think there's anyone that careless playing.

 

[johnlarson66]

Maybe I don't know enough about the game rules, but how would the communicating mafia know jm was non-communicating mafia?

Mark

I was saying that maybe DD was non-communicating mafia.

The Bala gave one innocent and one mafia the power to investigate. It is possible that judgemax received the investigation that was given to a mafia member and it came up dangerdoll as mafia.

 

[brains2]

Believe me, I've thought about that scenario also, but wouldn't the REAL innocent who got the investigatin have come out by now. I will be very pissed at them if they allow JM to do something like fool us, but I just don't think there's anyone that careless playing.

I would have to agree with this plant.. It just wouldn't make sense.. I personally have the Judge leaning innocent atm.

 

[johnlarson66]

Believe me, I've thought about that scenario also, but wouldn't the REAL innocent who got the investigatin have come out by now. I will be very pissed at them if they allow JM to do something like fool us, but I just don't think there's anyone that careless playing.

How bad does someone want to stick there neck out there? In this game, claiming you are innocent gets one lynched. I am not sure, I just know not to 100% trust anything.

What are your thoughts on Beth?

 

[wesleydnunder]

I was saying that maybe DD was non-communicating mafia.

The Bala gave one innocent and one mafia the power to investigate. It is possible that judgemax received the investigation that was given to a mafia member and it came up dangerdoll as mafia.

OK, dude. I missed that part.

Mark