Mafia #19 50/50

brains2 said:
So here is my list for right now... In preferential order

Andi - voting record on the two nights.. 1st night with DC on the Judge(known innocent)
Beth - for the JL vote when she clearly listed others on her list as candidates but put a second vote on someone else and made no significant case for that vote.
LadyG - She was on Judge's list and is why I'm thinking she got hit, somewhat of a gut feeling here but I'm thinking i'm right on this one.
DC - was also on judge's list and voted for the judge night 1.. and gut feeling here.
Click to expand...
You know, I wondered why LG wasn't hit. Judge was a non-communicating innocent. I thought that the Mafia would want to go for a communicating one. But perhaps Judge was onto something. But then when I went and pulled up LG's posts, LG was pretty severe in her comments about DD, so I dropped it. I can't quite wrap my mind around it but maybe DD did name LG to protect her though they were not on the same team. I'm going to go back and reread some posts.
 
Lady G said:
Judge, I know you are always suspicious of me no matter what, but really IF DD did get the investigation and found me "mafia" do you really think SHE would even mention my name??? Honestly, think DD style, if she investigated (or say I was communicating w/ her), I am sure she either would say nothing or name someone randomly who she "thought" was innocent. She would NOT knowing she was going down mention a member of her "team", would she??
No, I am more apt to believe she either did investigate me and wanted her fellow mafia to know her results, OR she just assumed me innocent and wanted others to think other wise. No matter, she was causing confusion in the town before she left.


No, there was no distancing there, I found what she said to be suspicious and said so...because I felt she was posting classic mafia "DD" style. Her saying to Blue, "good catch" over Niko teasing me just didn't add up in any way, then for her to take it as far as she did, just struck me wrong.


Yes, Jmax you are right about one thing, there was a "reason", reason being...I thought she seemed evil. I really don't know how to assure you on this, besides telling you I thought she looked mafia, She acted like there was something to Blue's "finding" when it was soooo obvious a joke, it just seemed she was trying to play on anything she could.
Click to expand...
Well, I found the above post where LG was replying to JM about possible reasons why DD named LG. I'm stumped to find anything scummy in this post. I'm not adding LG to my list just yet but it's not a bad idea to watch her.
 
plantling said:
You know, I wondered why LG wasn't hit. Judge was a non-communicating innocent. I thought that the Mafia would want to go for a communicating one. But perhaps Judge was onto something. But then when I went and pulled up LG's posts, LG was pretty severe in her comments about DD, so I dropped it. I can't quite wrap my mind around it but maybe DD did name LG to protect her though they were not on the same team. I'm going to go back and reread some posts.
Click to expand...

They hit judgemax, because she was a known innocent. It would have been a risk to hit someone else. They could have hit one of the non-communitcating mafia.

I am not sure if I would have hit her, mostly because if she was not hit, there would have been lots of explaining to do on her part as why she was not hit.

My guess is that they thought about it and it was not worth the risk of hitting one of their own.

Besides the towns vote to lynch, the communicating innocents have a hit.

I am also concerned with plantlings assumption that brains2 is an innocent. We have no idea if they are or are not. It is 4 against 6 plus brains2, who could be either.
 
bethkira2000 said:
ooohhh so scared of that link. I think he'll be lucky if he doesn't UD. And it is really quiet today.
Click to expand...

This post caught my attention. Beth is talking about me UD'ing. What is odd, I had already voted.
 
plantling said:
Hmmm, I just noticed this. There are 4 votes on Andi and most of the voters are on my list of suspects. IMO, Andi may be Mafia, but she's prolly not part of the communicating team. I think at least one of those voting for Andi are on that team. It could even be 3.

Blue and JL were on Niko for that joke he made to LG. DC seems to be going w/the flow a bit this game.
Click to expand...

I was nor on Niko about the joke, but more of his lack of explaining and just adding to the confusion. The joke went over my head.
 
plantling said:
And JL I've already voted :silly:. Though it may change. However the more I think about it the more I think you and Blue are a team as you haven't really mentioned each other even though both of you look scummy. :lipssealedsmilie:
Click to expand...

Who looks scummy?
 
rbishop said:
Bala has offered a non-communicating Innocent a chance at protecting someone from tonight's Mafia hit.....
Click to expand...

Whoever had this power should have protected judgemax!
 
atnixon said:
here is my **** list from earlier on in the game..and to be honest, for the most part, i feel i am sticking to this list with a little tweaking as below..

Blue + JM = Could they be two communicating mafia??
JL...at the moment your still my in the list...

Andi + BethK = You two are really concerning me, your severe lack of input, but coasting through the game has me worried...
Click to expand...

To answer your question. NO, they are innocent.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom