Mafia #19 50/50

John I was going to post on that inconstancy as well... But you just beat me to it. This has triggered all kinds of alarms in my head because while LadyG might be all over the place in her accusations (which btw have you noticed that this game?? Hmmm that might be that gut feeling of mine) she is normally dead on spot about rules.

Lady G said:
Well, I have quite a few things I have to get done today. I will be back on later to add more thoughts. Going to leave my list of suspects I have at the time.

Niko-He just isn't sitting well with me, he says he wasn't on when I know he was. That makes me very suspicious, as he could of just admitted to being there and gave a reason he didn't post.

Beth-Her hesitations, and her post are not setting well with me at all.

Andi-She just doesn't seem to add anything to the game as far as thoughts, I am wondering if she is a communicating mafia.

DC-Has done nothing at all to help the town, said he will play more after last night, guess we will have to wait and see what he does.
Click to expand...

I don't see your constant crucification of Niko for not posting. Many of us watch the threads and don't post. Much like you last night. You were on the boards, normally make an after work post but I'm now suspecting you had to meet up with your mafia buddies to decide the best course of action first in your chat room. Your off your play LadyG and I'm now ranking you right below or close to beth.

Another that is bothering me is Wes. Night fell and if he was an innocent he hasn't posted anything about last nights results as of yet??? I mean its late in the afternoon already. Hiding in the bushes is what it seems like to me.. Here weasel.. come here boy..

My vote is sticking with Andi until I get some answers and the longer she takes the more certain I am of her guilt.

I'm going to go back and do some more snooping b..
 
I am going to say two things, this is my last post until tuesday, as I said I am leaving town for some RL R&R.
I hate saying this next thing, after reading Jl's post #670 I agree.........ow that hurt. He is right no matter how you place brains2 mafia is winning, so unless there is a mafia lynched tomorrow night, and the next night they win. I wish now I was going to be here.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I know you are skimming, but atleast read your own posts!

It is not after night #4.

Your post makes no sense at all. It is either 4-6 or 4-7 or 5-6. No matter how you place brains2 the mafia outnumber the innocents as of right now.

This post brings Lady G way way up!
Click to expand...

But its still winnable John.. Night 3 the communicating townies get their hit, mafia doesn't. Tonight could take us back to winning depending on how the communicating townies direct their hit. But at this point I'm thinking they would have to be blind not to see at least some of the obvious mafia. That puts us into night 4 were both the mafia and the townies get a hit.

If they hit a mafia then that puts us at 5 - 4 winning.. Night 4 we both get a hit and the lynch.

Then depending on night 4 the following scenarios apply

Lynch mafia, hit mafia, they hit us - 4 to 2
lynch mafia, hit innocent, hit us - 3 to 3
lynch innocent, hit mafia, hit us - 3 to 3
lynch innocent, hit innocent, hit us - 2 to 4
lynch innocent, hit innocent, they hit their own - 3 to 3
 
Been doing some thinking and reviewing and it may just be me, but there is not a lot to go off from today....I was certain that Blue was mafia due to the way she tried to pull at very insignificant things...JM was a real shame to loose...

I am thinking JL and Beth are two of the possible three communicating mafia...the lack of conviction from either player has not gone un-noticed...That lack of conviction is also applying to Andi....way way toooooooo quiet in my opinion...

LG seems intent to carry on with her charade against me, i obviously dont see it the same as she does, so be it...but i dont overly see anything coming from her that strikes me as mafia, besides the quick mentions towards me...not wholy sure what to make of her...

DC...well..we have heard little to nothing from him, and i feel he is mafia just coasting throught the game

Malbri...again, i feel she is coasting...if she is innocent, i would of expected a lot more from her.

Wes...been very quiet really...that quiet i dont feel any vibes, good or bad, which does concern me..yes, i can understand he is new to the game, but, more is expected...

Brains2...his starting off attitude was not good..yes the game was quiet, but that attitude (posting manner) instantly rings alarm bells...for the town sake, i hope this person is a neutral and not alligned to anyside because if he is mafia, its not going to help our numbers against the scum...

Plant...so far has done nothing to make herself look mafia, seems to be looking at all doors around the town..but, i have to ask, is this your cover???? make yourself look so innocent that you slide through?

Swayd..well..never played a game with her, so i dot know what her style is...at the moment, i feel her style is done on purpose, effortlessly sliding through the game, not many people raising questions against her...that does not fit right...shall go and review her posts next i think, see if anything shows up...

just some interim thoughts for now
 
atnixon said:
Been doing some thinking and reviewing and it may just be me, but there is not a lot to go off from today....I was certain that Blue was mafia due to the way she tried to pull at very insignificant things...JM was a real shame to loose...

I am thinking JL and Beth (9) are two of the possible three communicating mafia...the lack of conviction from either player has not gone un-noticed...That lack of conviction is also applying to Andi (8) ....way way toooooooo quiet in my opinion...

LG (5) .....seems intent to carry on with her charade against me, i obviously dont see it the same as she does, so be it...but i dont overly see anything coming from her that strikes me as mafia, besides the quick mentions towards me...not wholy sure what to make of her...

DC (8) ...well..we have heard little to nothing from him, and i feel he is mafia just coasting throught the game

Malbri (8) ...again, i feel she is coasting...if she is innocent, i would of expected a lot more from her.

Wes (6) ...been very quiet really...that quiet i dont feel any vibes, good or bad, which does concern me..yes, i can understand he is new to the game, but, more is expected...

Brains2 (7) ...his starting off attitude was not good..yes the game was quiet, but that attitude (posting manner) instantly rings alarm bells...for the town sake, i hope this person is a neutral and not alligned to anyside because if he is mafia, its not going to help our numbers against the scum...

Plant (7) ...so far has done nothing to make herself look mafia, seems to be looking at all doors around the town..but, i have to ask, is this your cover???? make yourself look so innocent that you slide through?

Swayd (7) ..well..never played a game with her, so i dot know what her style is...at the moment, i feel her style is done on purpose, effortlessly sliding through the game, not many people raising questions against her...that does not fit right...shall go and review her posts next i think, see if anything shows up...

just some interim thoughts for now
Click to expand...

brains2 said:
If you had to rank everyone niko how would you rank them on a scale???
Click to expand...

Added a ranking in bolded red above....as i said before these are just interim thoughts right now
 
Thanks.. We have some simularities but I guess I'm just not seeing what you are seeing in JL.. I'm hoping that if Andi does get the lynch that the voting townies go after Beth or Mal based off your and my list (what we have in common)..

I'm not any more convinced that JL is mafia than Plant at this point at least they are trying to get something out there. While JL's shifting in votes does have me a little concerned I think it was more of way for him to either 1) see who follows and if any were on his list or 2) using it as an excuse.

While I understand your concern since you two have both been going after each other from my perspective you guys are less mafia than others listed.
 
atnixon said:
///Game off

WOW....how dead is this?? ....lol....Brains2 killed it....

///game on
Click to expand...

Sorry :wall:

But I'm thinking that all of the mafia are in chat right now trying to figure a way out of this predicament that they are in and that we are onto them... Otherwise I'm thinking they would be a lot more vocal trying to get us to lynch a townie..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom