Mafia #19 50/50

[plantling]

Yay we sure did need to nail 2 mafia, and we did =)

Plantling why do you choose DC instead of Andi, when Andi is at the top of your list? I don't disagree with you because I think DC is a very good candidate, but I do find it curious.
Are ya skimming Swayde? I thought it was a good idea to have a two horse race, if you wanna go back and read my post when I made the vote. Unless you're too busy that is. I figured you'd say something either way. If I would have voted for Andi, you'd probably said I was blending in. You may have others fooled, Swayde, but you don't have me fooled about your scumminess.

I also find it curious how you'd try to paint me as mafia for pointing out a slip up when DD's slip up was much more minor and she ended up being mafia. It just seems like Plantling is upset that she got caught in her freudian slip and is doing her best to turn the tables. You are still way up there on my list, but Andi's still ahead. If Andi is actually a townie, I really hope she starts acting like one so we don't end up lynching one of our own.
Well Swayde, why don't you pull up DD's post and mine side by side and compare them. Too much work for you eh? My post had one word that was misplaced. DD's had grammar and spelling errors. Go take a good look if you're not too busy.

Wes, this thread is actually very slow and short of posts compared to other games I've played, I can't see how it's giving you a headache to keep up.

And DC...there is no Don in this game. If your going to try to skate by, at least know the rules

I vote to lynch Andi.

My apologies, I did read it wrong. That's what I get for not taking the time to quote the posts I am trying to comment on, so I can make sure I did not read them wrong =/

Unfortunately your deductive skills are not working in your favor in regards to me, but being lynched would certainly take the burden off me to try and squeeze in time to contribute and help the town. Unfortunately, it would put the mafia at an advantage and as close as we are with their ability to hit coming up, lynching a fellow townie, is not a good thing.

OMG, Did you just admit to being wrong? Could have sworn you said you didn't slip up in these games. I guess you can't always be perfect, eh? And a mistake in about 20 posts. Wonder how many you'll make if you did try to post more to actually help the town than point out dumb errors and jump on them recklessly.

 

[plantling]

Now then, i have a problem with this post....above in red, care to explain LG?? A slip perhaps? a message to someone perhaps?

LOL, have you been eating out of the same Spaghetti dish as Swayde, Niko? Actually I don't know if LG is Mafia or not but it does say more in your favor that you did not automatically slap a vote on her.

 

[Reefscape]

LOL, have you been eating out of the same Spaghetti dish as Swayde, Niko? Actually I don't know if LG is Mafia or not but it does say more in your favor that you did not automatically slap a vote on her.

LOL....Just after a simple explanation

 

[plantling]

Now then, i have a problem with this post....above in red, care to explain LG?? A slip perhaps? a message to someone perhaps?

Awesome!

Thank you communicating townies for not hitting me.

Good call on Malbri.

Hmmm, rereading this I have to ask John. Why did you think that they would hit you? Do you feel that you have been scummy?

ATM, I actually have you leaning less Mafia as others have come out of the woodwork, even though you did leave your vote sitting on me in a "safe" place. I would like to hear your thoughts on Swayde and any of the rest of the players if you get a moment.

 

[plantling]

Hmmm, I don't know why the above post has Niko's post posted again. :huh:

LOL....Just after a simple explanation

Understood, and same here.

 

[Swayde]

I can admit when I am wrong Plantling, I don't think I am wrong about you though. I gotta give you credit, you are doing a great job of deflecting anyone who says anything about you. I don't buy it that you are innocent for a minute, but since you've clearly got way more time to appear to be helpful, it makes it harder for those with less time to really do much about it. Oh and yes, I do usually post more when I am innocent, and a LOT more when I am evil trying to look like I am innocent. The only other game where I was busy IRL, Ice got me lynched on the first day while I was off having a bday party for my son (oh I was innocent, but didnt have time to post). I am surprised to still be in this game with as little time as I've got, but I did make a commitment to play and I intend to see it through. I won't let this happen again because I feel so bad that I am pretty much useless and I hate when people do that =( I'll have a little time today to post while my son's working on his assignments, but this afternoon and evening are booked.

Andi, DC and Plant are my top suspects, for what it's worth. I still am unsure of JL. His posts have had me going back and forth on my opinion of him. I believe Brains, Niko, LG to be innocent. Not sure about Wes.

 

[Reefscape]

I can admit when I am wrong Plantling, I don't think I am wrong about you though. I gotta give you credit, you are doing a great job of deflecting anyone who says anything about you. I don't buy it that you are innocent for a minute, but since you've clearly got way more time to appear to be helpful, it makes it harder for those with less time to really do much about it. Oh and yes, I do usually post more when I am innocent, and a LOT more when I am evil trying to look like I am innocent. The only other game where I was busy IRL, Ice got me lynched on the first day while I was off having a bday party for my son (oh I was innocent, but didnt have time to post). I am surprised to still be in this game with as little time as I've got, but I did make a commitment to play and I intend to see it through. I won't let this happen again because I feel so bad that I am pretty much useless and I hate when people do that =( I'll have a little time today to post while my son's working on his assignments, but this afternoon and evening are booked.

Andi, DC and Plant are my top suspects, for what it's worth. I still am unsure of JL. His posts have had me going back and forth on my opinion of him. I believe Brains, Niko, LG to be innocent. Not sure about Wes.

Swayde...Can you give more info on why you think each of your top suspects are mafia? I.E Andi, DC...On plant, you've just explained...What makes you unsure of JL?

 

[plantling]

My thoughts on the players so far: (Before JL jumps on me for asking him but not putting it out)

Brains- I hope he is for the town, but ya never can be sure in these games. Also even if he was playing for the town, would his status be counted in the game towards the Innocents? Don't know if we should count on that so we should prolly err on the side of caution.

players left from the playlist:

lady- I've had similar thoughts as LG some of this game so I can't fault her for her thoughts. She has seemed to be helpful in trying to root out Mafia. However DD's naming her, especially if DD were a communicating Mafia does leave a little bit of wonder about her.

niko- Niko seems to be posting hepfully also. Because I butted heads w/Niko in a game in which we both were innocent but could have sworn the other was evil, I think I'm getting a better read on him now. However I wonder if I should be worried that now that I don't get a lot of vibes from him.

wesley- I haven't been able to get a good read on Wes. He seems to be grasping the game well at times then seems lost at others. I was a confused Newbie at one point also, so can't really judge too harshly. I can understand his recent vote on Swayde, but wonder if he was skimming the part about the two horse race.

swayde- I'm leaning her Mafia atm, see previous posts.

andi- Due to her lack of participation and voting record I have Andi as Mafia

jl66- I've butted heads a bit with John this game, but at times he does seem to put out some logical thoughts in his posts. Wish there were more to go on but perhaps he's busy IRL. Or it could be a great cover.

deputy- His voting record is a bit better than Andi's but his posts are very lacking in thought, so I have him as Mafia as well.

 

[brains2]

WOOO-WHOOOO!! Great night townies!! Wonderful pick there communicating Mafia!!! Kudos to you!! Couldn't of come home to a better night, 2 more mafia down:headbang2:

Now for me to decide, do I want to go with DC or Andi for next lynching!!

I have to get a shower in quick and a bite to eat, will be back on in a few!

You and Plantling using the same author?? She did that earlier and swade pointed it out and it made me go hmmmm. With you I have to say its different because you were on JMax's list and now post the same thing.. I'm now doing more of a HMMMMM..

Twice in less than a 24 hour period has to be more than coincidence expecially since you've had to have read the thread by this point unless your skimming??

I do agree with your possible choices however.. Those two do look the most scumtastic to me as well..

 

[brains2]

Yay we sure did need to nail 2 mafia, and we did =)

Plantling why do you choose DC instead of Andi, when Andi is at the top of your list? I don't disagree with you because I think DC is a very good candidate, but I do find it curious.

I also find it curious how you'd try to paint me as mafia for pointing out a slip up when DD's slip up was much more minor and she ended up being mafia. It just seems like Plantling is upset that she got caught in her freudian slip and is doing her best to turn the tables. You are still way up there on my list, but Andi's still ahead. If Andi is actually a townie, I really hope she starts acting like one so we don't end up lynching one of our own.

Wes, this thread is actually very slow and short of posts compared to other games I've played, I can't see how it's giving you a headache to keep up.

And DC...there is no Don in this game. If your going to try to skate by, at least know the rules

I vote to lynch Andi.

2 points. I think you need to read her post closer.. I had voted andi, she stated she thinks it needs to be a two horse race and voted DC..

As far as DC goes with that whole DON thing.. that has me questioning as well..