Mafia #19 50/50

Whoa guys, sorry there, went on a snap decision during a feud and thought judge seemed more different in play style than jmax. Had to leave for work right after the post and had no idea what was waiting to break out just minutes later....I gotta relook at things since I totally misread this situation...I think more than one person besides DD was in on the big arguement that was going on when I voted and it should be looked into...I also agree that "internet problems" are a weak excuse....Anyone who has played with me knows I have to make my decisions early for weal or woe and this one I made a mistake on...I'll watch for something good to work with in the morning but I must sleep now, night all...
 
Wooo-whooooo!!!!!!! THANK YOU JMAX!!!!!!! This is sooo great, after the last couple games getting a mafia on night one is such a high!!!! Naner, naner, naner!!!!

HA!!! Ice and Hooked thought we couldn't do it with out them:silly:

judgemax said:
now do you believe me?...lol:)
Click to expand...
Yes, Judge I do!!!! My only question is, did you really have the innocent investigation or were you teamies with DD and this was your way to look good? Sorry, but I have to have my suspicions. Although no one else made any attempt to "out" any one, no cases or anything else...so really I have to believe you did get the investigation....GREAT CALL!!!
 
judgemax said:
Actually if you want MY opinion, i think LG is my next suspect, ..I think, ..it was an attempt to let a mafia brethren slide through the game, under a false assumption. but, that is just MHO
Click to expand...
Judge, I know you are always suspicious of me no matter what, but really IF DD did get the investigation and found me "mafia" do you really think SHE would even mention my name??? Honestly, think DD style, if she investigated (or say I was communicating w/ her), I am sure she either would say nothing or name someone randomly who she "thought" was innocent. She would NOT knowing she was going down mention a member of her "team", would she??
No, I am more apt to believe she either did investigate me and wanted her fellow mafia to know her results, OR she just assumed me innocent and wanted others to think other wise. No matter, she was causing confusion in the town before she left.

plantling said:
Well these are just some of the early day one posts where LG states suspicions of DD. IMO, it was too severe to be distancing as there are only 3 communicating Mafia.

Wow, I can see why DD investigated LG IF she did get the investigation. I was thinking that since JM already outed DD that even if DD were a communicating Mafia, she might pretend to have gotten an investigation. Which would be nice since there would only be 2 communicating Mafia left. My picks are Andi and DC, who voted for JM and another possibility is Blue, as she and DD seemed to tag-team Niko at the beginning. I still like JL for Mafia, too. There's just something about him this round...
Click to expand...
No, there was no distancing there, I found what she said to be suspicious and said so...because I felt she was posting classic mafia "DD" style. Her saying to Blue, "good catch" over Niko teasing me just didn't add up in any way, then for her to take it as far as she did, just struck me wrong.

judgemax said:
That is a good point plant, i just feel like their was a reason, the squabble escalated the way it did, ..esp, over nothing?..could just be because its LG, i dunno...
Click to expand...
Yes, Jmax you are right about one thing, there was a "reason", reason being...I thought she seemed evil. I really don't know how to assure you on this, besides telling you I thought she looked mafia, She acted like there was something to Blue's "finding" when it was soooo obvious a joke, it just seemed she was trying to play on anything she could.
 
Right now, before I go to bed I have to say...Andi and Beth stand out to me more than anyone else at this time.

I will post more thoughts tomorrow, after some sleep. We did a great job tonight, lots of thanks to Jmax!!:grinyes:
 
Lady G said:
Right now, before I go to bed I have to say...Andi and Beth stand out to me more than anyone else at this time.

I will post more thoughts tomorrow, after some sleep. We did a great job tonight, lots of thanks to Jmax!!:grinyes:
Click to expand...
Well, just a quick thought or two before starting out the day:

Yep, I too, found Beth's hedging before nightfall suspicious. It could have been genuine Newbie confusion, but then the situation wasn't that hard to understand, so I'm wondering if it was more like hesitation to vote out one of her own.

Because for some reason I get hit on night two these days :rolleyes: , I will go ahead and put up a list and will try to update it if necessary before next nightfall. Any comments on the pple on my list is welcome.


MY LIST:
Assumed Innocents:
JMax
LG

Mafia Suspects:
Andi
JL
Blue
Beth
DC

Like I said, any comments are welcome. I don't have any investigative powers or special powers or roles, so it's all speculation on my part. I very well may be wrong about a few. The more discussion before nightfall, the better.
 
Im going to throw this out there. Im not assuming anyone is innocent. Thanks JM for outing DD. This doesnt make you innocent in my eyes tho. It has happeend more than once that mafia has sacrificed there own to make themselves look innocent. Ive played in a game like that as well. It is yet early in the game...

Right now, my top suspect is Andi for voting as she did last night.

I vote to lynch Andi, subject to change as always.
 
Great job Jmax =)

Andi, I was hoping yesterday to read that it was in fact your first game and that maybe you just didn't get the game, but it's not your first game and your behaviour, internet problems or not, is really scummy so far.

I am also still very, very suspicious of JL. If there was a power role, I'd be a little more inclined to think maybe that was the reason, but your gameplay so far has come across as very anti-town. I still think you are playing very strangely and I think you are a scumbag.

I vote to lynch Andi for now, this is subject to change since it's still pretty early for a vote on day 2.

Also keeping an eye on DC, he seems to be relying very heavily on his busy schedule to keep himself off radars, but I am not sure if that's because he's innocent and doesn't want us to waste a lynch on him because he's truly just that busy, or if he's using it as cover to hide his mafia nature.
 
just so you all know, I was not really hedging, i think was the word, I was pretty sure I was going to vote DD, just got caught up in things. I think my vote is going onto JL, now.
 
Ok, I’m typing this in another program to start, cause half the time that I tried to post yesterday it kept dumping me and I would loose every thing I said…

  • I was not sure that DD was mafia or innocent, it just happened she was Mafia. BUT I wasn’t going to just follow the train I have been the assisted cause in innocent’s deaths in previous games that way.
  • JM was a safe vote JM wasn’t going any where, I wasn’t trying to get a train going I was trying to not hurt the town even though I was not in a position to help the town.

I am still having internet problems here at WORK; I can get on and read but my ability to post with out being kicked off it hit or miss. And I knew due to my class last night I was not going to make it to my home computer till after nightfall, Saturday I will be able to do more.
 
Ok, so I'm gonna rely on my earlier hunch and agree with some of my fellow townies on this one.
I vote to lynch Andi.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom