Mafia #19 50/50

:confused: What's the difference between thoughts and views in this game? The point is you were trying to make it seem like LG was also hanging JM out to dry when in fact LG only entertained the possibility of JM being evil. YOU went on and on about some conspriracy plan of JM's and DD's.

I'll let the other players decide for themselves who tried to cast more suspicion on JM.


No plantling, you have called me a liar and I clarified the matter, lets not try and downplay that on your part.

I am not trying to make it seem as anything. I have stated my thoughts and anyone that cares to go back and read can see exactly what has been said.
 
well, this has been slow, i am hoping that by tonight i will have plenty more time, to contribute my thoughts, honestly, this is a very busy weekend for me, ..

So, My suspect list is as follows:

Blue: I think blue knows more about contriving a plan, than she is letting on, I think NIKO gate, was planned, I think BLUE is mafia.

LADY G , I still find it suspect, that DD named you. In MO, I would have named a known mafia, simply because, so many are now trusting LG is innocent.

Andi, She has several games under her belt, and this has got to be teh worst play I have seen from her yet. I think, she is struggling, with being a non communicating mafia.

DC, usually much more active, with a much stronger, more well thought out opinion, somewhat concerns me.

Wes, I agree, its a gut feeling, but its a strong one.

Fo bow, just in case I can not make it back before nightfall, I am Voting to lynch Blue as always this vote is subject to change.
 
Just got back from taking my building exam and caught up with the posts.

I see on pg. 47 that andi has four votes for no apparent reason that I can see. I believe 3 of those votes are from communicating mafia. That's just my "gut feeling".

I think jm is on the level and blue is pointing fingers everywhere she can. I think her vote against plant was retaliatory for the words they've been having between them lately.

Beth, swayde, Niko, jl66, andi? Dunno yet. DC claims to be busy with work, plant is getting into it with some good arguements, but those could be misdirection. So far the one that stands out the most is blue, so I vote to lynch Blue.

Mark
 
well things are turning,I originally voted for JL but I maybe changing there is a strong argument for Blueiz. I am thinking these are my top choices:
Andi
Blue
JL
 
Just got back from taking my building exam and caught up with the posts.

I see on pg. 47 that andi has four votes for no apparent reason that I can see. I believe 3 of those votes are from communicating mafia. That's just my "gut feeling".

I think jm is on the level and blue is pointing fingers everywhere she can. I think her vote against plant was retaliatory for the words they've been having between them lately.

Beth, swayde, Niko, jl66, andi? Dunno yet. DC claims to be busy with work, plant is getting into it with some good arguements, but those could be misdirection. So far the one that stands out the most is blue, so I vote to lynch Blue.

Mark

I doubt that the communicating mafia would all be voting for the same person early in the day and on Day Two. My guess is that half of the four could be mafia, but I doubt if even two of the communicating mafia are on the same person.
 
thru post #495...

to lynch...

andi (3) by jl66 swayde dc

jl66 (2) by plant beth

plant (1) by blue

blue (2) by judge wesley

8 of 13 have voted...

Nightfall in 5 hrs...
 
If Bala sleeps thru the night fall, please forgive him...too many people stating we need more input and posts, then not doing what they recommend...
 
Bala notices a stranger in town...
 
well, this has been slow, i am hoping that by tonight i will have plenty more time, to contribute my thoughts, honestly, this is a very busy weekend for me, ..

So, My suspect list is as follows:

Blue: I think blue knows more about contriving a plan, than she is letting on, I think NIKO gate, was planned, I think BLUE is mafia.

This, is a good point, I'm incline to agree with you here.

LADY G , I still find it suspect, that DD named you. In MO, I would have named a known mafia, simply because, so many are now trusting LG is innocent.

This too is a good point LG is too good at this game to assume she is not mafia

Andi, She has several games under her belt, and this has got to be teh worst play I have seen from her yet. I think, she is struggling, with being a non communicating mafia.

THis is the first game that I have run into techinical issues as well as RL during game time, if people want to hold that against me so be it. BUT recall this happened to LG last game and she was innocent.

DC, usually much more active, with a much stronger, more well thought out opinion, somewhat concerns me.

Wes, I agree, its a gut feeling, but its a strong one.

Fo bow, just in case I can not make it back before nightfall, I am Voting to lynch Blue as always this vote is subject to change.

As ussual my comments are in purple.

I am voting to lynch Blue
 
Really I'm not sure where my vote is going to land, looking back the whole Blue, DD, Niko thing came back to mind. Obviously we found DD to be mafia..now I wonder were Blue and DD "tag teaming" Niko?? Was Niko and DD distancing??

Then JL, and DC just seem very off to me. JL, with his vote for me, when talking about Niko in his post...saying I was defending Niko. Blue and DD also seemed to think that, was he going on there lead?? I was very surprised when JL replied with the Niko "slip" he is one I for sure would of realized it was just a joke, and for him to try and build a case around that just threw me off. His posts with his "thoughts" were very disoriented also, so not like JL.

The DD and Blue tag teaming was what i was trying to get everyone to see right at the start of the "discussion" that the three of us had...


Thisw could be something to look at ladyg, just keep in mind that a name will appear where the person last was for up to an hour after they leave if they dont log out..

My vote is on andi. Not following anyone concering it. Her post voting to JM is very disconcerting to me. Making a safe vote when there is information out there that pretty much screams another is mafia is a wasted vote.

I believe this was asked of me by LG...Answer is no, i was not aware that people could stay active for as long as an hour...

I could be reading to much into things, but does anyone see anything here besides me?? Blue mentions how "would JM make such a mistake as to confirm herself as innocent at this point," the very next post DD's comes out to try and say she got the investigation. Does it look to anyone like maybe they had been "chatting" on the idea?? After her and DD were all over Niko, together.

Something about these investigations is not sitting right with me somehow..I really cant put my finger on what it is though...I am starting to have doubts whether JM IS innocent...I am starting to be of the feeling that DD was a non-communicating mafia, which is why she sacrificed herself with a poor comeback after she ousted JM...Which then leads me to believe JM to be part of the communicating mafia team...this would effectivly put JM in the clear ( in everyones eyes ) and allow the mafia to keep a communicating team member alive right under our noses...just a thought for people to think about...

I find it odd that this is all JM had to post concering the exchange between concerning Niko.. Why didnt she share her thoughts with the town, she usually does a good job at that..

From these two posts, it makes me wonder if this isnt staged. Those are strong accusations by JM, its as tho those words were put there to be found. As well as DD's pitiful fight back. Even if she were mafia, looks to me as tho she would have fought back harder making accusations and so forth back at JM instead of basicaly giving in. DD's lack of fight seems as tho she wanted to be found out and voted for.

DD made the above post 5 minutes before JM said she new she was mafia. Is five minutes enough time for someone to deduce in there mind without a doubt one is mafia? Or were dd and jm chatting and putting a plan into action?

Im not saying JM is evil, all Im asking for is thoughts concerning this.. As its a possibility that this could be a setup so that mafia can take the town again. It really concerns me how some are automatically marking JM as innocent when this could be a clever ploy and this is just what the mafia want us townies to think.

Am just bringing this post, and a part highlighted in red to people's attention...Something is not right in it, but i am not sure what yet...something about this JM innocent thing....just concerns me a little why Blue is making head way on JM...I am starting to feel that Blue and JM are two of the three communicating mafia....just a hunch...

Hmmm, and Niko would know this right:confused:

This has been answered by Blue above, and no, i was not aware it was for that ammount of time..

I would like an answer from Niko on this, if you would of known (I don't see how as a Mod you wouldn't), why did you post that??

Answered above, and answered by Blue

To add, so as to clarify what Im saying. If DD and JM could communicate, they would be doing so over the Niko thing. DD could have went full force trying to get a train on Niko, and JM was in the background communicating with her, that could be an explanation as to why JM only posted "Wow" concerning it..

Again, this Blue mentioning JM and the communication things...i really am starting to feel they are talking to eachother...this hunch does not seem to want to go away...

I really trying to figure out what to post. At this point I see nothing to add.

I have no way to defend me playing odd, off or wierd. I do not see me playing any different than any other time.

Those that have played with me before should know of my Day One history of voting for the first role player or bouncing all around. They should also know that most of the time I am thought of as guilty and most often I am a top suspect.

I have never in a game claimed to be innocent. There was one game where I fought for my life and said if people voted for me that the game would be over, and it was for me, I was mafia that game. I try my best to play the same, if I am mafia or not.

I do not think I have done anything that would say I am mafia, but am honored that I have been noticed. I think the voters for judgemax and the late joiners onto dangerdoll should be the top suspects. I also think the people that vote late in the day should be watched.

I help when I can help. I do not think I have played any different and am very leary of those that say I am. Maybe I should stop role playing.

You see nothing to add?? You have not seen anything to add since the game started besides throw out random votes...this is exactly why your in my mafia radar JL..

I see Niko has left now, very troubling he didn't answer to my question as to why if he knew a member would continue to show as on up to an hour later if not logged off, why he tried to call Andi out on watching the thread. Which IF Andi was having computer problems could explain that, she wasn't able to log out before the computer goofed up on her, hence leaving her where she was.

Niko, you are really beginning to concern me more and more here. Was the fight staged between you and DD? This is all I'm thinking now, the fight, calling Andi out, and now watching for quite a while an not responding to anything??

No need to repeat what i have already stated about people still showing as online after they have left, read above..if that make you concerned, then so be it, nothing more i can say about it..

I am concerning you cus i am not posting? The reason i did not answer your question is because they were posted after i had gone. Its already been stated by Blue that people can still show up as online...so, i dont see why you feel the need to say such a thing..

Heres my list of top suspicions at this time, as well as why. Everyone is suspicious to me but myself, the ones listed are the ones that have stood out most to me at this time.

Andi, for the lynch vote given without a real expalnation til after the fact.

Plantling, something is off here, not sure if its being to nice so as not to stir the waters or what..As well as her and LG agree on a lot of things..they arent looking at each other.

LadyG, pretty much the same reason as Plantling, this isnt like LG at all.. As well as her and plantling agree on a lot of things and not looking at each other.

Atnixon, seems to have just fallen away, can pull the RL card if he wants, but hes been online in chat a lot today.

Wesley, just a gut feeling here...

To add, I think that LG and Plant may be communicating mafia simply becuase of there chatter between each other in the thread, almost seems as if they are trying not to look as tho they are talking outside the thread.

What i would suggest you do there Blue is go and look at the time the questions were asked of me, and when i left chat, and you will find that it was after i had left..To add to that, i am not going to just post for heck of it..i dont see the point...i made my accusations of JL and was waiting for some more input from him, and still there has been very little indeed..

yeah, now things are getting back to well "normal". I hope things heat up more before nightfall. I have to say Deputy I have never played with you before, but I am willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. I want more accusations,more plans, thoughts ......whatever lets bring this game to life.

You keep saying this, above in red, and i think you have said this twice..Where are all your accusations, your plans, your thoughts? They have been very little, near enough scarce in actual fact...Instead of telling everyone else to do this, why are you not doing this yourself? I feel you are just keeping yourself in the game, showing your face every now and then...Effectivly, your slipping under everyones radar and i would like for people to realise this...Could she be the 3rd communicating mafia???
 
AquariaCentral.com