Mafia #19 50/50

[brains2]

just went back to look at the list of players, and missed Wes off the list..he is another coaster...but i dont get him, i am not relly feeling good or bad from him..need him to get more into the game and help out if he is innocent..

Well if you don't get him how can you get any of the rest of the low posters or get a feel for if they are innocent or not? He is no different than any of the other low posters..

And realistically beth has only gotten really quiet since I sniffed her out that is what is leading me more and more to believe that she is mafia than some others on the list. Her posting hasn't been helpful it has been just enough to make people think she has but the guts of isn't.

I gave you a break in the beginning because your reasoning had merit. You may not have liked my tactics you can call me harsh or a jerk or whatever else you want but it did several things. It gave me a read on the prominent players in the game. You by no means have come off of my list but I'm thinking that you are doing more to help the town than most so I'm giving you a break..

LadyG's vote confuses me however.. While I understand the need to beat the bushes and kick the weasles earlier she listed three top candidates that she was waffling on but then voted DC. I consider that a safe vote right now and am going to continue to watch her carefully.. She also seems to be helping the town but with her again I just have this feeling.

I am even more assured of my vote right now with Andi my only problem right now is that she very well might UD. But then if I change my vote and she shows back up in the thread.. hmmmmm.. Out of everyone on my list she is the top along with beth.

I sat and watch the thread last night and saw Malbri in the thread for quite some time and she only had the one post. From the time she posted she was here with only two activity updates one at 8:00 and one at 8:29 but all we got was one post.

 

[brains2]

Don't forget to vote!

On as side note we should prolly be thinking of a second vote in case Andi doesn't show to vote. We could get a 2 for 1. It's a bit tricky as she may appear just before night and vote, but then we'll at least know to vote her the next day.

Well as of this point my list stands. But LadyG has voted for DC and that would be a possible second choice for me not perferred but possible.. I'm with you in that I want my vote to count this evening because we have to get it right this time. Or there is no pulling a rabbit out of the hat for the win.
My feelings for DC are not as strong as Beth but I'm hoping she is the target of the communicating townies tonight.

But I'm suspecting one of two things.. Andi is going to UD or she's going to pull into the thread and do her hit and run posting at the last minute which will save her behind. The more she stays away the more I am convinced that she is mafia.

 

[plantling]

Well as of this point my list stands. But LadyG has voted for DC and that would be a possible second choice for me not perferred but possible.. I'm with you in that I want my vote to count this evening because we have to get it right this time. Or there is no pulling a rabbit out of the hat for the win.
My feelings for DC are not as strong as Beth but I'm hoping she is the target of the communicating townies tonight.

But I'm suspecting one of two things.. Andi is going to UD or she's going to pull into the thread and do her hit and run posting at the last minute which will save her behind. The more she stays away the more I am convinced that she is mafia.

I was thinking DC and Beth, also, if I changed my vote. But it looks like DC may also UD, so perhaps Beth. Maybe we can get a 3 for 1. :grinyes:

In which case the communicating innocents should go after the other person that pple have been agreeing on, Mal.

 

[brains2]

I was thinking DC and Beth, also, if I changed my vote. But it looks like DC may also UD, so perhaps Beth. Maybe we can get a 3 for 1. :grinyes:

In which case the communicating innocents should go after the other person that pple have been agreeing on, Mal.

I could agree with either of those.. And a 3 for 1 would be scweeeeet. :grinyes:

But I think the innocent hit squad need to hold their vote until this evening and then send it in.. Like I said with both Andi's and DC's hit and run posting style anything is possible. They could pull a Dwarf Puffers and post just before nightfall thus saving their carcases.

 

[plantling]

I very well may change my vote to Beth later and if anyone has the gall to do the Dwarf Puffer, then they'll be next day's lynching for sure.

 

[brains2]

I think that might be doable.. I will try to check back in later in the day and see if any of them have posted.

 

[Reefscape]

Well if you don't get him how can you get any of the rest of the low posters or get a feel for if they are innocent or not? He is no different than any of the other low posters..

And realistically beth has only gotten really quiet since I sniffed her out that is what is leading me more and more to believe that she is mafia than some others on the list. Her posting hasn't been helpful it has been just enough to make people think she has but the guts of isn't.

I gave you a break in the beginning because your reasoning had merit. You may not have liked my tactics you can call me harsh or a jerk or whatever else you want but it did several things. It gave me a read on the prominent players in the game. You by no means have come off of my list but I'm thinking that you are doing more to help the town than most so I'm giving you a break..

LadyG's vote confuses me however.. While I understand the need to beat the bushes and kick the weasles earlier she listed three top candidates that she was waffling on but then voted DC. I consider that a safe vote right now and am going to continue to watch her carefully.. She also seems to be helping the town but with her again I just have this feeling.

I am even more assured of my vote right now with Andi my only problem right now is that she very well might UD. But then if I change my vote and she shows back up in the thread.. hmmmmm.. Out of everyone on my list she is the top along with beth.

I sat and watch the thread last night and saw Malbri in the thread for quite some time and she only had the one post. From the time she posted she was here with only two activity updates one at 8:00 and one at 8:29 but all we got was one post.

On Wes...Call it a gut feeling..i dont know what else to say about him at the moment...

Comments about me...Your comments sound a little bit arrogant i have to say..which the town does not need right now..It needs people to work together...When you joined the game, it was not hard to see who the prominant members were, they were the only ones posting...If your "entrance" to the game did several things, then it would be a good idea to share them with the town, not really going to be helping much else are they...

For the moment..I am going to lay my vote on Beth ( who i previous stated was at the top of my list )...Something really is just not right with her...

I vote to lynch Bethkira2000

 

[brains2]

/// game off
got a call from my kids teacher and so now I am home with a sick child.. will turn some attention to the game while he is sleeping
/// game on

 

[andi872]

Sorry all, I'm reading to catch up, Have spent a portion of the weekend at the med-stop my 2yr old has strep throat, he was running a 102.9 fever saturday night

 

[brains2]

Ok so I'm putting the low posters under some scrutiny.. Here are ALL of Malbri's posts to date in this thread. I will comment when necessary but you can pretty much draw your own conclusions as to how helpful this individual has been to the town in tracking down the mafia.

First day nothing to heavy everyone is keeping it pretty light.. No problem with this.

lol, I just got on and saw a pm from rbishop, and im thinking "Uh oh, im in troouuubllle"
But it was just for this, which was a relief

lol this is not possible
Not everyone can have one vote but one person have 2, that would mean someone voted more than once.

Im dropping that subject before I confuse myself....

Which is why I aint touchin' it

lol, that was not a newbie card.

I like to call it the Mallori Card.....

rofl
NIKOS A MAFIA

hmm....
Its quiet

Too quiet

I'd like to point this post out in particular.. She noting how quiet it is in the thread but in reality there has been 62 posts in the thread up to this point. While there were a few hours that no one really posted anything other than for her light banter I don't see anything of importance either. But its first day so I give people a break as first days are always difficult.

I just wanted to point out the possibility that he was trying to tell her something because if her pm box is full, they would not be able to communicate to find an off board communication site

Lets hope that made sense....

No, I dont think you understand what I was saying. How do they choose an offsite communication place without communicating through pm to choose it?

RL?

oh....yup, pretty much

POSSEDE!

lol, How have I been quiet? Im assuming you havent seen my gameplay in other games...

And for the record, I dont know what interplay is, so I will not defend myself for that

Realistically though she had been quiet about anything of importance in the game.. Nothing really helping the town in any way in her posts.

lol I typed in interplay, and I didnt get a definition, it just said Interplay:interplay

RBI killed the thread...

Again up to this point nothing really important in anything she is typing in the thread.

I vote to lynch Blue

Will explain when I get home

Note this vote.. Day one vote.. She said she would explain the reasoning for this vote when she got home.

oi, thats allota pages to read

Note no explanation or other comments other than this...

IM BACK

I vote to lynch blue

I havent gotten to read like the last ten pages cause ive been gone, but the begining of the game made me suspicious, she just seems sorta defensive, mighta just been me

Im going to read the rest and ill change it if I see something, I just didnt want like a computer problem or something and die a ud

Day 2 vote.. She votes Blue again - who ended up being an innocent.. But she still doesn't explain any reasoning for her voting.

lol rbishop needs to shut up, ive read all the pages now, and with time left
And I am changing my vote
I retract my vote for blue and vote to lynch niko
Something about him, he seems over-confident, like he wants to get mad, but he is trying to keep it calm to avoid attention, if you know what im talking about

I questioned her on that vote and wow.. she switched to Niko with only a light explanation.. Nothing substantial in this post either.

Oh gosh, thoughts about beth
Id have to look through again and get back to you on that, my mind can't concentrate on so many people

no, I said that I cannot concentrate on so many people, which means I saw something aobut blue and niko, so those were the people I was focasing on

I questioned her on Skimming.. (which I believe she's doing otherwise we should see something other than this fluff she's posting)

OUCH
That sparks
JM, you were a valuable player on our team, you will be missed

This might hurt me to say because of the suspicion on beth, but im gonna say it anyway. She just doesnt look mafia to me. I read all of her posts, and nothing screamed "MAFIAMAFIA!!"

lol, I seem innocent so I might be mafia, thats logical

Again I don't think she's an innocent at all.

lol, I work, I go to school, I do homework, I do chores
I dont have much time to really analyze the thread really hard like some of you
I have told you my thoughts, on multiple people
I am actually going to be a loner here, but I really dont like this brains guy.
He expects everyone to be on at every second posting every little thing that pops into their mind(not really, its an exgageration, but still)
Also, he came after a mafia was killed, do you think rbish would make him a mafia to even it back out(cause he is evil like that)
Anyways, im placing a vote now, because I have to work tomarrow, and im not sure what time I will get home
I vote to lynch brains

Now she votes me.. I have never expected people to post every little thing on their mind, but if you are indeed a member of the town I do expect more than what we have seen up to this point.

This is EVERY post she has placed into this thread. You decide townie or mafia?