Mafia #19 50/50

brains2 said:
For me I'm at a tie between lady and swade and then probably wes.. But then Lady and Swade are two very experienced players.. Wes could just be a newbie.. But like I've said by this point in the game I consider a newbie to have a grasp.. Then with his admission of reading a past game he should have more of a grasp.. Not a pro like ICE, but at least more helpful than he's been.

If I had to pick between swade and ladyg it would have to be the latter.. Just because I've had that feeling for quite some time that something isn't right about her play.
Click to expand...
I can't decide between G and Swayde either. G has been posting a lot of seemingly helpful thoughts, some of which we both agreed on. But lately her posts have had weird errors in them starting with her misreading the rules about the Mafia winning AFTER end of day 4 if they outnumber the innocents. That in itself didn't bother me much, but combined with a lot of other ones, raises the eyebrows. Swayde came at me full steam and didn't back down until you asked her to make a case on me then perhaps she didn't have time or she couldn't find anything on me then she switched her vote back to Andi. She has started to pick up on her postings but before I think she was the second lowest poster next to DC.
 
You know... I've just had a thought as well.. What if LadyG is the vocal mafia and Wes is the silent one of the communicating mafia team? I've gotta look at this.. Wes made a point of asking JMax if she had received the NC Townie investigation (which she answered both of his questions to the affirmative).. Then the following night JM was hit and LadyG was on her list. I think we need to go back to that period and start combing the thread.. This just makes to much sense now.. He got the positive confirmation on her being innocent which gave them the target to hit the following night so they didn't have to sacrifice one of their own.
 
plantling said:
I can't decide between G and Swayde either. G has been posting a lot of seemingly helpful thoughts, some of which we both agreed on. But lately her posts have had weird errors in them starting with her misreading the rules about the Mafia winning AFTER end of day 4 if they outnumber the innocents. That in itself didn't bother me much, but combined with a lot of other ones, raises the eyebrows. Swayde came at me full steam and didn't back down until you asked her to make a case on me then perhaps she didn't have time or she couldn't find anything on me then she switched her vote back to Andi. She has started to pick up on her postings but before I think she was the second lowest poster next to DC.
Click to expand...

I think what she has been posting has been a regurgitation of someone else's post. While I do agree that Andi and DC are probably mafia as well see the last post I just did... I'm thinking I'm onto something here.. I think it makes sense..
 
brains2 said:
I think what she has been posting has been a regurgitation of someone else's post. While I do agree that Andi and DC are probably mafia as well see the last post I just did... I'm thinking I'm onto something here.. I think it makes sense..
Click to expand...
At the very least it would be interesting to see what LG has to say about you and Niko's theories.
 
atnixon said:
Brains2 - Care to answer this for us??
Click to expand...

RB asked me to join the game, probably to just spice things up. It was inferred that I should post my views as a Townie, with no definition of alliances. Being a Townie of ACville, I feel I should give my honest opinion of what I see in the posts that are presented to us.
 
thru post #877...

to lynch....

andi (1) by swayde 813

Deputy (1) by plant 810

swayde (1) by wes 814

lady (2) by brains 864 niko 870

5 of 9 have voted....

No votes from lady, jl66, andi, and Deputy

Nightfall at 8 PM EST, Wednesday, 12/12...
 
brains2 said:
Wes made a point of asking JMax if she had received the NC Townie investigation (which she answered both of his questions to the affirmative).. Then the following night JM was hit and LadyG was on her list.
Click to expand...

In hindsight that was a dumb question for me to ask jm. I wasn't thinking forward enough to the mafia hit. It was just that she sounded so positive about DD that I asked the question, being completely clueless as to who was who. So far I've voted for two of the definite mafia lynchings with one oops vote for blue.

Mark
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom